2024 Volume 37 Issue 5
Article Contents

Chengxu Li, Shiyan Xiao, Haojun Liang. Effects of Fluorescent Pair on the Kinetics of DNA Strand Displacement Reaction[J]. Chinese Journal of Chemical Physics, 2024, 37(5): 679-684. doi: 10.1063/1674-0068/cjcp2302015
Citation: Chengxu Li, Shiyan Xiao, Haojun Liang. Effects of Fluorescent Pair on the Kinetics of DNA Strand Displacement Reaction[J]. Chinese Journal of Chemical Physics, 2024, 37(5): 679-684. doi: 10.1063/1674-0068/cjcp2302015

Effects of Fluorescent Pair on the Kinetics of DNA Strand Displacement Reaction

通讯作者: 陈斌, bchen63@163.com
  • 1. 

    沈阳化工大学材料科学与工程学院 沈阳 110142

  1. 本站搜索
  2. 百度学术搜索
  3. 万方数据库搜索
  4. CNKI搜索

Figures(4)

Article Metrics

Article views(274) PDF downloads(1) Cited by(0)

Access History

Effects of Fluorescent Pair on the Kinetics of DNA Strand Displacement Reaction

Abstract: Fluorescent labels are widely used in the characterizations of DNA-based reaction network operations. We systematically studied the effects of commonly used fluorescent pairs on thermal stabilities of signal-substrate duplex and the strand displacement kinetics. It is demonstrated that the modifications of duplex with fluorescent pairs stabilize DNA duplex by up to 3.5 °C, and the kinetics of DNA strand displacement circuit is also evidently slowed down. These results highlight the importance of fluorescent pairs towards the kinetic modulation in designing nucleic acid probes and complex DNA dynamic circuits.

    • DNA has been utilized as an ideal fundamental material to fulfill complicated functions, such as chemical reaction networks [1, 2], logical devices [3-5], biosensors [6-9], and even immune response systems [10, 11]. The realization of these diverse functions requires precise fine-tuning of the interactions among the components. Toehold-mediated strand displacement reaction (TMSDR) [12, 13], a process in which an invading strand binds to a sticky end named toehold of a DNA duplex and then replaces the incumbent strand via branch migration (BM), exhibits its extraordinary power as an effective programmable language for the design of dynamic DNA reaction networks [14, 15]. As the central role of TMSDR in the construction of DNA reaction networks, detailed characterizing of TMSDR progress is of great importance [16-20], which is also helpful to gain a better understanding of how the reaction networks operate.

      Fluorescent compounds that can transfer absorbed energy from dark to light have been widely exploited to monitor the kinetic progress of DNA strand displacement circuits [21-23]. Usually, a pair of fluorophore dye and quencher are attached to the same ends of two complementary DNA oligomers, and the fluorescence is quenched when they are close to each other. The TMSD reaction leads to the separation of fluorophore dye and quencher, and lights the fluorescence, which reports the processing of circuit operation [24, 25]. The fluorescent labels are also commonly modified to the ends that are close to toehold domain to detect the intermediate process of reaction circuit. The interactions of fluorescent labels between them and with nucleotides via π-π stacking and hydrogen bonding will inevitably affect the circuit kinetics. The previous works have proved that fluorescent groups can increase the melting temperature (Tm) of DNA duplex up to 4.3 °C [26, 27] and a single label close to toehold domain can modulate the kinetics of TMSDR by almost two orders of magnitude [28]. However, the effects of fluorescent pair on the TMSDR kinetics previously have been rarely studied. In the present work, we chose seven combinations of fluorophore dyes and quenchers, and studied how they affect the kinetics and thermodynamics of DNA circuits.

    II.   EXPERIMENTS
    • In this work, the DNA sequences were first optimized and designed by NUPACK [29] software to ensure that no secondary structure exists. The DNA oligonucleotides, either with or without fluorescent labels, were synthesized by Sangon Biotechnology Co., Ltd. (Shanghai, China). We used high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) to purify oligonucleotides with fluorescent labels, and ULTRAPAGE to purify unlabelled oligonucleotides. The nucleic acid stain used in DNA purification was 4S Red (purchased from Sangon, Shanghai, China). In experiments, buffer solution was set to 1×Tris-Acetate-EDTA-Mg2+ (known as 1×TAE/Mg2+, 40 mmol/L Tris-Acetate with 1 mmol/L EDTA and 12.5 mmol/L MgCl2, pH balanced to 8.4). The experimental water was ultrapure water (18.2 MΩ·cm) (Milli-Q Integral 5, Millipore Co., USA). The sequences in detail are displayed in Table S1 of Supplementary materials (SM).

    • The DNA duplexes (signal-substrate duplex and reporter-quencher duplex) were obtained by mixing complementary DNA oligonucleotides together with a concentration of 50 μmol/L. Next, we kept these duplex samples at 95 °C for 5 min, and then slowly cooled them down to room temperature at the rate of 1 °C/min. Double-stranded DNA samples were purified via 12% non-denaturing PAGE to remove undesired structures [23]. The extinction coefficients (e) of duplex samples were calculated using equation, e = etop strand + ebottom strand − 3200NAT − 2000NGC. The parameters NAT and NGC are referred to the numbers of AT pairs and GC pairs in DNA duplexes, respectively [30].

    • The measurements of TMSDR kinetics were recorded via fluorescence spectrophotometer (F-7000, Hitachi) at 25 °C. The excitation and emission of 6-FAM fluorophore were set to 492 and 520 nm, and those of Cy5 fluorophore were set to 643 and 667 nm. The widths of excitation and emission slits were both 5 nm. The experiment of each system was performed by three times to verify the accuracy.

    • We used Cary 300 UV-Vis (Agilent, USA) spectrophotometer to conduct UV melting experiments. The absorbance of duplex samples at 260 nm was recorded every 0.5 °C. The temperature was increased at the rate of 1 °C/min. The concentrations of labelled and unlabelled signal-substrate duplexes were 1 μmol/L.

    • The value of Tm and thermodynamic parameters were derived from the scatter graph fitted by logistic function [31]. The detailed description about the methods is given in SM.

    III.   RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
    • A two-step DNA strand displacement circuit was constructed to investigate the effects of different combinations of fluorophore dyes and quenchers close to toehold domain on the duplex thermodynamics and circuit kinetics (FIG. 1). As shown in FIG. 1, the invader activates the strand displacement reaction with a signal-substrate duplex (Sig-S) upon the assistance of the toehold domain a* in the first step, and releases the signal strand into the buffer solution. It should be mentioned that the lengths of invading and incumbent toehold were set to 5 bases and zero, respectively. Thus, the invading toehold initiates the strand displacement reaction between invader and Sig-S duplex, while the incumbent toehold of zero base strongly reduces the tendency of the reverse reaction, leading the reaction in the first layer to proceed in one direction. This design makes the first step a pure strand displacement reaction rather than a toehold exchange reaction. Then in the second step, the product strand Sig reacts with the reporter duplex in downstream reactions and releases the quencher strand, finally lighting the fluorescence. In this work, seven combinations of fluorophore dyes and quenchers were adopted to characterize their effects on the duplex thermal stabilities and the TMSDR kinetics, including 6-FAM/Dabcyl, 6-FAM/BHQ1, Alexa 488/Dabcyl, Alexa 488/BHQ1, Texas red/BHQ2, Cy3/BHQ2, and Cy5/BHQ2. These labels were modified on the 5′ end of signal strand and 3′ end of substrate strand. Considering that the excitation or emission spectrum of labelled fluorophore dyes or quenchers on the 5′ end of signal strand might overlap with the reporter system and affect the characterization of kinetic progress, we designed two kinds of reporter systems, R1 and R2, which have little interference with each other. The reporter system R1 consists of 6-FAM and Dabcyl, and reporter system R2 consists of Cy5 and BHQ2. We used an unmodified signal strand to trigger these two reporter systems, and the kinetic curves (FIG. S1 in SM) show that R1 and R2 have the same dynamic trend. This result demonstrates the reliability of the kinetic curves measured by R1 and R2, and the fluorescent curves can represent the strand displacement reaction in the first step of the designed circuit in FIG. 1.

    • Firstly, we studied the situation that fluorophore dyes (6-FAM, Alexa 488, Texas red, Cy3, and Cy5) were labelled at the 5′ end of signal strand, and quenchers (Dabcyl, BHQ1 and BHQ2) were labelled at the 3' end of substrate strand. The kinetic curves displayed in FIG. 2(A) show that different combinations of fluorophore dyes and quenchers exhibit diverse effects on the kinetic progress of TMSDR. When we modified the fluorophore dye 6-FAM or Alexa 488 on the 5′ end of signal strand and its corresponding quencher Dabcyl or BHQ1 at the 3′ end of substrate strand, the systems present faster kinetics than that in native format with no labelling. However, when the labels were Texas red, Cy3, Cy5, and their corresponding quencher BHQ2, the kinetics of these systems are significantly slowed down. We find that the effects of dual-labelled DNA duplex on the kinetics of TMSDR mainly depend on the label attached at the 5′ end of signal strand. These results are significantly different from our previous work, that is, attaching a single fluorescent label to the 5′ end of signal strand slows down the kinetics of strand displacement reaction while that on the 3′ end of substrate strand accelerates the kinetics [28]. The introduction of 6-FAM or Alexa 488 at the 5′ end of signal strand has little impact on TMSDR kinetics, thus, the acceleration brought by Dabcyl or BHQ1 being labelled at the 3′ end of substrate strand eventually emerges. However, when Texas red, Cy3 and Cy5, were tagged at the 5′ end of signal strand, the strong hindrance brought by them will slow down the circuit kinetics and even cover up the acceleration of BHQ2 at the 3′ end of substrate strand, and finally result in the deceleration of the reaction kinetics.

      When we modified the quenchers at the 5′ end of signal strand and the fluorophore dyes at the 3′ end of substrate strand (FIG. 2(B)), the kinetic curves differ slightly but still exhibit a similar trend. As shown in FIG. 2(B), for the systems with 6-FAM or Alexa 488 at the 3′ end of substrate strand, the presupposed strong enhancement of TMSDR kinetics is counteracted by the suppression of quenchers on the 5′ end of signal strand, presenting no significant change in circuit kinetics. However, when we modified Texas red, Cy3 or Cy5 on the 3′ end of substrate strand, the weak acceleration brought by these fluorescent labels is offset by the inhibition of BHQ2 on the 5′ end of signal strand, causing the dynamic processes of these systems being significantly reduced compared with the native signal-substrate duplex. These results suggest that for dual-labelled signal-substrate with a pair of fluorophore dye and quencher close to toehold domain, although the fluorescent label tagged on the 3′ end of substrate strand has the ability to enhance the kinetics of the circuit, the suppression of the label on the 5′ end of signal strand plays a dominant role.

    • Molecular dynamics simulation is a good method to understand the TMSDR mechanism at atomistic levels, and to calculate the thermodynamic properties of DNA strand before and after the strand displacement reaction. However, currently there are no suitable coarse-grained parameters for the fluorescent labels. Besides, TMSDR is a process of long path from the start point to the final state and large-scale conformational changes, which is currently difficult to be reached using normal coarse-grained molecular dynamics simulations. Although we cannot precisely calculate how these labels interact with each other and with the toehold domain via molecular dynamics simulation, the change of the kinetic process will inevitably be reflected in the variation of thermal stabilities of these dual-labelled duplexes. Melting temperature (Tm) can be used as a measurement of the stabilities of these duplexes and we can experimentally calculate their thermodynamic properties via Tm by using formula in SM. Thus, we measured the melting curves of different combinations of dual-labelled and unlabelled signal-substrate duplexes (FIG. S2 in SM) to obtain their melting temperatures, and then derived their thermodynamic properties (FIG. 3 and FIG. 4).

      For the systems with dual-label close to toehold domain accelerating the TMSDR kinetics (the red, orange, and yellow lines in FIG. 2), the pair of fluorophore dye and quencher at the toehold end has little effect on Tm of signal-substrate duplexes and even reduces Tm in some cases (FIG. 3). The weakened thermal stabilities of signal-substrate duplexes refer to the easier hybridization of invader strand with toehold domain, leading to the acceleration of circuit kinetics and somehow reducing the binding free energy (FIG. 4). By contrast, the higher Tm of dual-labelled signal-substrate duplexes corresponds to stronger thermal stabilities. As shown in FIG. 3, the combinations of Texas red/BHQ2, Cy3/BHQ2, and Cy5/BHQ2 can evidently increase the Tm of signal-substrate duplex up to 3.5 °C. The strong binding strength of signal-substrate duplex makes it difficult for the invader strand to replace the signal strand from the duplex, ultimately slowing down the circuit kinetics. These results are in accordance with the kinetic curves in FIG. 2 (blue, green, and light green lines). Our experiments prove that the thermodynamic properties of dual-labelled signal-substrate duplexes are significantly different from that of single-labelled signal-substrate duplexes, resulting in a prominent variation in their effects on the thermal stabilities of DNA duplexes and the kinetics of DNA strand displacement reaction.

    IV.   CONCLUSION
    • By modifying fluorescent labels on both the 5′ end of the signal strand and 3′ end of the substrate strand, the kinetics of DNA strand displacement circuit can be evidently modulated. In this present work, seven combinations of fluorophore dyes and their quenchers were adopted to study the effects of fluorescent pair on the TMSDR kinetics. When the signal-substrate duplex is modified by a fluorescent pair, the change of circuit kinetics is mainly determined by the fluorescent label being attached to the 5′ end of signal strand. We find that even though the kinetic curves differ slightly for the diverse combinations of fluorophore dyes and quenchers, they indeed exhibit a similar trend. That is, when the end modification of signal strand has little effect on the TMSDR kinetics, the overall effect of the dual-label combination is mainly determined by that being tagged on the toehold domain at the 3′ end of substrate. By contrast, when the end modification of signal strand has a strong hindrance on the kinetics of TMSDR, the acceleration introduced by its corresponding label on the toehold domain will be concealed, eventually causing the slowing-down of circuit kinetics. We have characterized the contributions of various combinations of dual-label on the melting temperatures and thermodynamic properties of signal-substrate duplex. These results suggest that the DNA circuit with slower kinetics corresponds to higher Tm and stronger binding energy of signal-substrate duplex.

      Our work demonstrates that the kinetics of DNA circuit and thermodynamic properties of dual-labelled signal-substrate duplex by attaching fluorescent labels to toehold domain end are quite different compared with the situation of single-labelled signal-substrate duplex, and the effects of the labels on the 5′ end of signal strand play a dominant role in determining the TMSDR circuit. We therefore suggest that the labels appearing at the 5′ end of signal strand close to the toehold domain should be carefully designed in the construction of the DNA circuits in order to reduce the effects of fluorescent labels on the TMSDR kinetics.

      Supplementary materials: The figures of reporter kinetics and UV melting profile, and detailed descriptions about the calculations of melting temperatures and thermodynamic properties from the UV melting curvres of DNA duplexes are given.

    Figure (4)  Reference (31)

Catalog

    /

    DownLoad:  Full-Size Img  PowerPoint
    Return
    Return