2025 Volume 38 Issue 6
Article Contents

Zheng Sun, Hongjun Fan. Theoretical Studies on Stability of Oxygen-Evolving Center Model Complex Mn4CaO4 in Oxidative Condition[J]. Chinese Journal of Chemical Physics, 2025, 38(6): 893-906. doi: 10.1063/1674-0068/cjcp2403034
Citation: Zheng Sun, Hongjun Fan. Theoretical Studies on Stability of Oxygen-Evolving Center Model Complex Mn4CaO4 in Oxidative Condition[J]. Chinese Journal of Chemical Physics, 2025, 38(6): 893-906. doi: 10.1063/1674-0068/cjcp2403034

Theoretical Studies on Stability of Oxygen-Evolving Center Model Complex Mn4CaO4 in Oxidative Condition

  • Corresponding author: E-mail: fanhj@dicp.ac.cn
  • Received Date: 12/03/2024
    Available Online: 27/12/2025
通讯作者: 陈斌, bchen63@163.com
  • 1. 

    沈阳化工大学材料科学与工程学院 沈阳 110142

  1. 本站搜索
  2. 百度学术搜索
  3. 万方数据库搜索
  4. CNKI搜索

Figures(11)  /  Tables(1)

Article Metrics

Article views(112) PDF downloads(0) Cited by(0)

Access History

Theoretical Studies on Stability of Oxygen-Evolving Center Model Complex Mn4CaO4 in Oxidative Condition

Abstract: The photosynthetic oxygen-evolving center (OEC) is a unique Mn4CaO5 cluster catalyzing the water oxidation into electrons, protons and O2 through a five-intermediate state cycle (Sn, n=0, 1, 2, 3, 4). The modeling of OEC is essential for understanding the water oxidation mechanism and developing high efficient water oxidation catalysts. Recently, a series of Mn4CaO4 model complexes have been synthesized, which have very similar structures to OEC and also show reactivity of water oxidation. In this work, we employed DFT method to investigate the stability of Mn4CaO4 model complex in oxidative conditions, aiming to figure out whether it decomposes itself to release O2 during the catalytic water oxidation process. We discovered that the barrier for the O−O bond formation is quite high in the S1 and S2 states, while decreases to 40.2 kcal/mol in the S3 state, indicating the good stability in all oxidation states under normal conditions. Acetonitrile and pyridine can effectively reduce the barrier to 36.5 kcal/mol and 29.9 kcal/mol, respectively. Therefore, strong Lewis base, such as pyridine, could be harmful to the stability of Mn4CaO4 and shall be avoided when designing such a catalytic system. Once the O−O bond is formed, Mn4CaO4 in the S3 state can readily decompose to O2, solvated Ca2+ and Mn4O2 complex, with the assistance of acetonitrile or pyridine. As a comparison, the O2 decomposition in the S2 state is kinetically hindered and thermodynamically disfavored. The S4 state Mn4CaO4 has a much lower barrier for O–O bond formation, and is unstable. However, the S4 state Mn4CaO4 is difficult to achieve under water oxidation condition, as evidenced by the calculated redox potential of 2.3 V for S3→S4 transition.

    • The unique function of oxygen release by higher plants and algae comes from the oxygen evolution center (OEC) in photosystem II (PSII), which is one of the most important reactions in maintaining the biosphere cycle [1−3]. The OEC is a Mn4CaO5 cubane complex, which achieves oxygen formation by storing four equivalents of electrons in a continuous oxidation step (called S0→S4) from two water molecules transported from the ligand environment [4]. In each oxidation step, the electrons accumulated in Mn in OEC are externally transferred to P680+ through TyrZ (redox tyrosine group) near Ca2+ and the protons are transported to the luminal side through the surrounding hydrogen bond network [5, 6]. In the most widely accepted O5 mechanism, the O−O bond is formed by O5 of the cubane and O of the water in S4 state, which was recently supported by Bhowmick et al.’s X-ray free-electron lasers (XFEL) experiment [7] and Greife et al.’s Fourier transform infrared spectrometer (FTIR) experiment [8]. Certainly, the detailed mechanism for water oxidation is still in debate, and other possible mechanisms have also been well studied [9, 10].

      Simulating the structure and function of natural OEC has attracted great attention, especially after high resolution X-ray structure of the OEC was reported by Shen et al. in 2011 [11]. Agapie et al. synthesized the Mn3CaO4 complex which is similar to the cubane structure of OEC in 2011 [12], and later on a series of Mn3MO4 complexes with the Ca2+ replaced by other metals [13] have been reported. The electronic structure and electrochemical properties of these complexes have been studied as well, and spin changes have been observed in S2→S3 transition by X-ray absorption spectroscopy (XAS) characterization [14, 15]. However, all these structures lack the fourth Mn, and their redox potential is far from that of OEC. Most importantly, these complexes do not have water oxidation activity. In 2015, Zhang et al. reported the Mn4CaO4 (FIG. 1) complex [16], which is the closest model to OEC in structure and function so far. This compound well simulates all Mn in OEC with only one μ2-O missing. The oxidation states of the four Mn centers are (III, III, IV, IV), which correspond to the S1 state of OEC, and the redox potential of the S1→S2 transition process in acetonitrile is 0.90 V, which is also very close to the value of OEC as well. Furthermore, it does have the water oxidation activity. Later on, Zhang et al. synthesized Mn4YO4, Mn4GdO4 [17] complexes with the Ca2+ replaced by Y and Gd. The experimental oxidation potentials of these complex are pretty similar to that of Mn4CaO4, which supports our theoretical results that the redox inactive Ca2+ does not strongly modulate the redox potential [18, 19]. In 2022, Zhang et al. reported (Mn3LaO4)2O and (Mn3SrO4)2O complexes which contain the missing μ2-O, and experimental evidence suggests that this μ2-O could induce oxidation and reduction [20]. Very recently, Zhang et al. synthesized the Mn3Ce2O5 complex which shows good activity for water oxidation [21].

      These advancements have greatly improved the understanding of the structure, reactivity, and mechanism of OEC. However, the stability of the model complex, especially under the water oxidation condition, has strongly limited further studies. Most complexes are not stable enough when water is present. In the case of Mn4CaO4, the water oxidation experiment is carried out with only less than 1% water, and Liao’s calculation shows that it takes a little bit of energy to insert five water molecules into the cluster [6]. Even in CH2Cl2 and CH3CN solvents without any water, the cyclic voltammetry (CV) curve only exhibits both redox and oxidation peaks at S1 and S2 states, while only one peak can be observed for other states, which suggests possibly irreversible structural transformation occurs [16].

      Therefore, in this work we carried out theoretical studies to investigate the stability of the Mn4CaO4 model complex in oxidative conditions, aiming to understand whether the complex decomposes spontaneously when it catalyzes water oxidation. We focus on the decomposition accompanied by O2 evolution, because: (1) many manganese oxide complexes with highly oxidized Mn are catalyst for O2 evolution, or can decompose to release O2; (2) mechanistic study shows that the bridging oxygen is involved in O2 formation during the water oxidation, while the other part of the cluster is maintained in the S0–S4 cycle; (3) in 2017, Zhang reported a model complex Mn4O2 [22] which has a similar synthetic condition and similar ligand environments to Mn4CaO4, and is likely the decomposition product of S3 state of Mn4CaO4 resulting from the release of O2 and Ca2+. We will study mechanisms by which Mn4CaO4 decomposes to release O2 when water is not involved, and how the solvent and Lewis bases can modulate the decomposition.

    II.   THEORETICAL METHOD AND MODEL
    • Gaussian 16 [23] was used to carry out all calculations in this work. Geometric optimization was carried out on B3LYP* (Becke’s three parameter hybrid functional) level [24], with DFT-D3 dispersion corrections [25, 26]. B3LYP* is B3LYP with the HF exchange reduced to 15%, and Siegbahn et al. have shown that BLYP with 15%−20% Hartree-Fock (HF) exchange is the best in the energy calculation of OEC complexes. Siegbahn et al. and Fan et al. also proved that B3LYP-D3 and BLYP*-D3 well reproduced the energy, structure and redox potential of OEC model complexes [6, 27]. For O, N, C, and H atoms, the 6-31G(d,p) basis sets were chosen, while for metal atoms (Mn and Ca) we used Stuttgart/Dresden effective core potential basis set (SDD) pseudo-potential basis sets [28]. The vibrational calculations were carried out at the same level to verify the local minimum and transition states, as well as to derive the free energies. At the optimized structure, a single point energy calculation and solvation energy calculation were carried out at the B3LYP*-D3 level, with SDD for metal atoms and 6-311+G(2d,2p) for other atoms. The solvation energy was calculated using polarizable-continuum model (PCM) continuous solvation model [29] and acetonitrile solvent (ε = 35.7). For all species, the concentration correction of 1.9 kcal/mol was added to the calculated free energy, which is derived from the free energy change of 1 atm (the condition for free energy calculation, which equals to 24.5 L/mol at 298.15 K) to 1 mol/L (standard condition in solution). Specifically, acetonitrile is the solvent, and its concentration in pure liquid acetonitrile, 19.1 mol/L, is used in the concentration correction. For the calculation of the redox potentials, the experimental absolute redox potential of the standard hydrogen electrode (SHE, 4.52 V) in acetonitrile was used as a reference [30], which corresponds to electron affinity of 104.2 kcal/mol.

      The structural model used in the calculation is the simplified structure of the Mn4CaO4 complex, specifically, utilizing the methyl group to replace the tert-butyl group on the carboxylic acid. Using full model as the reference, the error of the simplified model on the oxidation potential of S0→S1, S1→S2, and S2→S3 are 0.08 V, 0.19 V, and 0.02 V, respectively. The optimized core structures are also highly similar, suggesting that the simplified model is able to reproduce the properties of the full model pretty well.

      The redox potential of S2→S3 transition for Mn4CaO4 is 1.25 V in pure acetonitrile and dichloroethane [16], and S3→S4 transition has not been observed in cyclic voltammogram under 1.6 V. According to Liao et al.’s theoretical calculation, water oxidation could be facile at the applied potential of 1.3 – 1.7 V [6], and our calculated results show that the redox potential for S3→S4 transition is 2.3 V. These results suggest that although Mn4CaO4 can catalyze water oxidation through S0→S4 cycle under ~1.7 V (it is the water inserted Mn4CaO4 that has been oxidized to S4), the complex itself cannot reach S4 state at the water oxidation condition. In this work, we are investigating the stability of the Mn4CaO4 itself, therefore we will focus on the decomposition in S1→S3 states, while only discussing the S4 state briefly in the later. Notably, our calculation shows that S1→S2 and S2→S3 transitions follow electron transfer (ET) mechanism, while S3→S4 transition follows proton coupled and electron transfer (PCET) mechanism.

    III.   MECHANISM OF O–O BOND FORMATION IN Mn4CaO4
    • Mechanistic study shows that the bridging oxygen is involved in the redox cycle, including O2 oxidation and the formation of O−O bonds between oxygen in water and bridging oxygen [31−34]. There are four bridging oxygen (O1, O2, O3, O4) in Mn4CaO4, which can form six different O−O bonds. The optimized structures and their relative energies for these isomers in S3 state (where all Mn ions are in the +4 oxidation state) are shown in FIG. 2. It shows that the O−O bond between O1 and O2 (ISO1) is the most stable, followed by the O−O bond between O3 and O4 (ISO2) which is 5.1 kcal/mol higher in free energy. The O1 and O2 are both μ3-O between Mn and Ca2+, while O3 and O4 are μ3-O which are farther from Ca2+. Other O−O bonds are much more unstable, with relative energies of >10.0 kcal/mol (ISO3−ISO6). We propose that this is because the distance between O1 and O2 is short (2.50 Å), furthermore, the bond between bridging oxygen and Ca2+ is weaker and easier to be activated. Since the O−O bond between O1 and O2 is much better than those between other bridging oxygen, in the later we will focus on decomposition mechanism of S1−S3 states which are associated with the O1−O2 bond. Concerning on S4 state, our calculation shows that in the absence of water, the S3→S4 transition is a PCET oxidation with the redox potential of 2.4 V. The oxidation states of all Mn ions are +4, together with one electron oxidation occurring on the carboxylate ligands. This is in agreement with the results of Siegbahn et al. that the S4 state with one Mn(V) is higher in free energy than that with four Mn(IV) and one unpaired electron on the ligand [35, 36].

      In Table I, we summarize the distance between Ca2+ and the bridging O, Mn ions and bridging O, as well as the O1−O2 bond length in the S0, S1, S2 and S3 states. The results show that as the oxidation state increases from S0 to S3, the distance between Ca2+ and the bridging O becomes longer, accompanied by the decrease of the O−O, Mn1−O, and Mn3−O distances. These structural parameters suggest weaker binding between Ca2+ and Mn4O4 parts, and easier O−O bond formation in higher oxidation states. In addition, the Mn2−O and Mn4−O distances do not change significantly with the oxidation state.

    • Firstly, we study the mechanism of O–O bond formation in S3 state at high spin state (FIG. 3(A)). The initial state is S=13 (S3-13, FIG. 4(A)) in which the oxidation states of the four Mn ions are (IV, IV, IV, IV). When the O–O bond is formed, the ground state is S=15. The Mn1 and Mn2 are reduced, and the oxidation state of the four Mn ions changes to (IV, III, IV, IV). The mechanism of O–O bond formation in S3 state is studied by scanning the O–O distances and locating the transition states, and the results are shown in FIG. 3(A), FIG. 4 and FIG. 5. Along with the decreasing of the O1−O2 distance, the α spin density on Mn2 increases, and the β spin density on O1 and O2 increases, indicating an electron migrates from O1 and O2 to Mn2. S3-13a (FIG. 4(B)) is then the product of one electron reduction of Mn2. During this stage, the free energy increases continuously, and the distances of Mn2–O1 and Mn2−O2 increase to 2.06 Å and 2.11 Å, respectively. When the O−O distance is decreased further, the second electron transfer occurs to get S3-13b (FIG. 4(C)). It is the β electron transfer from O1 and O2 to Mn3, indicating the reduction of Mn3. The transition state S3-TS is shown in FIG. 4(D), with the calculated barrier of 43.6 kcal/mol (ΔG, and the same for below unless specified) and the O−O distance of 1.65 Å. Therefore, at the S=13, the O−O bond formation undergoes stepwise electron transfer from O1/O2 to Mn2 and Mn3. S3-13b has a low spin Mn3 center, and is quite high in free energy (41.2 kcal/mol). It undergoes spin flipping to get S3-15 (FIG. 4(E)) with the free energy of 28.6 kcal/mol, then undergoes electron transfer from Mn3 to Mn1 to reach the lowest electronic state S3-15a (26.9 kcal/mol, FIG. 4(F)). Later on, we call this mechanism as stepwise ET mechanism.

      For Mn4CaO4 in S3 state, S=15 spin state is much higher in free energy than S=13 spin state. However, as the decrease of O–O bond and reduction of the Mn ions, the free energy of S=15 decreases while that of S=13 increases. Therefore, another mechanism is that the spin crosses from S=13 to S=15 once S=15 becomes more stable than S=13. We found this occurs after the first electron reduction to reach S3-13a, and one β electrons on O1 and O2 flips to reach S=15.Then one α electron transfers to Mn1 to reach the lowest S=15 state S3-15a (26.9 kcal/mol) without notable barrier. The spin crossover occurs at O−O distance of 1.74 Å, and the calculated barrier is 40.2 kcal/mol, which is lower than the stepwise pathway that forms O−O bond before spin flipping. We call this mechanism as spin crossover mechanism. Although this spin crossover pathway is the best way to form O−O bond, the barrier of 40.2 kcal/mol indicates that the O−O bond can hardly be formed in S3 state of Mn4CaO4 without the help of other reagents. The electron transfer during the O−O bond formation is shown in FIG. 5.

      The O−O formation in S2 and S1 states has been studied using the similar method, and the results are shown in FIG. 3 (B) and (C). As with S3, we have located two pathways, the stepwise ET pathway and the spin crossover pathway, for the O–O formation in S2 and S1 states. Both pathways started with the Mn2 reduction to get S2-14a and S1-15a, respectively. In this step, one α electron transfers from O1 and O2 to Mn2 without notable barrier. Then in the stepwise ET pathway, the next step is the Mn3 reduction to reach S2-14b and S1-15b, respectively. For S2 state, the barrier is 48.4 kcal/mol, and the O−O bond length is 1.65 Å in the transition state (S2-TS). While for S1 state the barrier is 53.1 kcal/mol, and O–O bond length is 1.64 Å in the transition state (S1-TS). S2-14b and S1-15b have low spin Mn3 center, they undergo spin flipping and electron transfer (for S2-14b) from Mn3 to Mn1 to reach the lowest electronic state S2-16a and S1-17a. In the spin crossover mechanisms S2-14a and S1-15a undergo spin crossover to reach S=16 and S=17 states, respectively, followed by electron transfer to Mn ions (Mn1 for S2 and Mn3 for S1) to reach the lowest electron state S2-16a and S1-17a directly. The crossover occurs at r(O−O)=1.74 Å for S2 state and 1.75 Å for S1 state, with barriers of 43.0 and 48.5 kcal/mol, respectively. Therefore, the spin crossover pathway is the best pathway to form O−O bond for both S2 and S1 states.

      We also explored the O–O formation in S4 state (FIG. S1 and FIG. S2 in Supplementary materials, SM). Unlike that for S0→S3 transition, where the oxidation takes place at the the Mn ions, for S3→S4 transition the oxidation occurs on the ligands. The calculated pKa of S4 Mn4CaO4 is −11.2, associated with the deprotonation of one pivalic acid ligand on Ca2+. This implies that a PCET mechanism is preferred for S3→S4 transition, leading to the S4 state with one pivalate radical ligand coordinated to Ca2+. The S=12 state and S=14 state, in which the unpaired electron on pivalate radical and Mn ions are ferromagnetic coupling and antiferromagnetic coupling, respectively, are close in free energy. The highly active pivalate radical at S=14 state then oxidizes one bridging O to form the peroxypivalate with O–O bond. The barrier is only 9.4 kcal/mol which is much lower than that of S3 state, suggesting that Mn4CaO4 in S4 state is unstable at normal condition. However, as discussed above, the S4 state Mn4CaO4 can hardly be reached in the water oxidation condition.

      In total, the best pathway to form O–O bond in S3, S2 and S1 states is the spin crossover pathway which follows the Mn2 reduction, spin crossover, and Mn1 reduction (in S1 state the last step is the Mn3 reduction). As for S4, the reduction of Mn3 occurs in the second part of the process. The barrier heights are 48.5, 43.0, 40.2 and 11.5 kcal/mol for S1, S2, S3 and S4 state, respectively, indicating that the O–O bond is easier to form in the higher oxidation state of Mn4CaO4. On the other hand, all barriers are pretty high, which suggests that Mn4CaO4 can hardly decompose to O2 without the help of other reagents. S4 state Mn4CaO4 is unstable with much lower O–O formation barrier, but it is hard to be formed in anhydrous environment.

    • In the above discussion, we demonstrate that the O−O bond formation has rather high barriers. Together with the O–O bond formation, the r(Ca−O4) and r(Mn2–O2) increases from 3.01 Å to 3.83 Å and from 1.85 Å to 2.36 Å, respectively, indicating that the dative bond of Ca2+ and Mn2 is weakened. Therefore, we think that an additional dative bond on Ca2+ and Mn2 could be helpful for the O–O bond formation. Furthermore, the possible product for O2 decomposition, Mn4O2, indeed has a pyridine ligand on Mn2. Since acetonitrile solvent is widely used in the synthesis of Mn4CaO4, and acetonitrile is a weak Lewis base that can coordinate to Ca2+ and Mn2, we first investigate the O−O bond formation with the help of acetonitrile.

      The geometric optimization shows that it costs 1.6 and 2.2 kcal/mol for the Ca2+ in S2 (FIG. 6(C)) and S3 (FIG. 6(D)) states to coordinate additional acetonitrile molecule, respectively, while Ca2+ in S1 state cannot coordinate additional acetonitrile. The easier coordination in S3 state is in line with its higher net charges. The coordination on Mn2 is much harder, and for S3 state the ΔG increases 29.5 kcal/mol when one acetonitrile coordinates to Mn2 (FIG. 6(E)), however, the value is still lower than the barrier for the O−O bond formation (40.2 kcal/mol).

      We have studied the mechanism of O−O bond formation in S3 state Mn4CaO4 in which Ca2+ and Mn2 are coordinated by one acetonitrile, and the results are shown in FIG. 3(D), FIG. 7 and FIG. S3 (SM). It shows that the O−O bond formation follows the similar pathways to those without acetonitrile. Although it costs 29.5 kcal/mol to coordinate the acetonitrile, the barriers for all pathways are actually decreased, indicating the acetonitrile coordination is helpful for O−O bond formation. Specifically, in the spin crossover pathway, it costs 21.8 kcal/mol to produce S3-15a-MeCN (FIG. 7(A)), with the barrier of 36.5 kcal/mol and O–O bond length of 1.74 Å. In the stepwise ET pathway, it cost 35.9 kcal/mol to get S3-13b-MeCN (FIG. 7(B)), with the barrier of 38.0 kcal/mol (S3-TS-MeCN, FIG. 7(C)) and O−O bond length of 1.66 Å. In comparison, as mentioned above, the barriers for the two pathways are 40.2 and 43.6 kcal/mol, respectively, when acetonitrile is absent (FIG. 3(A)). We have also studied the O−O bond formation in S2 state Mn4CaO4 in which Ca2+ and Mn2 were coordinated by one acetonitrile (FIG. 3(E), and FIG. S4 (SM)), the barrier also decreases for both pathways, however, to a less extent than that in S3 state.

      Although the barrier for O−O bond formation decreases when acetonitrile is coordinated to Ca2+ and Mn2, the barrier is still as high as 36.5 kcal/mol in S3 state, which indicates that Mn4CaO4 in S1 to S3 state still has good stability in acetonitrile solution at normal condition. Next, we consider the O−O bond formation in which Mn2 is coordinated by pyridine (Ca2+ is coordinated by one acetonitrile either). Pyridine is a stronger Lewis base, and it was chosen because: (a) pyridine is a ligand of Mn4CaO4 that coordinates to Mn4, (b) possible product for O2 decomposition, Mn4O2, have a pyridine ligand on Mn2. The results are shown in FIG. 3 (F) and (G).

      It shows that pyridine is a better choice than acetonitrile for coordinating to Mn2, with ΔG of 24.6 kcal/mol to obtain S3-13-py (FIG. 6(F)). Notably, the barrier for O−O formation in S3 state decreases significantly when pyridine is introduced (FIG. 3(F)). In the spin crossover pathway, the barrier decreases from 40.2 kcal/mol to 29.9 kcal/mol. The S=15 product, S3-15a-py (FIG. 7(D)), is lower in free energy than S3-15a by 18.6 kcal/mol. The O–O bond at the crossover is 1.80 Å which is slightly longer that without pyridine. For the stepwise ET pathway to get S3-13b-py (FIG. 7(E)), the barrier decreases from 43.6 kcal/mol to 33.5 kcal/mol, and the O–O bond length in the transition state is 1.66 Å (S3-TS-py, FIG. 7(F)) which is similar to that without pyridine. We also studied the O−O bond formation at S2 state (FIG. 3(G)), and the changing trend is similar to that for S3 state. The barrier for O−O bond formation is significantly reduced with the introduction of the pyridine ligand. Specifically, the barrier for the spin crossover pathway decreases from 42.6 kcal/mol to 37.8 kcal/mol, while the barrier for stepwise ET pathway decreases from 48.4 kcal/mol to 41.3 kcal/mol.

      These results demonstrate that the barrier for O−O bond formation can be notably reduced by introducing a relatively stronger Lewis base to coordinate with Mn2. Notably, with pyridine, the barrier drops below 30 kcal/mol in S3 state, indicating that Mn4CaO4 in S3 state could potentially decompose and release O2 under normal condition in the presence of pyridine or other strong Lewis bases, while the S2 state remains stable.

    • The Mn center in Mn4CaO4 strongly prefers to high spin state, but the high spin Mn center can form low spin Mn4CaO4 through antiferromagnetic coupling. This type of low spin states is close in free energy with the high spin state, thus providing alternative pathways to form O–O bond. We have studied the O−O formation in S3 state with S=7, in the case of the Mn2 coordinated by one pyridine molecule (FIG. 8). There are four different electronic structures, S3-7a-py to S3-7d-py (FIG. S5 in SM), for S=7 spin state, which is featured by the spin of (βααα), (αβαα), (ααβα) and (αααβ) for the four Mn ions, respectively. Among them, S3-7d-Py is the most stable one and has the shortest O–O bond, while other three isomers can have stepwise ET mechanism which does not involve structures with low spin Mn center. Therefore we focus on S3-7a-Py and S3-7d-Py to study the mechanism of O−O bond formation.

      However, as shown in FIG. 8 and FIG. S6 (SM), we found that S3-7a-py actually prefers similar stepwise ET mechanism to that in high spin state. S3-7a1 (FIG. S5(C) in SM, ΔG=24.4 kcal/mol), which has low spin Mn center, is formed with the barrier of 36.5 kcal/mol and transition state of S3-7a-TS (FIG. S5(D) in SM). It undergoes electron transfer from Mn3 to Mn1 to reach S3-7a2 (FIG. S5(E) in SM, ΔG=7.2 kcal/mol). As the comparison, the barrier for the spin crossover mechanism of S3-7d-Py to get S3-9d1 (FIG. S5(F) in SM) is only 29.3 kcal/mol, and is the best pathway for O–O bond formation at S=7 spin state. The barrier is actually slightly lower than that of high spin state S3-13-py (29.9 kcal/mol). The O–O bond length for crossover is 1.78 Å, which is also pretty similar to that for S3-13-py (1.80 Å). Therefore, the O–O bond can be formed in both high spin and low spin states of Mn4CaO4 in S3 state, with comparable barriers, and in both cases, the spin crossover path is preferred. It should be noted that the discussion here focuses on the O–O bond formation between O1 and O2. In water oxidation, these two oxygen atoms are not involved in the O2 formation, therefore our results cannot be directly applied to water oxidation.

    IV.   DECOMPOSITION AND TRANSFORMATION OF Mn4CaO4 AFTER O–O BOND FORMATION
    • As discussed above, the O–O bond formation at the S3 state of Mn4CaO4 is below 30 kcal/mol when pyridine is involved, which indicates possible O−O bond formation at normal or under slight heating conditions. In this section, we focus on the decomposition and transformation following the O−O bond formation. There are two possible pathways. In path 1 the Ca2+ leaves Mn4O4 first, followed by the O2 formation and dissociation. In path 2 the O2 formation and dissociation occurs before the Ca2+ leaves. Former studies have shown that the Ca2+ is able to stabilize the cubane structure at high oxidation state [37−41], furthermore, when the Ca2+ is present, the O2 dissociation will introduce a few unsaturated Mn and Ca2+ centers. Thus, we think path 1 sounds more reasonable. The leaving of Ca2+ could be facilitated by the continuous coordination of acetonitrile molecules (the solvent).

      We still focus on the high spin S3 state with Mn2 coordinated by one pyridine (FIG. 9). As shown above, the O1−O2 bond formation yields S3-15-py in which the O−O motif is peroxide. We found it can isomerize to the superoxide through electron transfer from the O−O bond to Mn3. There are two types of superoxide, S3-15b-py (S=15, FIG. 10(A)) in which the O2− has different spin from the Mn ions, and S3-17a-py (S=17) in which O2− has the same spin as the Mn ions. The superoxide S3-15b-py is the most stable one and is lower in free energy than S3-15a-py by 1.7 kcal/mol and S3-17a-py by 3.2 kcal/mol. Then we studied the coordination of acetonitrile on the Ca2+. Damon et al. have shown that there are six water molecules at the first coordination shell of Ca2+ in water solvent [42]. Alexis et al.’s calculations also demonstrated that the Ca2+ coordinated by six water molecules is the most stable [43]. In order to study the solvation of Ca2+ in acetonitrile solvent, we have calculated the stability of different solvated Ca2+ species, and found that the Ca2+ coordinated by 7 acetonitrile ligands is the most stable. Since in our model, the Ca2+ is already coordinated by 2 pivalic acid and 1 acetonitrile ligands, we speculate that the Ca2+ could coordinate with 4 more acetonitrile ligands.

      We then coordinate 1–4 acetonitrile ligands to Ca2+ in S3 state of Mn4CaO4. The free energy changes are shown in FIG. 9 and selected optimized structures are shown in FIG. 10. It shows that, with the increasing number of the acetonitrile ligands on Ca2+, the dative bond between Ca2+ and Mn4O4 breaks successively, and the distances between them become longer and longer. ΔG values for coordinate 1−4 acetonitrile ligands on superoxide S3-15b are −3.8, −1.5, 4.0, and 2.9 kcal/mol (relative to S3-15a), and on superoxide S3-17a are −1.1, −0.7, 6.8, and 8.6 kcal/mol, respectively. The Ca2+ in the peroxide S3-15a can only coordinate 1–3 acetonitrile ligands, with ΔG value of 1.3, 2.2, and 10.6 kcal/mol, respectively. It indicates that the superoxide S3-15b is the best one to coordinate acetonitrile ligands. Four acetonitrile molecules coordinate to S3-15b to form 15b-5p (FIG. 10(B)) in which all dative bonds between Ca2+ and Mn4O4 were broken. The Ca2+ part binds with the Mn4O4 part through a few hydrogen bonds and van der Waals interactions, with an average distance of 7.14 Å between Ca2+ and Mn ions. The total ΔG for the coordination is only 2.9 kcal/mol (relative to S3-15a), suggesting that the coordination of acetonitrile ligands on Ca2+ is facile when the O−O bond is formed in S3 state of Mn4CaO4.

      The leaving of the Ca2+ part is beneficial for the O2 formation. Our calculations show that the O2 formation from the superoxide 15b-5p to reach 15c-5p (FIG. 10(C)) is exergonic by 2.6 kcal/mol. In 15c-5p the Mn2−O1 bond is broken, and the Mn3−O2 bond increases to 2.44 Å. The oxidation states of all Mn ions are +3, with each O atom having one unpaired electron. The spin on Mn ions and on O are opposite. These geometric and electronic features support the triplet O2 formation in 15c-5p. We have scanned the O–O distance along the O2 formation, and found that there is no notable barrier. Later on, the O2 dissociates from 15c-5p to give Mn4O2Ca (FIG. 10(D)), followed by the dissociation of the Ca2+ part to reach Mn4O2a. The O2 dissociation is exergonic by 6.1 kcal/mol, while the Ca2+ dissociation is exergonic by 10.7 kcal/mol. Mn4O2a then undergoes ligand exchanges to give the product Mn4O2 (FIG. 10(E)) synthesized by Zhang. Overall, the O2 dissociation and Ca2+ dissociation are pretty facile when the Ca2+ is saturated by the acetonitrile. Again, it supports the idea that the Ca2+ is able to maintain the cubane structure with high oxidation state Mn ions in OEC [44−46]. Alternatively, we also calculated the pathway in which the Ca2+ dissociation occurs prior to the O2 dissociation. In this case, the Ca2+ dissociates to give p15b (FIG. 10(F)), with ΔG of 13.5 kcal/mol. Then it undergoes O2 formation and dissociation, as well as ligand exchange to reach Mn4O2. The O2 formation from superoxide also does not have notable barrier. As shown by the calculated energies, this pathway is less facile than the above pathway in which O2 dissociates first.

      Therefore, with the help of acetonitrile and pyridine, the decomposition and transformation of S3 state are all facile and exergonic after the O–O bond is formed, while the O–O bond formation is the rate-determining step of the whole reaction. We also investigated the decomposition mechanism in which only acetonitrile is involved. We found that, after O–O bond formation, in the best pathway, the reaction also undergoes acetonitrile coordination to Ca2+, O2 dissociation, Ca2+ dissociation, and ligand exchanges. These steps are also pretty facile and exergonic, with the O–O bond formation still being the rate-determined step.

      The decomposition and transformation in S2 state of Mn4CaO4 have also been investigated using similar models, and the results are shown in FIG. 11. The peroxide S2-16a-py can also isomerize to the superoxide (S2-16b-py and S2-18-py) which are close in free energy. Similar to that in S3 state, the superoxide S2-16b-py, which has an opposite spin on Mn ions and O2, is the most stable one. The ΔG value for coordinating 1–4 acetonitrile on superoxide S2-16b are 0.1, 10.1, 10.2 and 13.3 kcal/mol (relative to S2-16a), and on superoxide S2-18a are 4.0, 12.8, 13.6, and 17.6 kcal/mol, respectively. The Ca2+ in the peroxide S2-16a can only coordinate 1–3 acetonitrile molecules, with the ΔG value of 5.0, 8.2, and 13.4 kcal/mol, respectively. Notably, the coordination of acetonitrile in S2 state is much harder than that in S3 state. The superoxide S2-16b, in which the spin of Mn ions and O2 are opposite, is the best one to coordinate acetonitrile. Four acetonitrile molecules coordinate to S2-16b to get 16b-5p in which all dative bonds between Ca2+ and Mn4O4 are broken. Then the superoxide 16b-5p transfers to 16b-5c which is featured by O2 formation and is 0.5 kcal/mol higher in free energy. The O2 dissociation is exergonic by 9.3 kcal/mol, and the subsequent Ca2+ dissociates is endergonic by 12.9 kcal/mol. The Ca2+ dissociation prior to O2 dissociation to get S2-Mn4O4 is endergonic by 12.2 kcal/mol, and is also not competitive. In total, after the O–O bond formation, the decomposition pathway of S2 state is pretty similar to that of S3 state, and is also not the rate-determined step. Kinetically, the decomposition of S2 state is still inhibited by the O–O bond formation. However, it should be noticed that, overall, the decomposition and O2 evolution of S2 state is endergonic by 25 kcal/mol (FIG. 11), indicating the decomposition is not only kinetically inhibited, but also thermodynamically disfavored.

    V.   CONCLUSION
    • Stability is one of the key factors in catalyst research and application. In this work, we investigated the decomposition and O2 evolution of the OEC model complex Mn4CaO4 using DFT methods. We found that the O–O bond is preferred to be formed between O1 and O2, through the spin crossover mechanism. The reaction can occur in both high spin and low spin states. The barrier for the O–O bond formation is pretty high in S1 and S2 states, and decreases to 40.2 kcal/mol in S3 state. The relatively high barriers indicate that Mn4CaO4 has good stability in all oxidation states under normal conditions. We found that Lewis bases, such as acetonitrile and pyridine can effectively reduce the barrier by coordinating to Ca2+ and Mn2. The barrier decreases to < 30 kcal/mol when pyridine is involved, suggesting that strong Lewis bases, such as pyridine, are harmful for the stability of Mn4CaO4, and should be avoided when designing such a catalytic system. After the O–O bond is formed, with the help of pyridine or acetonitrile, the S3 state of Mn4CaO4 easily undergoes acetonitrile coordination, O2 release, Ca2+ release, and ligand exchange, leading to the formation of Mn4O2 complex. As a comparison, the decomposition of S2 state is kinetically hindered and thermodynamically disfavored. The S4 state of Mn4CaO4 is pretty unstable, with O–O formation barrier of only 9 kcal/mol, however, it can hardly be achieved under water oxidation conditions as shown by the very high potential for S3→S4 transition. Nevertheless, our results do not rule out that there could be other decomposition pathways other than the O–O bond formation, and water may also assist the decomposition of Mn4CaO4 during the catalytic water oxidation. The experimental characterization of the possible decomposition products will be very helpful for further mechanistic studies.

      Supplementary materials: O−O bond formation in S2, S3, S4 state of Mn4CaO4, O−O bond formation at low spin states (S=7), spin densities, and energies and coordinates for all optimized structures are shown.

    Figure (11)  Table (1) Reference (46)

Catalog

    /

    DownLoad:  Full-Size Img  PowerPoint
    Return
    Return