2025 Volume 38 Issue 6
Article Contents

Haideng Shi, Yanan Zhou, Wenhua Zhang. Nitrate Reduction Reaction on Single-atom Catalysts Supported on 3N-coordinated Nitrogen-doped Graphene[J]. Chinese Journal of Chemical Physics, 2025, 38(6): 907-916. doi: 10.1063/1674-0068/cjcp2405069
Citation: Haideng Shi, Yanan Zhou, Wenhua Zhang. Nitrate Reduction Reaction on Single-atom Catalysts Supported on 3N-coordinated Nitrogen-doped Graphene[J]. Chinese Journal of Chemical Physics, 2025, 38(6): 907-916. doi: 10.1063/1674-0068/cjcp2405069

Nitrate Reduction Reaction on Single-atom Catalysts Supported on 3N-coordinated Nitrogen-doped Graphene

通讯作者: 陈斌, bchen63@163.com
  • 1. 

    沈阳化工大学材料科学与工程学院 沈阳 110142

  1. 本站搜索
  2. 百度学术搜索
  3. 万方数据库搜索
  4. CNKI搜索

Figures(6)

Article Metrics

Article views(137) PDF downloads(3) Cited by(0)

Access History

Nitrate Reduction Reaction on Single-atom Catalysts Supported on 3N-coordinated Nitrogen-doped Graphene

Abstract: Utilizing nitrate (NO3−) as the nitrogen source to produce ammonia can effectively remove NO3− pollutant while obtaining valuable ammonia, and the understanding of the mechanisms is essential for the design of new catalysts. In this work, by using density functional theory calculations, the electroreduction mechanisms of nitrate reduction reaction (NO3RR) on transition metal single atom supported on 3N-coordinated N-doped graphene (TM/N3-G) are systematically investigated. It is found that the protonation of *OH acts as the potential determing steps except for the traditionally considered *NO3/*NO/*NO2 protonation step and the desorption of water may play an important role for NO3RR on some TM/N3-G. By considering the stability of single-atom catalyst (SAC), the preferential adsorption of NO3− larger than H and H2O, the limiting potential of whole NO3RR, the selectivity toward NH3, V (Mn, Os)/pyrrolic-N3-G and Mn (Ru, Ir)/pyridinic-N3-G are screened out as potential SACs for NO3RR. This work provides an understanding of the NO3RR mechanism and highlights several promising NO3RR catalysts based on the TM/N3-G system.

    • Ammonia (NH3) is a vital chemical fertilizer in agriculture and plays a significant role in meeting the increasing demand for food [1]. The traditional method of ammonia production involves Haber-Bosch process, which consumes approximately 1%–2% of global energy consumption [2−4]. Therefore, exploring more environmentally friendly and efficient methods for ammonia synthesis is demanded. The nitrate reduction reaction (NO3RR) employs NO3− as a nitrogen source, utilizing electrocatalysis to convert NO3− to NH3. Compared to the Haber-Bosch process, NO3RR for ammonia synthesis can proceed under milder conditions. Additionally, compared to electrocatalytic nitrogen reduction reactions (NRR), NO3RR exhibits higher efficiency and selectivity in ammonia production. Furthermore, NO3− is readily available from wastewater. This method offers dual advantages by addressing environmental pollution and meeting the demand for efficient ammonia production [5].

      The NO3RR involves 8 electron transfers coupled with 9 proton transfers [6−8]. After the adsorption of NO3− on active sites, a series of hydrogenation steps proceed and NO3− is gradually reduced to NH3, possibly accompanied by the formation of several by-products. Consequently, understanding the mechanism for the NO3RR pathways and designing efficient catalysts are of great significance. Various electrocatalysts, such as metals [9, 10], alloys [11], metal oxides [12, 13], and single-atom catalysts (SACs), have been developed to achieve high NO3RR performance [14, 15]. Among them, SACs have been widely investigated in electrocatalysis owing to their well-defined structures, the maximum efficiency of metal atom utilization, and the tunable performance by developing uniformly dispersed single metal atoms. It should be pointed out that two-dimensional (2D) carbon-nitrogen materials including nitrogen-doped graphene, g-C3N4, g-C2N, g-CN etc. supported single metal atoms have been theoretically investigated for NO3RR owing to their abundant unsaturated coordination active sites of 2D materials [16−18]. Experimentally, nitrogen-doped carbon (NC) supported Fe [15], Cu [19] single atoms demonstrate high catalytic performance at −0.7 VRHE with high ammonia selectivity. While the research on the NO3RR by SACs is still in its infancy. Hence, it is of particular urgency to explore promising SACs and their corresponding mechanism.

      The stability of SACs, the adsorption free energy of NO3−, the limiting potential of NO protonation and NH2 protonation are always adopted as criteria to screen to potential SACs for NO3RR. Based on this procedure, Ti (Zr)/g-CN [7], Zr (Hf)/g-C2N [8], and Ru/g-C3N4 [20] were theoretically screened out and exhibited high selectivity toward ammonia at low limiting potential as −0.39 V (−0.41 V), −0.28 V (−0.27 V), and −0.34 V. As for nitrogen doped carbon materials, Os-N4/graphene was predicted to achieve high NO3RR at −0.42 V [6]. However, the NO3RR mechanisms may change with the variation of the local environment of single metal atoms and it is difficult to prepare SACs on N-doped carbon materials with exact coordination environments [21, 22]. Thus, it is desirable to investigate the potential catalytic performance of N-C supported SACs with different single atom coordination configurations.

      Herein, in this work the NO3RR mechanisms on SACs coordinated by pyrrolic-N3 and pyridinic-N3 on nitrogen-doped graphene (TM/pyrrolic-N3-G and TM/pyridinic-N3-G, FIG. 1(a, b)) are intensively investigated. Through assessments of the stability of TM/N3-G, NO3− adsorption properties, and detailed NO3RR processes and ammonia selectivity, some qualified catalysts with excellent NO3RR performance are screened out. Among these catalysts, Mn/pyridinic-N3-G exhibits the highest activity with a limiting potential for NO3RR of only −0.17 V. Finally, an efficient SACs screening strategy for NO3RR is proposed.

    II.   COMPUTATIONAL DETAILS
    • All the calculations were performed using the Vienna ab initio simulation package (VASP) [23]. The Perdew-Burke-Ernzerhof (PBE) [24] generalized gradient approximation (GGA) [25] was employed to describe exchange-correlation effects. Ionic-electronic interactions were described using the Projector-Augmented-Wave (PAW) method [26], with a plane-wave cutoff energy set to 400 eV. Convergence criteria for energy and forces during geometry optimization, energy calculation, and frequency calculation were set to 10−5 eV and 0.02 eV/Å, respectively. To avoid interfacial interactions in the Z direction, a vacuum layer of 15 Å was utilized. The DFT-D3 correction method was employed to account for van der Waals effects [27], and an implicit solvent model (vaspsol) [28] was employed to consider solvent effects. Brillouin zone sampling was performed using a 3×3×1 Monkhorst-Pack k-point grid. Ab initio molecular dynamics (AIMD) [29] simulations were conducted to assess the thermal stability of the designed catalysts, employing a Nose thermostat algorithm with a time step of 1 fs and a canonical ensemble simulation for a duration of 10 ps.

      The Gibbs free energy change ΔG was calculated based on the computational hydrogen electrode (CHE) model proposed by Nørskov et al. [30−32]:

      where ΔE, ΔEZPE, and ΔS represent the energy difference, the zero point energy difference, and the vibrational entropy difference between the final and initial surface species for each adsorption, desorption, and protonation elementary step. The pH value in our work is zero.

      The formula for calculating the adsorption free energy ($ \Delta G_{^*\rm{NO}_3} $) of NO3− on TM/N3-G is as follows [11, 33, 34]:

      where $ G_{^*\rm{NO}_3} $ and G* respectively represent the energy after NO3− adsorbed on TM/N3-G and the energy of pure TM/N3-G; $G_{\mathrm{HNO}_3({\rm{g}})}$ and $G_{\mathrm{H}_2({\rm{g}})}$ represent the energies of gas-phase HNO3 and H2 molecules, respectively; and ΔGcorrect is 0.392 eV [7].

      The formula for calculating the binding energy (ΔEb) is as follows:

      where $ E_{\rm{TM/N_3\text{-}G}} $, $ E_{\mathrm{N}_3\text{-}\mathrm{G}} $, and ETM(single) represent the energies of TM/N3-G, N3-G, and the isolated transition metal single atom, respectively.

    III.   RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
    • A series of transition metal (TM) atoms (ranging from Ti to Au, excluding Tc due to its radioactivity) embedded in the cavities of pyrrolic-N3-G and pyridinic-N3-G, denoted as TM/pyrrolic-N3-G and TM/pyridinic-N3-G (FIG. 1 (a) and (b)), respectively, were investigated as the single-atom catalysts toward the NO3RR based on the nitrogen-doped graphene materials. Thus, a total of 23 TM/pyrrolic-N3-G and 23 TM/pyridinic-N3-G catalysts were constructed. The stability of catalyst is a prerequisite for studying catalytic performance. Accordingly, the stabilities of the designed TM/pyrrolic-N3-G and TM/pyridinic-N3-G catalysts were evaluated by calculating their corresponding binding energy and formation energy. As shown in FIG. 1(c), the calculated binding energies of all the designed catalysts are negative, suggesting their good stability. Remarkably, the calculated binding energy for the same TM atom on the pyrrolic-N3-G is generally more negative than that on the pyridinic-N3-G, indicating the better stability of TM/pyrrolic-N3-G than that of the corresponding pyridinic-N3-G, which is consistent with a previous report [35].

      The adsorption of NO3− is the first step of the NO3RR process. Two configurations of NO3− adsorbed on TM active sites (one adsorbs via one O atom and the other adsorbs via two O atoms) were taken into consideration, as displayed in FIG. 2(a). The calculated results reveal that the NO3− prefers to be adsorbed on the TM center by 2-O bidentate configuration of all the designed catalysts rather than 1-O monodentate, as listed in Table SI (Supplementary materials, SM). Moreover, the adsorption energies of NO3− based on 2-O bidentate configuration were calculated and are plotted in FIG. 2(b) (TM/pyrrolic-N3-G) and FIG. 2(c) (TM/pyridinic-N3-G). It can be observed from FIG. 2(b, c) that the adsorption of NO3− on Ni (Cu, Ag)/pyrrolic-N3-G and Ag/pyridinic-N3-G is very weak with positive $ \Delta G_{^*\mathrm{NO}_3} $.

      To get insight into the origin of the NO3− adsorption energy difference on the catalysts, we select three catalysts with significant differences in NO3− adsorption energy (Ag/pyrrolic-N3-G, Mn/pyrrolic-N3-G, and W/pyrrolic-N3-G, their corresponding NO3− adsorption energies are 0.27 eV, −0.50 eV and −1.77 eV, respectively) as examples. The calculated results of projected crystal orbital Hamilton population (pCOHP) for NO3− adsorption on the above three catalysts are shown in FIG. 2(d). The hybridized energy levels between the transition metal d-orbitals and the NO3− 2p-orbitals are divided into binding and anti-binding states. For the Ag/pyrrolic-N3-G, Mn/pyrrolic-N3-G, and W/pyrrolic-N3-G, a clear shift in the integrated crystal orbital Hamilton population (ICOHP) to a lower energy position with respect to the Fermi level is seen from FIG. 2(d), indicating an increase in the NO3− adsorption energy, which is consistent with the results of the calculated adsorption energy calculation trend.

      In addition, it is important to note that the hydrogen evolution reaction (HER) is a significant competitive reaction in the NO3RR process. As known, if the adsorption energy of NO3− is more negative than that of hydrogen, the HER process is suppressed by the NO3RR process and the NO3RR process dominates the whole reaction. Hence, the adsorption energies of hydrogen on all the designed catalysts were also calculated and are shown in FIG. 2 (b) and (c). It can be concluded that the adsorption energies of NO3− are more negative than that of hydrogen on all the catalysts, except Au/pyrrolic-N3-G and Au/pyridinic-N3-G, suggesting that NO3RR is a more favorable competitor with HER. Based on these results, Ni (Cu, Ag, Au)/pyrrolic-N3-G, and Ag (Au)/pyridinic-N3-G are excluded in further discussion.

      The electrochemical conversion of NO3− to NH3 is a complicated multistep electron-proton transfer process. FIG. 3 shows the possible reaction pathways of the NO3RR studied in this work (taking TM/pyrrolic-N3-G as an example). It can be seen that after the adsorption of NO3− on the TM active site, the hydrogen atom will attack oxygen atom of *NO3 to generate the intermediate species *NOOOH. During the above process, two adsorption configurations of *NOOOH will be generated, involving NOOOH (one non-hydroxyl O atom bonded to the TM site) and NOOOH (two non-hydroxyl O atoms bonded to the TM site). For the TM/pyrrolic-N3-G catalysts, it is favorable for the NOOOH adsorption configuration to be formed on the Ti, V, Cr, Mn, Zr, Nb, Mo, Ru, Rh, Hf, Ta, W, Ir, and Pt active sites, while the NOOOH adsorption configuration is favorable to be formed on the Fe, Co, Pd sites as summarized in Table SII (SM). Note that the bonds between the non-hydroxyl O atom and the N atom of *NOOOH are broken on the Re and Os sites during the geometry optimization process. The following reaction pathways are O−NOOH→O−NO→OH−NO→NO, as shown in FIG. S1 (SM). After the formation of the *NOOOH intermediate, the hydrogen atom continues to attack the oxygen atom of the *NOOOH, leading to the formation of the *NOO species. Furthermore, in the fourth step of the reaction, the hydrogenation results in the formation of two possible *NOOH intermediate adsorption modes: NOOH mode and NOOH mode. It can be found that NOOH is preferred on Ti, V, Fe, Nb, Mo, Hf, Ta, W, and active sites, while NOOH is more energy favorable on other active sites. The following hydrogenation of *NOOH will generate the key intermediate *NO. There are two different adsorption structures of *NO, involving end-on adsorption (NO) and N, O adsorption (NO) modes. The NO adsorption mode is more stable on the designed Ti (V, Nb, Mo, W)/pyrrolic-N3-G catalysts, while on the other TM/pyrrolic-N3-G catalysts the favorable NO adsorption mode is N, O adsorption (NO) mode.

      It can form four kinds of intermediate species during the protonation of the above-generated *NO, involving N-protonated NHO, NHO, and O-protonated NOH, NOH (FIG. 3). By comparing the calculated energies of the above four possible intermediates, the formation of the N-protonation intermediate is more stable than that of the O-protonation on TM/pyrrolic-N3-G. More specifically, on the Ti, V, Cr, Mn, Zr, Nb, Mo, Hf, Ta, and W active sites of TM/pyrrolic-N3-G catalysts, the key intermediate *NO is reduced by protonating the N atom to form NHO, while on the Fe, Co, Ru, Rh, Pd, Ir, and Pt active sites of TM/pyrrolic-N3-G catalysts, the formation of NHO by protonating the N atom of the *NO is more favorable. Furthermore, the continuous protonation of the above-formed NHO and NHO can generate three different intermediate configurations: NHOH, NH2O, and NHOH, and the formation of the NH2O intermediate exhibits energy advantage, indicating the favorable protonation of the N atom. The protonation of the NH2O includes two different ways: the proton attacks the O atom of the NH2O or continues to attack the N atom to release NH3. Subsequently, three possible intermediate species can be generated, involving NH2OH, NH2OH, and O(+NH3). For the designed TM/pyrrolic-N3-G catalysts, the formation of O(+NH3) intermediate configuration is energetically favorable on the most of the TM active sites except Pd. Specifically, the NH2OH configuration is energetically favorable on the Pd active sites. Moreover, further hydrogenation of the O intermediate will produce the *OH intermediate. Finally, the protonation of the formed *OH leads to the formation of H2O, which leaves the active site and exhibits the bare active sites. All the calculated energies of the above considered intermediate species with different configurations can be found in Tables SII–SV in SM.

      In addition, the NO3RR pathways that proceeds on the TM/pyridinic-N3-G catalysts are generally consistent with those on TM/pyrrolic-N3-G due to their similar structures. Specifically, the most stable intermediate species during the NO3RR process for most of the designed TM/pyridinic-N3-G catalysts (except Re, Ir/pyridinic-N3-G) are indicated by solid boxes in FIG. 3. For Re/pyridinic-N3-G, the bond between the non-hydroxyl O atom and an N atom of the intermediate *NOOOH will break on the Re active sites during the geometric optimization process, while the subsequent NO3RR reaction pathways on the Re/pyridinic-N3-G are same as Re/pyrrolic-N3-G (FIG. S1 in SM). While, on the Ir site, the formed *NO tends to protonate on O to generate *NOH intermediate, and the subsequent pathway is NOH→N→NH→NH2→NH3 (FIG. S2 in SM). In summary, we obtain the most stable intermediate species of the NO3RR process on all catalysts. Next, we will further investigate the transformation of these intermediate species to measure the performance of NO3RR.

      The NO3RR performance of TM/N3-G is examined by the Gibbs free-energy change of potential determining steps (PDS), which is the maximum Gibbs free-energy change among all elementary steps in the aforementioned pathways. It is found that the potential determining step is different among TM/N3-G. As shown in FIG. 4(a, b) and Tables SVI–SVII (SM), the PDSs are (1) *NOOO→*NOOOH for Cr (Mn, Co, Ru, Rh, Pd, Ir, Pt)/pyrrolic-N3-G and Cu (Ru)/pyridinic-N3-G, (2) *NOO→*NOOH for Ti (V, Cr, Ta, Ir)/pyridinic-N3-G, (3) *NO→*NHO for Fe/pyrrolic-N3-G and Mn(Fe, Co, Ni, Rh, Pd, Pt)/pyridinic-N3-G, (4) *OH→*H2O for Ti (V, Zr, Nb, Mo, Hf, Ta, W, Re, Os)/pyrrolic-N3-G and Zr (Nb, Mo, Hf, W, Re, Os)/pyridinic-N3-G. According to the reported results [6−8, 20], the selected catalysts with high performance generally possess a low energy barrier ( < 0.50 eV) in the NO3RR process. As shown in FIG. 4(a, b), our calculated results reveal that the designed V (Mn, Co, Os, Pt)/pyrrolic-N3-G and Mn (Cu, Ru, Ir)/pyridinic-N3-G meet this requirement. Subsequently, our focus will shift toward the study of ammonia catalytic properties for these catalysts exhibiting high activity in the NO3RR process.

      Different from the previous work, it is found that the desorption of H2O plays an important role in the recovery of active sites. Therefore, we calculated the adsorption energies of NO3− and H2O and plotted them on graph. As shown in FIG. 5(a), H2O exhibits stronger adsorption strength than NO3−, on the active sites of Co/pyrrolic-N3-G and Cu/pyridinic-N3-G, hindering the continuous progress of the reaction. As shown in FIG. 5(b), it is found that Gibbs free energy changes of *OH→*H2O exceed 0.50 eV while the OH adsorption energy is less than −1.28 eV (ΔG*OH < −1.28 eV).

      Thus, based on detailed NO3RR mechanisms investigations, V(Mn, Os, Pt)/pyrrolic-N3-G and Mn (Ru, Ir)/pyridinic-N3-G are screened out as the promising catalysts toward the NO3RR with high stable and catalytic activity. The free energy profiles of NO3RR on V (Mn, Os, Pt)/pyrrolic-N3-G and Mn (Ru, Ir)/pyridinic-N3-G are shown in FIG. 5(c−i). Moreover, the potential determining step of the Mn (Pt)/pyrrolic-N3-G and Ru/pyridinic-N3-G is *NO3→*NO3H, of the Ir/pyridinic-N3-G is *NO2→*NO2H, of the Mn/pyridinic-N3-G is *NO→*NOH, of the V (Os)/pyrrolic-N3-G is *OH→*H2O, respectively, and the corresponding energy barriers are 0.26 eV, 0.46 eV, 0.44 eV, 0.42 eV, 0.17 eV, 0.43 eV, and 0.46 eV. Furthermore, it should be pointed out that the products of the NO3RR are not only NH3 but also other by-products such as NO2, NO, N2O, and N2. Therefore, it is necessary to consider the selectivity of the NO3RR to NH3. In fact, the relatively large distance between the TM active sites of the two-dimensional single atom catalysts makes the migration of NO difficult to occur [19, 36], which further results in the difficulty of the NO coupling that tends to generate the N2O and N2. Therefore, we only need to consider the possible desorption of NO2 and NO. As shown in FIG. 5(j), the desorption energies of NO2 and NO are both above 1.00 eV, making desorption difficult at room temperature. Therefore, NO3− is more likely to generate NH3 at the active site rather than other by-products.

      To further verify the stability of the screened-out V (Mn, Os, Pt)/pyrrolic-N3-G, and Mn (Ru,Ir)/pyridinic-N3-G catalysts with high NO3RR performance, we performed AIMD simulations using the canonical ensemble (NVT) for a total simulation time of 10 ps with the time step of 1.00 fs under 500 K condition. As shown in FIG. S3 (SM), except Pt/pyrrolic-N3-G, the snapshots of the above catalysts exhibit no significant changes in their geometric structures at 10 ps, further indicating their good stability. V (Mn, Os)/pyrrolic-N3-G and Mn (Ru, Ir)/pyridinic-N3-G are screened out as potential SACs for NO3RR. V (Mn, Os, Ru, Ir) exhibited limited activity on g-C2N and g-CN [7, 8]. However, by altering the coordination environment of the transition metals (TMs), the catalytic activity for nitrate reduction reaction (NO3RR) of these TMs was significantly enhanced.

      The studies of Niu on g-CN [7] and Zhu on TM/g-C2N [8] suggested that the PDS of the NO3RR process typically involve *NO→*NOH in the sixth step and *NH2→*NH3 conversion in the tenth step. On both substrates, transition metal (TM) monomers are anchored in the cavity of the substrate via two TM-N chemical bonds, maintaining a nearly planar configuration with the substrate. Conversely, in the report by Wang on TM/N4-G [37], the PDS of NO3RR involves the protonation of NOx (x=1, 2, 3). In this work, the protonation of NOx (x=1, 2, 3) and OH is the PDS of NO3RR. By contrasting the results, it is hypothesized that the diminished dimensions of the substrate cavity intensify the interactions between transition metals (TMs) and the substrate, inducing modifications in the composition of the most stable intermediate species on the TM sites. In another study on TM/g-C3N4 [20], which shared structural similarities with the TM/N3-G, catalysts were screened out based on the Gibbs free-energy change of *NO→*NOH and *NH2→*NH3, without considering the changes in pathways and PDS resulting from structural differences, resulting in the omission of some TM/g-C3N4 with high activity in NO3RR process.

      According to the aforementioned analysis and discussion, based on the 3N-coordination system, we propose a screening strategy for selecting catalysts with high-performance of NO3RR. As shown in FIG. 6, the strategy involves: (1) calculating the binding energy of catalysts to eliminate those with unstable structures, (2) calculating the adsorption energy of NO3−, H, and H2O, and screening out the catalysts that meet the requirements ($ \Delta G_{^*\mathrm{NO}_3} $ < 0.00 eV, ΔG*H, and $ \Delta G_{^*\mathrm{H}_2\mathrm{O}} $) to ensure the adsorption of NO3− at the active sites of the catalysts, (3) calculating the adsorption energy of OH and excluding catalysts with G*OH < −1.28 eV, as these catalysts have a high energy barrier for the tenth step (*OH→*H2O) of the NO3RR process, (4) calculating the limiting potentials of the catalysts in NO3RR process and screening out those with high activity in NO3RR process, (5) screening out catalysts with NO and NO2 adsorption energy more negative than −1.00 eV, (6) further investigating the thermodynamic stability of catalysts through AIMD simulations.

    IV.   CONCLUSION
    • In summary, the NO3RR mechanisms on stable TM/N3-G were intensively investigated. By comparing all the possible configurations for each intermediate, the optimal NO3RR pathways were determined. In terms of catalytic performance, the V(Mn, Os)/pyrrolic-N3-G and Mn(Ru, Ir)/pyridinic-N3-G were predicted as promising NO3RR catalysts due to their considerably low limiting potential ( < |−0.50| V). It is suggested that weaker *OH adsorption (ΔG*OH > −1.28 eV) is expected to avoid high ΔG for *OH protonation. And stronger NO3− adsorption than H2O is required for continuous reaction. Moreover, the selectivity of these screened-out catalysts was studied by considering the production of byproducts (NO2, NO) and the HER activity. Our findings not only offer a comprehensive understanding of the NO3RR mechanism but also provide an efficient method for designing optimum TM/N3-G catalysts for the NO3RR.

      Supplementary materials: NO3− adsorption energy, the DFT calculated adsorption energies, and free energy change, and some high-performance single-atom catalysts for NO3RR (Tables SI−SVIII) are shown. Subsequent reaction pathways for Re (Os)/pyrrolic-N3-G, subsequent reaction pathways from *NOH for Ir/pyridinic-N3-G, total energy and temperature variations during AIMD simulations, and the snapshots of the last steps of each AIMD simulation (FIG. S1–S3).

    Figure (6)  Reference (37)

Catalog

    /

    DownLoad:  Full-Size Img  PowerPoint
    Return
    Return