-
Transition metal oxide diatomic species play a crucial role in various scientific contexts, not only as important constituents in the atmospheres of hot stars [1−3] but also due to their potential applications in advanced spectroscopic studies [4−12] and laser cooling experiments [13−15]. These molecules have garnered significant interest for comprehensive investigations aimed at elucidating their electronic configurations and chemical bonding properties. Understanding these fundamental aspects is essential for grasping related physical and chemical processes. The present study focuses on CuO−, a particularly intriguing diatomic anion within this class of compounds.
In the past decades, the CuO− anion has attracted renewed interest due to its unique electronic state structure and intriguing ionic-covalent bonding properties [16−18]. Under the ionic bond approximation, the closed-shell ground state of CuO−, X1Σ+, can be described by an electronic configuration of 3d102pσ22pπ44sσ0, while its lowest triplet excited state, the open-shell a3Π state, is 3d102pσ22pπ34sσ1. Early photoelectron spectroscopic studies on CuO− by Polak et al. [16] and Wu et al. [17] observed photodetachment transition features from the two states, X2Π←X1Σ+ and X2Π←a3Π, which were reasonably explained based on the ionic bond model. Wu et al. [17] also observed an a′ excited state of CuO− with an energy of ~ 1.03 eV in the photodetachment spectra by generating hot CuO− from dissociation of CuO3−. This a′ excited state, lying ~ 0.76 eV above the ground X1Σ+ state, was preliminarily attributed to a spin-orbit splitting component of a3Π0 based on an electronic structure analysis. In 2017, Orms and Krylov employed the equation-of-motion coupled-cluster (EOM-CC) method for high-level theoretical calculations on the low-lying electronic states of CuO− [19]. Based on the calculation results, they further analyzed previous photoelectron data and suggested the a′ feature in Ref.[17] to be due to a low-lying 3Σ+ state (3d102pσ12pπ44sσ1). Recently, Kocheril et al. performed a high-resolution photoelectron imaging study on CuO− by using a cryogenic ion trap, and found that the a3Π state has a long lifetime of ~ 45 ms [18]. Based on an analysis of the photoelectron angular distributions, they suggested that the X1Σ+ and a3Π states of CuO− can be better explained by a covalent interaction with strong electronic correlation effects.
This study complements our understanding of the low-lying electronic state structures of CuO−, aiming for a renewed insight into its ionic/covalent bonding properties. We employed a combined experimental and theoretical approach, by utilizing high-resolution anion photoelectron imaging and high-level quantum chemical calculations. This now allows us to assign low-lying electronic states observed in the present and previous experiments and discuss the diatomic bonding character and non-adiabatic couplings among low-lying electronic states of CuO−.
-
Photoelectron imaging experiments on CuO− were performed using a home-made plasma injection photoelectron velocity map imaging (PI-PE-VMI) instrument, details of which have been described in Ref.[20]. Briefly, in the present experiment, a copper-containing plasma, generated by a discharge nozzle with copper-made plate electrodes, was perpendicularly injected into a supersonic jet expansion. The supersonic jet beam was produced using a homemade piezoelectric valve with a 0.8%O2/Ar gas mixture at a stagnation pressure of 11 bar [21]. CuO− anions were generated via reactions of Cu/Cu− atoms in the plasma with O2 in the supersonic jet. The generated CuO− ions were mass-selected by a 90° deflected time-of-flight mass spectrometer before entering the photoelectron imaging system. A Nd:YAG pumped pulsed dye laser beam, perpendicular to the ion beam direction, interacted with the CuO− ions, producing photodetached electrons. Photoelectrons were detected by a position-sensitive detector and recorded in real-time by a CMOS camera.
-
To evaluate the equilibrium bond lengths and harmonic vibrational frequencies for both X1Σ+ and a3Π states of CuO−, we performed perturbatively corrected density functional theory (DFT) calculations with the revDOD-PBEP86-D4/2021 method combined with a ma-def2-TZVPP basis sets [22−27]. Additional NEVPT2 calculations were also carried out for a double check of the a3Π state results [28]. Based on the calculated equilibrium bond length for the X1Σ+ state, more accurate calculations at the MRCI+Q theoretical level were performed to explore the low-lying electronic states of CuO− with inclusion of spin-orbit coupling effects. In MRCI and NEVPT2 calculations, a CASSCF active space containing 12 active electrons and 10 active orbitals was chosen as a reference space [29]. In addition, full-electron relativistic corrections based on the exact two-component (X2C) theory were also included in all calculations above [30, 31]. These computations were carried out using the ORCA 6.0 software package [32−34].
-
FIG. 1 shows the photoelectron images and their corresponding electron binding energy (eBE) spectra of CuO− acquired using photodetachment wavelengths at 627.5 nm and 860.6 nm, respectively. By comparing our results to those presented in Refs. [16−18], we can attribute the spectral features observed in the eBE > 1.6 eV region to detachment transitions from the X1Σ+ ground state of CuO− to the X2Π ground state of neutral CuO. As shown in FIG. 1, this X band system exhibits well-resolved fine structures, with peaks labelled by f and g, h and i, j and k, corresponding to vibrational transitions from X1Σ+ v = 0 and 1 of CuO− to X2Π v = 0 and 1 of CuO (see the detailed assignments in FIG. 1 and Table I). The intervals between each pair of these features represent the 2Π1/2-2Π3/2 spin-orbit splitting in the ground state of CuO. The vibrational frequencies for CuO− X1Σ+ and CuO X2Π inferred from our results are 742 cm−1 and 653 cm−1, respectively, while the spin-orbit splitting in CuO X2Π is determined to be ~ 270 cm−1. These results are in good agreement with literature values in Ref.[16].
In addition to the X2Π←X1Σ+ photodetachment transition mentioned above, we also observed clearly resolved features of the X2Π←a3Π photodetachment transition in the eBE region of 1.1–1.5 eV. Previous studies [17] only showed one unresolved peak at ~ 1.27 eV. Here, benefiting from our high spectral resolution, we have also identified several fine structures (labeled by b–e in FIG. 1) alongside the strongest feature a located at about 1.28 eV. Based on available molecular data, features a, d, and e can be straightforwardly assigned as transitions from a3Π (v = 0) of CuO− to X2Π (v = 0, 1, 2) of CuO, respectively. Further assignments of spin-orbit components, as well as the newly observed features of b and c in FIG. 1, are discussed based on our calculation results below.
Assignments of the peak b and c have been made based on the accurate calculation results, which are demonstrated in detail below. Our DFT calculations yield optimized equilibrium bond lengths for X1Σ+ and a3Π states of CuO− to be 1.669 Å and 1.680 Å, respectively, with corresponding harmonic vibrational frequencies of 792 cm−1 and 750 cm−1. As a double-check, NEVPT2 calculations on the a3Π state of CuO− yielded consistent results (bond length: 1.686 Å, frequency: 742 cm−1). It is noticed that, features b and c in FIG. 1 exhibit red shifts relative to the strongest feature a by approximately 150 cm−1 and 480 cm−1, respectively. Based on the calculated vibrational frequencies, neither b nor c can be assigned as vibrational hot band of a3Π (v = 1). They may originate from other low-lying states or spin-orbit splitting components.
The results of our spin-orbit coupling included MRCI+Q calculations are tabulated in Table II. Here, four low-lying electronic states below the ionization limit of CuO− are included:
$^{ {1}} {\Sigma }^{ +} ,\;({3{\mathrm{d}}}^{ {10}} {2{\mathrm{p}}\sigma }^{ {2}} {2{\mathrm{p}}\pi }^{ {4}} {4{\mathrm{s}}\sigma }^{ {0}}) $ ,$^{ {1}} \Pi\; {\mathrm{and}}\; ^{ {3}} \Pi , (3{\mathrm{d}}^{ {10}} {2{\mathrm{p}}\sigma }^{ {2}} {2{\mathrm{p}}\pi }^{ {3}} {4{\mathrm{s}}\sigma }^{ {1}}) $ ,$^{ {3}} {\Sigma }^{ +} ,\;({3{\mathrm{d}}}^{ {10}} {2{\mathrm{p}}\sigma }^{ {1}} {2{\mathrm{p}}\pi }^{ {4}} {4{\mathrm{s}}\sigma }^{ {1}}) $ , and non-adiabatic couplings among these states result in twelve spin-orbit states (denoted by the quantum number Ω in Table II). Notably, our calculations show that, the a3Π state is severely mixed with the 1Π and 3Σ+ states, leading to irregular splittings among its Ω = 2, 1 and 0, components. Furthermore, even for the X1Σ+ state, a weak coupling with the a3Π state is also found. These results are evident for the presence of strong multiconfiguration correlation effects in the low-lying electronic states of CuO−, as suggested in Ref.[18], which underscores the complexity in the low-lying electronic states of CuO−.Based on the MRCI+Q calculations, we can assign spectral features a, d, and e in FIG. 1 as transitions of a3Π2(v = 0)→X2Π3/2(v = 0, 1, 2), while b and c as 2(Ω=0) and 3(Ω=0) spin-orbit states of CuO− to CuO X2Π3/2,1/2 (v = 0), respectively. It is noted that the 2(Ω=0) and 3(Ω=0) spin-orbit states arise from weak state mixing of the a3Π0 component with the higher-lying 3Σ+ and ground X1Σ+ states, respectively. Additionally, the degenerate a3Π1 state, i.e., 1(Ω=1) and 2(Ω=1) spin-orbit states, is also expected to be observed in our experiment. According to our calculations, transitions from a3Π1 to CuO X2Π3/2 and X2Π1/2 should lie < 0.01 eV and −0.04 eV relative to the strong feature a, respectively. The former would not be resolvable in our experiments, while later may be blended with feature b, which appears as a slightly broadened and unresolved doublet structure. In addition, the present calculations have also allowed us to assign the a′ state reported in Ref.[17] to the 5(Ω=1) and 6(Ω=1) spin-orbit states, which result from mixing the 1Π and 3Σ+ states with the 3Σ+ character more than 0.86.
In Ref.[18], photoelectron anisotropy parameters β for both X1Σ+ and a3Π states are found to be positive, i.e., their images exhibit photoelectron angular distribution (PAD) patterns parallel to the laser polarization direction. Based on this, the Cu–O bond in CuO− was suggested to be covalent. However, as shown FIG. 1, in our experiment, the PAD for the X1Σ+ state is clearly a perpendicular pattern, with a negative anisotropy parameter β ≈ –0.5. The discrepancy between the β values obtained here and in Ref.[18] indicates that the PAD from the X1Σ+ state can not be described by a simple p-wave or s-d wave model. As discussed in Refs. [35−37], under the central atom approximation, the actual PADs behave as a function of photoelectron kinetic energy (eKE), and the relative proportion of p-wave and s-d wave contributions. In Ref.[18], a photodetachment energy of 3.49 eV was used, which yields X1Σ+ state eKE in the range of 1.5–1.7 eV. Here, we have used a much lower photodetachment energy of 1.98 eV, yielding the X1Σ+ state eKE less than 0.2 eV. Following the extensive discussions about PADs in Ref.[36], variation of β from −0.5 at eKE < 0.2 eV to +0.7 at eKE ≈ 1.7 eV hints a mixed p-wave and s+d wave nature. A rough estimation using the theoretical model described in Ref.[35] results in a proportion of the s+d wave electrons to be approximately 0.80 ± 0.10. Since the p wave and s+d wave photoelectrons from the X1Σ+ state of CuO− can be considered as indicators of covalent and ionic interactions [18], the present results suggest that the Cu–O bond in the X1Σ+ state of CuO− anion should be characterized by mixed ionic and covalent bond, with a contribution of the ionic interaction to be about 80%.
For the a3Π2 state, similar values of the anisotropy parameter β ≈ +0.8 are obtained both here and in Ref. [18], which correspond to a typical p-wave PAD. The electronic configuration of the a3Π state under the ionic bond approximation can be described as 3d102pσ22pπ34sσ1. Thus, photodetachment of an electron from the 4sσ orbital can reasonably explain the observed p-wave PAD in experiments.
To get a more in-depth understanding on the Cu–O bond in CuO−, we performed electrostatic potential analysis [38] on both X1Σ+ and a3Π states by using the Multiwfn software [39], and the results are shown in FIG. 2. In the electrostatic potential surfaces, blue regions represent higher negative charge populations, while transition colors of blue-white-red indicate the increase of the electrostatic potential, or the decrease of the negative charge population. From the results in FIG. 2, it is evident that the negative charge population in the a3Π state almost fully resides on the copper atom, which is characteristic for a typical ionic bond. For the X1Σ+ state, the negative charge population slightly spreads from the oxygen atom towards copper, which is consistent with our conclusion that the Cu–O bond in the X1Σ+ state should be characterized by mixed ionic and covalent interactions, with the ionic character being more dominant.
-
In summary, the low-lying electronic states of CuO− observed in the present and previous photoelectron spectroscopic experiments have been assigned based on supporting quantum chemical calculations with inclusion of complex spin-orbit coupling effects, which also revealed strong multiconfiguration correlation effects on the low-lying electronic states of CuO−. Analyses on the photoelectron angular distributions indicate that, the Cu–O bond in the X1Σ+ state should be characterized by mixed ionic and covalent interactions, with the ionic character being more dominant, while the a3Π state can be characterized by a typical ionic bond. This work also provides a combined experimental and theoretical approach to investigate the interplayed ionic/covalent electronic structures of diatomic transition metal containing species.
Combined Experimental and Theoretical Study on Low-Lying Electronic States of CuO−†
- Received Date: 30/09/2024
- Available Online: 27/12/2024
-
Key words:
- CuO− /
- Photoelectron imaging /
- Spin-orbit coupling /
- Ionic/covalent bond
Abstract: We present a combined experimental and theoretical study on the electronic structure and bonding characteristics of the CuO− anion. On the experimental side, high resolution photoelectron imaging has allowed the detection of new features of the low-lying states of the CuO−. Supporting MRCI+Q calculations with inclusion of complex spin-orbit coupling effects have yielded complemented assignments of the photoelectron spectra obtained in the present and previous experiments to low-lying spin-orbit mixed states, which also reveal strong multiconfiguration correlation effects in CuO−. Analyses on the experimentally measured photoelectron angular distributions indicate that, the Cu–O bond in the X1Σ+ state can be characterized by mixed ionic and covalent interactions, with the ionic character being more dominant, while the a3Π state can be characterized by a typical ionic bond. Our results provide a renewed understanding in the interplay of ionic-covalent bonding characters in the diatomic CuO− anion.
首页
登录
注册


DownLoad: