-
Second harmonic generation (SHG), as a powerful surface-sensitive technique, has been widely applied to investigate the molecular structure and dynamics at electrochemical interfaces due to its inherent interface selectivity and high sensitivity [1−5]. In the 1980s, Richmond et al. pointed out that the SHG signal at metal electrode/aqueous electrochemical interface was dominated by the contribution from the electrified metal surface, and the χ(3) contribution from water molecules in the electric double layer (EDL) could be ignored, because the nonlinear susceptibility of the water near the surface should be small relative to that for electrode [6, 7]. Until 1992, Eisenthal et al. found that the concentration, pH and temperature dependence of SHG signal at a charged silica/aqueous interface could not be explained by only considering the χ(2) contribution, and the χ(3) theory of bulk water molecules was first proposed [8]. After that, Shen, Roke, and Geiger et al. further improved the χ(3) theory of charged aqueous interface [9−12]. However, these studies on the χ(3) contribution have mainly focused on charged insulation systems, such as fused silica/aqueous interface [13−15] and gas-liquid interface [12, 16, 17].
At present, there are few studies on the χ(3) theory of electrode/electrolyte interfaces. Dlott et al. used sum-frequency generation (SFG) spectroscopy to study solid electrolyte interphase formation on a model for Li-ion battery anode [18, 19] and low-overpotential CO2 reduction in a room-temperature ionic liquid [18, 20], proposing that potential-dependent SFG measurement could be used to qualitatively determine whether the SFG signal at electrochemical interface derived from χ(2) or χ(3) contribution. In addition, the χ(3) contribution developed by Eisenthal et al. is closely related to the thickness of the EDL (Debye length), and the thickness of the EDL is inversely proportional to the square root of the electrolyte concentration based on the Gouy-Chapman model. Therefore, in some research work on electrode/electrolyte interfaces, the χ(3) contribution from the EDL is usually negligible based on the short Debye length at high electrolyte concentration (≥10 mmol/L) [21−24]. However, for the low electrolyte concentration, whether the SHG signal generated at the electrode/electrolyte interface contains the χ(3) contribution from molecules in the EDL, and the extent of its χ(3) contribution remain unresolved.
The Pt electrode/aqueous electrolyte interface is one of the most studied electrified interfaces in electrochemical surface science [25]. SHG spectra, with interfacial selectivity and sensitivity, can provide molecular-level information for the electrochemical process at the Pt electrode/aqueous electrolyte interface [4, 5, 26]. The detected total SHG signal at the Pt electrode/aqueous electrolyte interface contains contributions from the substrate, the adsorbed molecules, and the molecules in the EDL. In order to explore the structural changes of water molecules in the EDL, it is necessary to separate this part of the contributions from the total SHG signal. So far, SHG/SFG intensity measurement [27−30] or phase measurement [12−14, 17, 31] methods have been used to disentangle the χ(2) and χ(3) contributions at charged aqueous interface. Compared with the SHG/SFG intensity measurement, which can only provide qualitative information on the changes of χ(2) and χ(3) [28−30] or quantitative information of |χ(2)| and |χ(3)| based on certain assumptions and specific known conditions [27], the SHG/SFG phase measurement can directly separate the χ(2) and χ(3) contributions. Geiger et al. used heterodyne-detected SHG (HD-SHG) spectroscopy to study the fused silica/water interface and showed that phase information can be used to unambiguously separate the χ(2) and χ(3) contributions [13, 14, 31]. Although as early as the 1990s, Richmond et al. [32−34] and Pettinger et al. [35, 36] used time-domain SHG interference to study the influence of potential and adsorption on the SHG phase at the single crystal electrode/electrolyte interface, HD-SHG spectroscopy has not been widely applied to quantitatively separate the contributions of each part at the electrode/aqueous electrolyte interface.
Lithium perchlorate (LiClO4) is one of the most common lithium salts used in Li-ion batteries due to its high solubility, good ion conductivity, and high anodic stability [37−39]. Furthermore, the contribution of ClO4− ions adsorption to the SHG signal can be excluded because of the very weak adsorption of ClO4− ions on the Pt electrode surface [40, 41], making LiClO4 an ideal electrolyte for studying the structure of water molecules at the Pt electrode interface. In this study, we used HD-SHG spectroscopy to study the structural changes of water molecules in the EDL at the Pt/LiClO4 interface with low electrolyte concentrations. The SHG intensity and phase at the Pt/LiClO4 interface with concentrations of 0.1 mmol/L and 100 mmol/L were measured under different potentials. The χ(3) contribution from water molecules in the EDL and the χPt contribution from the Pt electrode were separated. We found that both contributions with increasing potential followed a parabolic model, where the potential at the minimum was close to the potential of zero charge (PZC). Compared with the χPt contribution, the χ(3) contribution from water molecules in the EDL ranged from 0% to 22%. Moreover, the χ(3) contribution increased with increasing interfacial potential, which was mainly due to the more ordered arrangement of the water molecules in the EDL. In addition, SHG intensity and phase at different ionic strengths under the open circuit potential were measured. We found that the χ(3) contribution from water molecules in the EDL increased with decreasing ionic strength, which was attributed to the increase in the number of water molecules in the EDL.
-
The effective second-order nonlinear susceptibility at charged aqueous solution interface can be expressed as [11, 13, 42]
where χ(2) and
$ \chi _{\text{Water}}^{(3)} $ are the second- and third-order nonlinear susceptibility, respectively. The χ(2) term contains the contributions from the substrate and adsorbates in the inner region. The$ \chi _{\text{Water}}^{(3)} $ term originates from the reorientation of water molecules in the EDL induced by the interfacial electric field.$ \Phi(0) $ is the interfacial potential. φDC is phase angle of the$ \chi _{\text{Water}}^{(3)} $ term, which takes the form [13, 14]Here, λD is the Debye length, and Δkz is the wave vector mismatch related to a certain experimental configuration. For our experimental conditions, Δkz=3.19×107 m−1. In previous studies on charged silica/aqueous interfaces, the χ(3) contribution from the silica substrate was neglected [8, 13, 14]. However, this assumption does not apply to the electrode/electrolyte interface. Corn and Richmond pointed out that SHG intensity is closely related to the charge density on the electrode in the early studies on the electrode/electrolyte interface [6, 43−45]. For the Pt electrode/electrolyte interface, the metal substrate itself can exhibit a significant potential-dependent nonlinear response, and the interfacial electric field can also induce a third-order response from water molecules in the EDL. Therefore, it is necessary to consider the third-order contributions from the change of the charge density on the electrode side due to the interfacial electric field or adsorption, and from the reorientation of water molecules in the EDL.
The total SHG signal at the Pt electrode/electrolyte interface includes contributions from the Pt electrode surface, surface-bonded species, and water molecules in the EDL [24]. In this paper, we focus on the potential range where no obvious redox peaks are observed to avoid the contribution from hydrogen underpotential deposition (a process where hydrogen adsorption occurs at potentials positive of the thermodynamic reduction potential) and the oxidation of water molecules. Furthermore, ClO4− ions are hardly adsorbed on the Pt electrode surface, as confirmed by previous studies [40, 41], and no other specifically adsorbing species are present in the system. Thus, the contribution from surface-bonded species can be ruled out. The total effective second-order nonlinear susceptibility can be written as
where,
$ \chi _{\text{eff, Pt}}^{(2)} $ represents the effective second-order nonlinear susceptibility generated on the Pt electrode surface, including the second-order contribution from the Pt electrode$ \chi _{\text{Pt}}^{(2)} $ and the third-order contribution induced by the interfacial potential$ \chi _{\text{Pt}}^{(3)} $ . Since the metallic surfaces usually exhibit complex nonlinear susceptibilities [24], the SHG electric field at the Pt/LiClO4 interface can be written aswhere Esig and φsig are the SHG amplitude and phase produced by the sample, respectively. φPt is the SHG phase of the Pt electrode surface.
In order to separate the
$ \chi _{\text{eff, Pt}}^{(2)} $ and$ \chi _{\text{Water}}^{(3)} $ contributions, the vector relationships of the SHG field at the Pt/LiClO4 interface is shown in FIG. 1. According to the trigonometry, the$ \chi _{\text{Water}}^{(3)}\Phi (0) $ contribution can be expressed as:Here, Esig and φsig can be obtained from the SHG intensity and phase measurement of the Pt/LiClO4 interface, respectively. φDC can be calculated from Eq.(2). Knowing the amplitude EPt and phase φPt of the Pt electrode surface, the
$\chi _{\text{Water}}^{(3)}\Phi (0)$ contribution can be acquired.According to the Gouy−Chapman model, the potential
$ \Phi(0) $ in the EDL varies with the distance z from the interface as follows [46]Here
$ \Phi_0 $ is the potential at z=0 relative to the bulk solution, e is the elementary charge, kB is the Boltzmann constant, T is the temperature, 1/κ the Debye screening length. The potential profiles in the EDL for different concentrations of LiClO4 electrolyte at the electrode potentials$ \Phi_0 $ =0.1 V and$ \Phi_0 $ =0.4 V were simulated according to Eq.(6), as shown in FIG. 2. The potential in the EDL decayed faster and faster with increasing concentration of LiClO4. When the concentration increased to 100 mmol/L, the potential rapidly decayed to zero within 3 nm. Only a few layers of water molecules contributed to the SHG signal [9]. Therefore, for the Pt/LiClO4 interface with a concentration of 100 mmol/L, the SHG signal mainly originated from the Pt electrode surface. While for the Pt/LiClO4 interface with a concentration of 0.01 mol/L, the potential extended much further into the solution, and thus the SHG signal contained significant contributions from both the Pt electrode surface and water molecules in the EDL. -
LiClO4 with a purity of 99.99% was purchased from Sigma-Aldrich (Shanghai, China). LiClO4 aqueous electrolytes with different concentrations were prepared with ultrapure water (18 MΩ·cm, Millipore Simplicity 185 system).
-
The HD-SHG experiment setup has been reported elsewhere [4]. Briefly, using 80 fs pulses centered at 800 nm with a repetition rate of 82 MHz from a mode-locked Ti-sapphire oscillator (Tsunami 3960C, Spectra-Physics), the interface was probed at a 60° incident angle. The incident pulse power was 300 mW. A reference z-cut α-quartz wafer with a thickness of 150 μm was used to generate the local oscillator (LO). An interference pattern produced by the translation of the reference z-cut α-quartz crystal along the beam path was recorded. In order to improve the signal-to-noise ratio during the experiment, the SHG signal intensity ISHG at each stage position was obtained by collecting the signal five times and averaging it, with an acquisition time of 1 s per point. The SHG phase can be obtained by fitting the interference pattern with the following equation [4, 47, 48]
where x is the stage position. I1, A, f, and φfit are fitting parameters. In addition, SHG intensity at the Pt/LiClO4 interface was measured through removal of the reference z-cut α-quartz crystal. All SHG experiments were measured under the pp polarization combination.
-
The spectro-electrochemical experiments were conducted in a homemade three-electrode cell, which was described previously [5]. To reduce the time delay between fundamental pulse and SHG pulse, the optical window was changed from a prism to a fused silica window sheet with a thickness of 2 mm. The working electrode was a polycrystalline Pt electrode with a diameter of 12 mm and a thickness of 0.5 mm. The reference electrode was a saturated calomel electrode (SCE), and the counter electrode was a Pt rod. All experiments were performed under flow conditions. The electrode potential was controlled with a potentiostat/galvanostat analyzer Echemlab XM (Solartron Co., UK).
Differential capacitance-potential curves were measured by using the potentiostat/galvanostat analyzer Echemlab XM. Electrochemical impedance measurements were conducted at a constant frequency (10 Hz) by scanning the electrode potential at a scan rate of 1 mV·s−1, and the ac potential with 10 mV peak-to-peak amplitude was superimposed on dc potential. The capacitances were obtained by using the equation Cd=−1/(2πfZ"), where Z" is the imaginary component of impedance, and f is the frequency [26, 49].
-
To determine the electrochemical window of the Pt electrode, cyclic voltammetry (CV) curves of the Pt electrode in 0.1 mmol/L and 100 mmol/L LiClO4 electrolytes were measured, as shown in FIG. 3. The potential was scanned from −0.2 V to 1.2 V and then returned to −0.2 V at a sweep rate of 100 mV/s. In the potential range of 0.1−0.6 V, the current was small and no redox peak was observed, indicating that the electrode was in the EDL region. During the anodic scan, the Pt electrode began to oxidize when the potential increased to 0.6 V, Pt+H2O→Pt−OH+H++e− [24], and the sharply increased current above 1.1 V implied the evolution of oxygen [50]. During the cathodic scan, the evolution of hydrogen occurred when the potential was lower than 0.1 V. Therefore, to avoid the influence of water decomposition on the SHG signal, the HD-SHG measurements were carried out in the potential range of 0.1−0.8 V.
FIG. 3(b) shows the differential capacitance-potential curves of the Pt electrode measured in 0.1 mmol/L and 100 mmol/L LiClO4 electrolytes. For 0.1 mmol/L LiClO4, a capacitance minimum was observed at 0.35 V, indicating that the potential of zero charge (PZC) of the Pt electrode was 0.35 V. This agreed well with the PZC of Pt electrode in the HClO4 aqueous solution determined by Xu et al. using electrochemical impedance spectroscopy [24]. For 100 mmol/L LiClO4, the capacitance increased and a maximum at 0.35 V was observed, which is similar to the capacitance maximum at the Pt(111) electrode/perchlorate aqueous electrolyte observed by Ojha et al. [25] and Pajkossy et al. [51, 52]. In addition, Ojha et al. pointed out that although the PZC of the Pt(111) electrode can only be identified at anomalously low electrolyte concentration, the value of the PZC is valid for all concentrations of perchloric acid [25]. Therefore, the PZC of the Pt electrode in the LiClO4 electrolyte is 0.35 V.
-
To explore the influence of the potential on structure of water molecules at Pt/LiClO4 interface, potential-dependent SHG intensities were first measured. FIG. 4 shows the SHG intensities recorded at the Pt/LiClO4 interface with concentrations of 0.1 mmol/L and 100 mmol/L when periodic triangular wave potentials were applied. The time-dependent SHG intensity exhibited periodic changes at the two concentrations (FIG. 4 (b) and (c)). However, the time-dependent SHG curves during anodic scan could not completely coincide with that of cathodic scan, which may be due to the hysteresis effect [53−55]. Furthermore, potential-dependent SHG intensities were obtained during the cathodic scan (FIG. 4(d)). The SHG intensities both showed a parabolic relationship with the applied potential. Moreover, the SHG intensity minimum was observed at 0.4 V, which is very close to the PZC obtained by the differential capacitance curves (FIG. 3(b)).
-
To obtain the contribution from water molecules in the EDL, we measured SHG phase of the Pt/LiClO4 interfaces. FIG. 5 shows SHG interference patterns for the Pt/LiClO4 interfaces with concentrations of 0.1 mmol/L and 100 mmol/L at different potentials by HD-SHG setup. Under a certain potential, the detected SHG intensity changed periodically with the position of the reference z-cut α-quartz crystal, and the period of oscillation was 53.50 mm. In addition, as the electrode potential increased, the SHG intensity maximum gradually shifted towards the right direction, indicating that there was a SHG phase difference at different electrode potentials. The phase shift with a concentration of 0.1 mmol/L was more obvious compared with that at 100 mmol/L. In order to obtain the quantitative information on the SHG phase, the SHG interference patterns were fitted with Eq.(7). Relative phases at different potentials were obtained from the fitting results. Furthermore, the SHG phase of a standard sample under a specific condition must be known to obtain the absolute phase of the Pt/LiClO4 interfaces. Xu et al. studied Pt/HClO4 interface with a concentration of 100 mmol/L using phase-sensitive SHG and concluded that the SHG phase for the Pt electrode at PZC is 90° [24]. Therefore, we assumed that the measured SHG phase of Pt/LiClO4 interface with a concentration of 100 mmol/L at 0.4 V was 90°. Following the approach established for Pt/perchlorate interfaces, we set the absolute SHG phase of the Pt electrode at its PZC to 90° under high ionic strength conditions (100 mmol/L LiClO4), consistent with phase-sensitive SHG measurements reported in the literature for analogous systems where the χ(3) contribution is negligible. This provides a fixed reference point for decomposing the potential-dependent total SHG signal. Then, the absolute SHG phase of the Pt/LiClO4 interface at different potentials can be extracted, as shown in FIG. 6(a). As the potential increased, the SHG phase of the Pt/LiClO4 interface with the concentration of 0.1 mmol/L and 100 mmol/L gradually decreased. For 0.1 mmol/L LiClO4, the SHG phase decreased by 15.9°±1.6°, which was mainly caused by the potential-induced changes in the electronic structure of the Pt electrode surface and the structure of water molecules in the EDL. For 100 mmol/L LiClO4, the SHG phase decreased by 7.0°±1.9°, which was due to the potential-induced changes in the electronic structure of the Pt electrode surface [56, 57]. The decrease in SHG phase with increasing potential arises from two main contributions: (i) potential-induced changes in the electronic structure of the Pt surface, which alter the surface nonlinear susceptibility; and (ii) the reorientation and ordering of water molecules in the EDL, which modify the χ(3) contribution. At higher ionic strength (100 mmol/L), the phase shift is primarily dominated by the electronic response of the Pt electrode, while at lower ionic strength (0.1 mmol/L), the additional phase shift is attributed to the enhanced ordering of water molecules in the extended EDL.
With the SHG intensity and phase information, we could disentangle the
$ \chi _{\text{Water}}^{(3)}\Phi (0) $ contribution from water molecules in the EDL and the χPt contribution from the Pt electrode according to Eq.(5) when the concentration of LiClO4 electrolyte was 0.1 mmol/L, as shown in FIG. 6(b). The$ \chi _{\text{Water}}^{(3)}\Phi (0) $ and χPt contributions both showed a parabolic relationship with the electrode potential, and the potential at the minimum of each curve was close to the PZC of the Pt/LiClO4 system. As the electrode potential increased, the$ \chi _{\text{Water}}^{(3)}\Phi (0) $ contribution from water molecules in the EDL first decreased until the potential arrived at PZC and then increased over PZC, indicating that the orientation of water molecules might flip at PZC. This is similar to the results obtained by Uosaki et al. using sum-frequency generation (SFG) spectroscopy to study the structure of interfacial water molecules at Pt/HClO4 interface. They found that the potential-dependent SFG intensity of OH stretching region of interfacial water exhibited parabolic behavior and the potential at the minimum was close to the PZC of Pt/HClO4 system [58]. The$ \chi _{\text{Water}}^{(3)}\Phi (0) $ contribution from the water molecules in the EDL increased as the potential became more negative or positive than the PZC, which was attributed to the more ordered arrangement of water molecules in the EDL. In addition, we found that compared with the χPt contribution, the$ \chi _{\text{Water}}^{(3)}\Phi (0) $ contribution ranged from 0% to 22%, implying that even in a very dilute LiClO4 electrolyte, the contribution from the Pt electrode surface far exceeded the contribution from water molecules in the EDL. -
To investigate the influence of ionic strength on the
$ \chi _{\text{Water}}^{(3)}\Phi (0) $ contribution, we measured SHG intensity and phase at Pt/LiClO4 interface with different ionic strengths under open circuit potential. FIG. 7 shows the time-dependent SHG intensity for the Pt/LiClO4 interface at various ionic strengths. The SHG intensity remained unchanged over time at each ionic strength. As the ionic strength increased, the SHG intensity first increased and then decreased, and changed within 30 counts, indicating that the ionic strength has little effect on the SHG intensity at the Pt/LiClO4 interface under open circuit potential.FIG. 8 shows SHG interference patterns produced by the Pt/LiClO4 interface with different ionic strengths. The maximum of SHG intensity gradually shifted towards the left direction as the ionic strength increased, which indicated that there was a SHG phase difference between different ionic strengths. The relative SHG phase could be extracted by fitting the SHG interference patterns with Eq.(7). Considering that SHG phase for the Pt/LiClO4 interface with a concentration of 100 mmol/L at PZC was 90°, the absolute phases at various ionic strengths were obtained, as shown in FIG. 9(a). The SHG phase decreased with decreasing ionic strength. When the ionic strength was 0.001 mmol/L, the SHG phase shift was 15.1°±1.9°. In addition, FIG. 9(a) also shows the variation of SHG amplitude Esig with ionic strength. Esig was obtained from the square root of SHG intensity in FIG. 7 and Esig at 100 mmol/L was normalized to 1.
The
$ \chi _{\text{Water}}^{(3)}\Phi (0) $ contributions at different ionic strengths were calculated from the measured SHG amplitude Esig and phase φsig according to Eq.(5), as shown in FIG. 9(b). It can be seen that the$ \chi _{\text{Water}}^{(3)}\Phi (0) $ contribution from water molecules in the EDL increased with decreasing ionic strength, which originated from an increase of the Debye length and the number of ordered water molecules in the EDL. -
HD-SHG spectroscopy was used to study the effects of electrode potential and ionic strength on the structure of water molecules in the EDL at the Pt/LiClO4 interface. First, the potential-dependent SHG intensity and phase at the Pt/LiClO4 interface with concentrations of 0.1 mmol/L and 100 mmol/L were measured, from which we found that the potential-dependent SHG intensity curves were parabolas, and the potential at the minimum was close to the PZC obtained by the differential capacitance curve. Secondly, the
$ \chi _{\text{Water}}^{(3)}\Phi (0) $ contribution from water molecules in the EDL and the χPt contribution from the Pt electrode at the Pt/LiClO4 interface with a concentration of 0.1 mmol/L were separated according to the SHG intensity and phase measurement results. We found that the$ \chi _{\text{Water}}^{(3)}\Phi (0) $ contribution and the χPt contribution both showed a parabolic relationship with the applied potential, and the potential at the minimum of the parabola was close to PZC. Compared with the χPt contribution, the$ \chi _{\text{Water}}^{(3)}\Phi (0) $ contribution ranged from 0% to 22%. Moreover, as the interfacial potential increased, the$ \chi _{\text{Water}}^{(3)}\Phi (0) $ contribution from water molecules in the EDL increased, which was due to the more ordered arrangement of water molecules in the EDL. In addition, the ionic strength-dependent SHG intensity and phase were measured under the open circuit potential. We found that as the ionic strength decreased, the$ \chi _{\text{Water}}^{(3)}\Phi (0) $ contribution from water molecules in the EDL increased, which was attributed to the increased number of ordered water molecules. These results provide quantitative information for the χ(3) contribution from water molecules in the EDL to the SHG response at the electrode/dilute electrolyte interfaces.
Structure of Water Molecules at Pt Electrode/Electrolyte Interface Probed by Heterodyne-Detected Second Harmonic Generation
- Received Date: 22/11/2025
- Available Online: 27/08/2026
-
Key words:
- Pt electrode /
- Heterodyne-detected second harmonic generation /
- Interface /
- Electric double layer /
- Molecular orientation
Abstract: Heterodyne-detected second harmonic generation (HD-SHG) spectroscopy was used to study the effects of potential and ionic strength on the structure of water molecules at Pt electrode/LiClO4 electrolyte interface. The contribution from Pt electrode and the third-order nonlinear susceptibility, χ(3), contribution from water molecules in the electric double layer (EDL) were separated according to the SHG intensity and phase measurements of Pt/LiClO4 interface at different potentials. The results showed that the contributions from the Pt electrode and water molecules in the EDL both presented a parabolic relationship with the applied potential, and the lowest point of the parabola was close to the potential of zero charge. Compared with the contribution from the Pt electrode, the χ(3) contribution from water molecules in the EDL ranged from 0 to 22%. Moreover, the χ(3) contribution from water molecules in the EDL increased with increasing interfacial potential, which was due to the more ordered arrangement of water molecules in the EDL. In addition, under open circuit potential, the SHG intensity and SHG phase measurements with different concentrations of LiClO4 showed that the χ(3) contribution from water molecules in the EDL increased with the decrease of ionic strength, which was attributed to the increase of the number of ordered water molecules in the EDL. These results provide quantitative information for the χ(3) contribution of water molecules in the EDL to SHG signal at the electrode/dilute electrolyte interfaces.
首页
登录
注册


DownLoad: