-
In recent years, with the increasing depletion of traditional non-renewable energy sources such as coal, petroleum, and natural gas worldwide—coupled with the massive emissions of greenhouse gases resulting from excessive reliance on fossil fuels, the living environment and sustainable development of humans face unprecedented severe challenges [1]. Issues such as intensified greenhouse effects, abnormal climate changes and ecosystem imbalances have become increasingly prominent, compelling the international community to re-examine energy structures and environmental policies [2] In this context, China has proposed the “dual carbon” goals, aiming to achieve carbon peak by 2030 and carbon neutrality by 2060. This strategic decision further underscores the urgency and importance of developing and utilizing sustainable energy [3]. Biomass, as a crucial sustainable carbon resource, boasts an annual production of approximately 200 billion tons with extensive sources [4]. It primarily originates from abundant plant matter, animal residues, microbial metabolic byproducts, and various organic wastes in nature, which are continuously regenerated through natural processes such as photosynthesis [5]. Compared to fossil fuels, biomass resources possess multiple advantages including vast reserves, widespread distribution, relatively low cost, and strong environmental compatibility. More importantly, it has been widely applied in many fields such as producing green and low-carbon liquid fuels and their additives, synthesizing high-value-added chemical raw materials and platform molecules, as well as developing environmentally friendly energy materials [6]. Therefore, the large-scale development of biomass energy can not only effectively alleviate the tension in energy supply but also significantly reduce greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions, which is crucial for China to achieve its carbon peak and carbon neutrality goals, as well as promoting the transformation of the energy structure toward cleaner alternatives [7].
Lignocellulose, as the most abundant renewable biomass resource on Earth, is widely distributed in various plant tissues in nature. Its sources mainly include hardwood, softwood, various grass plants, waste residues generated during agricultural and forestry production, as well as urban waste fiber materials [8]. Although there are certain differences in the composition of lignocellulose among different plant species (FIG. 1), the main components generally remain cellulose, hemicellulose, and lignin. In typical lignocellulose, cellulose accounts for approximately 40%−60%, hemicellulose for about 20%−40%, and lignin usually constitutes 10%−25% [9]. Additionally, it is accompanied by small amounts of pectin, various extracts, and mineral components [10]. It is noteworthy that even within the same plant, the composition and structure of lignocellulose in different tissue parts (such as roots, stems, and leaves) as well as at different growth stages may vary [11]. As shown in FIG. 2, among the three main components of lignocellulose [12], cellulose plays the role of a fundamental framework. Its molecules are composed of D-glucose units linked by β-1,4-glycosidic bonds, with tightly packed and highly ordered carbon chains exhibiting distinct parallel orientation between chains, forming a microfibrillar structure with alternating crystalline and amorphous regions [12]. Compared with cellulose, hemicellulose exhibits a relatively loose structure and binds to the surface of cellulose microfibrils through hydrogen bonding, forming an amorphous covering layer [13]. Structurally, hemicellulose not only physically interacts with cellulose but also chemically bonds with lignin through linkages such as ether bonds and ester bonds. This complex, formed jointly by hemicellulose and lignin, is termed the lignin-carbohydrate complex (LCC), which acts as a “binder” in the cell wall, filling the gaps between cellulose microfibrils and enhancing integrity and mechanical strength. Lignin is a complex three-dimensional network aromatic polymer that crosslinks with cellulose and hemicellulose through ether and ester bonds, particularly tending to form stable ester bond connections with hemicellulose. It encapsulates cellulose and hemicellulose within its network, thereby further expanding to form a robust polyphenolic macromolecular structure [14]. It can be seen that various components in lignocellulose are intertwined through various chemical bonds and physical interactions, collectively forming the highly complex and antagonistic overall structure. The chemical diversity of these components and the complexity of interactions between them not only endow lignocellulose with superior biological functions and material properties but also pose significant challenges for the efficient and thorough separation of three main components, as well as the realization of biomass resource utilization and valorization.
There is no doubt that we can directly use or convert lignocellulose to meet the demands of various fields. However, this approach not only significantly increases the difficulty of subsequent applications but may also lead to severe waste of certain high-value components in lignocellulose. Therefore, selecting or developing an efficient separation method to thoroughly overcome the inherent recalcitrance of lignocellulose and further promoting the efficient utilization and conversion of each component, have been widely recognized as a more efficient and preferred technical pathway. Currently, many researchers have developed various methods for the component separation of lignocellulose, generally categorized into physical, chemical, and biological approaches [15]. Among these, chemical methods can avoid the drawbacks of biological methods, such as long cycles, low efficiency, and high costs, as well as the high energy consumption and costs associated with physical methods, making them highly regarded for component separation. And the traditional chemical methods such as alkaline or acid methods have achieved effective separation and extraction of cellulose to a certain extent. However, they are often accompanied by some issues including severe environmental pollution, excessive energy consumption, and incomplete separation of components [7]. Therefore, developing environmentally friendly, highly efficient, and mild component separation methods of lignocellulose remains a key research focus and challenge in this field. The organic solvents, ionic liquids (ILs), and deep eutectic solvents (DESs) methods have attracted extensive attention from researchers due to their high efficiency in full-component separation, superior selectivity of desirable products, and relatively environmentally friendly nature [16−18]. This review therefore focuses on current advances in the above three methods, while also providing a detailed summary of three main components of lignocellulose, as well as their utilization in chemical raw materials and energy production (FIG. 3). Moreover, the developments are also discussed based on separation methods and practical production. Our goal is to elucidate the separation mechanisms and principles of method design, providing guidance for the development of efficient component separation methods of lignocellulose. We believe that this review will inspire more creativity in designing such win−win component separation methods of lignocellulosic biomass.
-
To ensure a comprehensive and up-to-date overview of the advances in component separation of lignocellulosic biomass, a systematic literature search and selection process was conducted. The methodology aimed to cover the most significant scientific outputs, particularly emphasizing emerging research from 2023 to 2025. Among which, the literature searches were primarily performed using major academic databases, including Web of Science Core Collection, Scopus, and Google Scholar. The search strategy combined keywords related to the feedstock (lignocellulosic biomass and lignocellulose), the process (component separation, fractionation, and pretreatment), and the solvents (organic solvents, ionic liquids, deep eutectic solvents). Accordingly, the primary focus was on literature published between 2020 and 2025, with particular effort to include and critically assess nearly all emerging works from 2023 to 2025. The inclusion criteria were composed of original research articles and review papers focusing on novel solvent-based separation methods, studies reporting mechanistic insights, process optimization, or innovative applications of separated components. Furthermore, the initial search results were screened based on titles and abstracts to identify relevant studies. The full texts of the selected publications were then thoroughly analyzed. The information was categorized by the main components of lignocellulose as well as their utilization, the three types of methods for separating lignocellulose, and challenges and prospects based on research and summary. This structured approach allowed for a coherent synthesis of the current state of the art, identification of research trends, and a critical discussion of future challenges, as presented in this review.
-
Cellulose is a linear homopolysaccharide composed of D-glucose units linked by β-1,4-glycosidic bonds (FIG. 2), with a molecular weight ranging from approximately 50,000 to 2,500,000, equivalent to 300−15,000 sugar units. The degree of polymerization of wood cellulose can reach up to 10,000, while that of cotton can reach up to 15,000 [19]. The linear structure of the polymer chain with hydroxyl groups evenly distributed on both sides, enables cellulose to align in parallel at the nanoscale into an extensible, flat, and double-helical crystalline structure, thereby forming the initial elementary fibers [13]. These elementary fibers further aggregate to form larger structures, such as nanofibers, micron-scale fibers, and millimeter fibers, wherein the fiber bundles are bonded through hydrogen bonding between hydroxyl groups. These hydrogen bonds are inherently directional, promoting the oriented arrangement of cellulose molecules and contributing to cellulose crystallization. However, intramolecular hydrogen bonding tends to cause a relatively uniform charge distribution within cellulose molecules, thereby reducing intermolecular directional forces and hindering crystallization, thus forming loosely packed amorphous regions. Additionally, the ratio of ordered to disordered in cellulose can be used to assess the crystallinity of cellulose. Generally, a higher relative crystallinity endows cellulose with greater mechanical toughness, as the crystalline regions are 3−30 times more resistant to degradation compared to amorphous regions, thereby slowing down the conversion process [8, 20].
Hemicellulose is a polymeric polysaccharide composed of pentoses (xylose, arabinose), hexoses (glucose, mannose, and galactose), and trace sugars (Rhamnus and fructose), along with small quantities of uronic acids and acetyl groups [21]. The main aggregated polysaccharides formed include xylan, polygalactose-glucomannan, polyarabino-galactose, glucomannan, and poly glucose. Unlike cellulose, hemicellulose has a polymerization degree of 500-3000, with a much lower molecular weight than cellulose [22]. Hemicellulose exhibits a random amorphous structure, demonstrating lower stability. Additionally, due to its hydrophilic nature, hemicellulose also possesses water-absorbing properties. Due to the above three factors, the solvents for component separation or other catalysts can more easily access it, making it more prone to depolymerize and convert into small-molecule compounds compared to cellulose and lignin [9].
Lignin is the sole naturally renewable resource containing aromatic benzene rings [9, 23]. In lignification process, carbon dioxide and water are first converted into sugars, which subsequently form three types of acids (sinapic acid, ferulic acid, and p-coumaric acid) by various enzymes, followed by the formation of coniferyl alcohol (G), sinapyl alcohol (S), and p-coumaryl alcohol (H), which ultimately produce a three-dimensional cross-linked aromatic polymer composed of three major phenolic units (FIG. 4), which are connected via C−O bonds (β-O-4, α-O-4) and C−C bonds (5-5, β-β, β-1, β-5) [23−27]. The primary distinction among these phenolic units lies in their varying degrees of methoxylation [28]. Notably, lignin also contains a variety of valuable functional groups such as phenolic hydroxyl, aliphatic hydroxyl, carbonyl, and methoxyl groups, among others, which endow it with diverse reactivity [29]. From a functional perspective, lignin imparts hydrophobicity to lignocellulosic biomass and provides a rigid structure that protects internal carbohydrates from bacterial, chemical, and enzymatic attacks [30]. However, this also presents challenges in terms of the efficient utilization and value-added conversion of lignocellulose.
-
Currently, there are two main pathways for the conversion and utilization of lignocellulose. One involves the direct conversion of raw lignocellulosic materials into desired products, but this often sacrifices one or two other components to maximize the target product. The other pathway involves the efficient separation of the three main components (cellulose, hemicellulose, and lignin), followed by their respective high-efficiency conversion into different desirable products. This approach enables the simultaneous utilization of multiple components and reduces reliance on downstream separation processes, aligning more closely with the concept of biofinery. This is also why many researchers continue to focus on component separation methods. In lignocellulose, cellulose/hemicellulose accounts for the highest proportion, being polysaccharide polymers themselves. Apart from being directly degraded into monosaccharides or low-degree-of-polymerization polysaccharides for direct use or as fermentation feedstock, they can also be processed and subsequently reacted to generate a series of biomass intermediate derivatives, primarily oxygen-containing C2−C6 biomass platform molecules [12]. These platform molecules, as substrate chemicals, can be converted into multiple high-value-added chemicals. The main components include furan compounds and their derivatives (furfural, 5-hydroxymethylfurfural, 2,5-furandicarboxylic acid), organic acids (levulinic acid, 3-hydroxypropionic acid, succinic acid, lactic acid), alcohols (glycerol, ethanol, sorbitol, xylitol), and biomass alkanes [31]. In addition, nitrogen-containing compounds have played a critical role in recent years, but are mainly derived from petrochemical processes [32]. Therefore, it is essential to produce nitrogen-containing compounds from sustainable lignocellulose, which has led to the development of some bio-based nitrogen-containing compounds.
Among them, furfural is mainly derived from the hemicellulose component (xylose/xylan), with a molecular weight of 96.08 [33]. The molecular structure contains a furan ring group, a aldehyde group, and two unsaturated double bonds (FIG. 5). These properties make furfural chemically reactive, prone to undergoing reduction, oxidation, condensation, nitration, and other reactions to produce various chemicals that can replace those derived from traditional fossil energy processing [34]. Additionally, furfural can be reduced to furfuryl alcohol, which is widely used in the food additive, resin, and adhesive industries. It can also undergo hydrogenation and ring-opening to form long-chain alcohols (1,5-pentanediol, pentanol) [35]. Recent studies have employed biphasic systems to achieve the efficient separation of lignocellulose, with pentanol serving as a key solvent. Gao et al. [36] employed a pentanol biphasic system to separate corn stover, indicating that this system yields higher glucose recovery and lignin recovery compared to methanol monophasic system, while the obtained lignin exhibits higher reactivity. For such biphasic separation systems, if xylose derived from hemicellulose hydrolysis can be efficiently and directionally converted into pentanol, it would further enable the self-recycling or replenishment of solvents. This approach ensures both the green separation and circular utilization of the separation solvents. Therefore, if researchers achieve high-selectivity production of pentanol, this approach may be a promising direction for further investigation. Additionally, Lv et al. [37] successfully achieved efficient separation of lignocellulose by using hemicellulose-derived diformylxylose as a bio-based solvent, similar to the report of Zhang et al. [38] who also effectively separated lignocellulose by employing lignin monomer derivatives and ethylene glycol. Specifically, the development of sustainable solvents for biomass biorefineries remains a pivotal challenge in green chemistry, thus warranting focused attention on exploring more biomass-derived solvents for component separation.
Compared to furfural, 5-hydroxymethylfurfural (HMF) has relatively broader sources, which can be derived from cellulose/hemicellulose components (fructose, glucose), disaccharides (sucrose, maltose, cellobiose), and polysaccharides (inulin, starch, cellulose) [39]. It contains a furan ring, an aldehyde group, a hydroxymethyl group, and two unsaturated double bonds, with one more hydroxymethyl group than the furfural molecule (FIG. 5). Although HMF is chemically reactive and not easily applied directly on a commercial scale, its derivative products [40] have extensive coverage and significant market potential (FIG. 6). For example, 2,5-furandicarboxylic acid, listed by the U.S. Department of Energy as one of the top ten high-value-added biomass-based chemicals, can be derived from HMF [41]. Additionally, HMF can be converted into 2,5-dihydroxymethylfuran, 2,5-dimethylfuran, 2,5-dihydroxymethyl tetrahydrofuran, and 2,5-dimethyl tetrahydrofuran, which can serve as gasoline additives and biomass-based fuels [42]. Among these, 2,5-dihydroxymethylfuran is particularly noteworthy. The main challenge in achieving highly selective hydrogenation of HMF to 2,5-dihydroxymethylfuran lies in suppressing side reactions such as hydrogenation of the furan ring, ring-opening, and hydrodeoxygenation of hydroxyl groups [12]. Guo et al. [43] employed a Pd2N1/SBA-15 catalyst, which achieved the best performance, converting 99.0% of HMF to 2,5-dihydroxymethylfuran with 96.0% selectivity, surpassing previously reported catalysts.
Moreover, cellulose and hemicellulose also serve as important raw materials for nitrogen-containing compounds. Among them, bis(aminomethyl) furan represents one of the most promising primary diamines for synthesizing novel polymers with unique functionalities [44]. The multiple reaction mechanisms and research progress can be found in the review by Ji et al. [45]. In addition, cellulose/hemicellulose has been widely applied in the materials field, such as optical metamaterials [46], battery electrodes [47], hydrogels, emulsions, and aerogels, demonstrating their potential for sustainable development across various domains including energy production and healthcare applications.
Lignin has the lowest content in lignocellulose but the highest carbon content, accounting for approximately 40% [48]. At the same time, it is also the component with relatively low utilization during the separation process, especially in traditional separation methods (such as alkaline pulping process and ethanol production processes), where it is often regarded as a waste material and directly used as fuel, leading to resource wastage [49]. This significantly reduces its potential utilization value. Converting lignin into high-value products is an important area in the application of lignocellulose energy conversion, and it plays a crucial role in improving overall biorefinery efficiency. Lignin can be widely applied in the production of chemicals raw materials and green liquid fuels after depolymerization or chemical modification [50]. To date, numerous studies [51] have reported on selective cleavage of the C−O/C−C bonds of lignin to depolymerize it into phenolic products, cycloalkane products, alcohol products, and aromatic monomer products, as well as direct one-pot hydrodeoxygenation for producing liquid fuels (FIG. 7).
The important lignin-derived chemical platform molecules are phenol, cresol, anisole, toluene, guaiacol, and benzaldehyde. In the study by Xu et al. [52], aqueous diethylamine was used under high solid content conditions, not only achieving the efficient utilization of lignin aromatic benzene rings, but also converting into high-value-added nitrogen-containing compounds. This may also remind researchers that lignin functional groups might possess significant potential for chemical applications. Therefore, the separate or complementary conversion of side chain groups and aromatic benzene rings will be a key research direction for future development. Furthermore, to overcome the excessive reliance of traditional depolymerization methods on high-pressure hydrogen and considering both safety and energy sustainability, our group has also made some progress [53−56]. Structurally, lignin can provide a large number of reactive phenolic hydroxyl groups, rigid benzene rings, and carbonyl structures. Therefore, it is also an ideal material that simultaneously possesses adsorption capabilities, resistance to thermal aging, oxidation resistance, high-temperature deformation resistance, as well as excellent biocompatibility and good biodegradability. This includes lignin-based composite materials (lignin and chitosan), lignin-based carbon capture materials, lignin-based organic dye adsorption materials, preparation of high-temperature-resistant or oxidation-resistant modified resins, modified asphalts, as well as lignin-based hydrogels and other materials [57−59]. Moreover, the application of lignin in energy storage has also become a major research focus in recent years [60]. Consequently, the low-cost, scalable and environmentally friendly production of lignin-derived carbon through component separation has emerged as a key area of research.
-
In the early pulping process, organic solvents have been used in lignin removal, which led to the development of lignocellulose separation with organic solvents. The reaction temperature of this method is usually in the range of 120−250 °C, and there is a variety of commonly used organic solvents including alcohols, ketones, esters, acids, among others [61]. In recent years, several novel organic solvents have been investigated for lignocellulose separation, such as methyl isobutyl ketone (MIBK), γ-valerolactone (GVL), and tetrahydrofuran (THF). According to numerous studies, the mechanism of lignocellulose separation with organic solvents is related to the protonicity of solvents. Polar protic solvents including methanol, ethanol, and ethylene glycol (EG) can disrupt the intermolecular binding bonds between lignin and hemicellulose during the separation process, as well as cleaving the ether bonds of lignin structure and the glycosidic bonds of hemicellulose. Additionally, these solvents can also dissolve lignin oligomers and oligosaccharides, thereby inhibiting their repolymerization [62, 63]. However, polar aprotic solvents such as THF and GVL can only act as solvents. Their solvent properties result in a weak ionization capacity, meaning they are unable to cleave the chemical bonds in lignocellulose. In contrast, water can act as a nucleophilic reagent to participate in cleaving chemical bonds. Consequently, such polar aprotic solvents are often combined with nucleophilic reagents like water to form cosolvent methods for synergistic lignocellulose separation [64]. Compared with other chemical separation methods, the use of organic solvents can reduce biomass recalcitrance while simultaneously enhancing cellulose conversion efficiency and enabling the recovery of relatively intact lignin with a low degree of condensation [65]. Furthermore, methods such as distillation can be employed to recover organic solvents following separation for cyclic reuse.
-
Component separation using organic solvents primarily employs ethanol-based methods, and related research has been well established. Advantages of ethanol include low toxicity, low boiling point, low cost and ease of recovery, and it can also effectively reduce water viscosity and improve the ability of solvents to dissolve lignocellulose [66]. Furthermore, adding acid or base catalysts in separation processes can enhance efficiency or enable equivalent performance at a lower reaction temperatures and shorter reaction times. Zhang et al. [67] used ethanol to separate balsa wood, adding different Lewis acid catalysts (AlCl3, CuCl2, and FeCl3) to the ethanol solution. The results showed that AlCl3 exhibited optimal separation efficiency, achieving a 67.69% lignin removal rate and an 85.91% saccharification yield, and the obtained lignin has the advantages of small and homogeneous molecules as well as abundant functional groups for numerous applications. Ni et al. [68] employed CrCl3-catalyzed ethanol separation of poplar wood to achieve near-complete removal of lignin (Ea=18.03 kJ·mol−1) and hemicellulose (Ea=24.15 kJ·mol−1) under mild conditions (FIG. 8(a)), and the results indicated that the activation energy for dissolving lignin and hemicellulose in mixed solvents is significantly lower than that reported in other studies. Density function theory (DFT) calculations and molecular dynamics (MD) visualization also revealed the mechanism including electronic distribution, hydrogen bonding effects, and reaction activity, while elucidating that ethanol simultaneously suppresses lignin recondensation by acting as a capping agent through steric hindrance. Specifically, this system enhances molecular polarity, expands hydrogen bond networks, and reduces the gap of orbits, which synergistically catalyzes the bond cleavage of lignocellulose and suppresses side reactions, thus providing molecular-level theoretical support for the industrial application of Lewis acid-organic solvent separation method. Building on the exploration of ethanol-based methods, Li et al. [69] demonstrated that the organic separation of alkaline ethanol and glycerol can disrupt the complex internal structure of lignocellulose, achieving more efficient lignin removal and enhancing the accessibility of cellulose to enzymes. However, this method has a weak effect on hemicellulose degradation, thereby exhibiting relatively high retention efficiency. Recently, Chen et al. [70] employed a mixed solvent of 25% ethanol and water for bagasse separation, where the solid substrate was fixed above the interior of the reactor, out of direct contact with solvents, and 4 MPa of CO2 was introduced into the reactor. And this method strengthens the separation of components via cooling-induced vapor−liquid phase transition of the solvent, meaning that no additional solid−liquid separation was required after the reaction. Mechanistically, Aspen process simulation was employed to conduct flash vaporization calculations, clarifying the correlation between the vapor-phase composition and the removal efficiency of lignin, and retention efficiency of cellulose with both good structural homogeneity for downstream application. Additionally, life cycle assessment (LCA) revealed a global warming potential (GWP) of 16.22 kg CO2 eq·kg−1 for cellulose-rich pulp under 25% ethanol condition, significantly lower than that of 50% ethanol systems (22.66 kg CO2 eq·kg−1), highlighting the environmental benefits of reduced organic solvent usage (FIG. 8 (b) and (c)).
EG possesses a high boiling point, which mitigates the risk of high pressure during separation. However, more energy is required for solvent recovery than low-boiling-point alcohols [71]. Although it can be derived from biomass, petroleum-based feedstocks remain the predominant source at present resulting in classifying as a common solvent. Fan et al. [72] investigated wheat straw separation with ethanol, EG, and glycerol (FIG. 8(g)). DFT and MD results demonstrated that EG with a binary hydroxyl structure, forms stronger hydrogen bond networks and non-covalent interactions with lignin, exhibiting optimal performance in lignin removal, β-O-4 bond retention, and carbohydrate conversion. The results also elucidated the regulatory mechanism of hydroxyl groups in alcohol solvents on lignin dissolution and structural stability related to molecular polarity, interaction strength, and reaction activity, thus providing theoretical support for precise solvent selection and catalytic system optimization of lignocellulose separation. Ling et al. [73] employed an EG/water system for bagasse separation, showing a hemicellulose removal rate of 43.2% and a lignin removal rate of 29.1%, respectively. And the addition of hydrochloric acid significantly improves both hemicellulose removal rate and cellulose hydrolysis yield. On the basis of exploring acid catalyzed EG methods, Zhang et al. [38] employed p-toluenesulfonic acid (PTSA) in the EG system to efficiently separate corn stover. The results showed that the synergistic effect between the PTSA and EG significantly increases the efficiency of lignin removal, raising the delignification rate from 43.43% (PTSA in an aqueous solution for separation) to 85.37%. And the recovered lignin exhibits more than 90% purity and a low molecular weight, making it highly valuable for downstream applications. Collectively, the advantages of using EG for component separation include reducing the surface tension of the separation system to disrupt lignocellulose structure, forming strong hydrogen bonds with lignin via its hydroxyl groups to solubilize it efficiently and inhibit condensation, and forming hydrogen bonds with carbohydrates to protect cellulose or hemicellulose, thereby achieving selective delignification. Following the removal of lignin and some hemicellulose, a porous structure forms on the lignocellulose surface, which reduces non-specific adsorption of cellulose and significantly enhances accessibility for enzymatic hydrolysis.
Based on the application of EG, 1,4-butanediol (1,4-BDO) has gained attention due to its four-carbon chain structure longer than the two-carbon chain of EG and its spatial conformation that better accommodates the spatial arrangement of lignin side chains. Du et al. [74] employed 1,4-BDO to separate poplar wood through experiments and DFT calculations (FIG. 8 (d) and (e)). The results confirmed that the PTSA/1,4-BDO system could remove 84.78% of lignin and 85.55% of hemicellulose under optimal conditions. DFT calculations also showed that 1,4-BDO forms stronger hydrogen bonds with lignin (−2.43 kcal·mol−1) than EG (−2.41 kcal·mol−1) through its terminal hydroxyl groups, and establishes nearly planar π-π conjugation with lignin benzene rings resulting in enhancing molecular binding stability. Furthermore, the dual hydroxyl structure of 1,4-BDO can protect lignin β-O-4 bonds via α-ethylation reactions, thus reducing main-chain breakage and condensation. Accordingly, Song et al. [75] systematically compared the separation effects of ethanol, EG, and 1,4-BDO as organic solvents on bagasse under AlCl3 catalysis and the AlCl3/1,4-BDO system exhibited optimal performance, achieving 90.3% cellulose retention, 81.7% delignification rate, and 58.8% furfural yield (FIG. 8(f)). DFT and MD results revealed that 1,4-BDO can enhance biomass deconstruction and target product formation by forming a stable hydrogen bond network, increasing total energy density (−8692.4 kcal·mol−1), and optimizing adsorption-desorption equilibrium, while synergistically improving enzymatic hydrolysis efficiency through etherification modification of lignin with a well-preserved structure thus providing molecular-level evidence for precise selection of solvent-catalyst combinations.
-
In recent years, green biomass-derived solvents have been widely used for separating components of lignocellulose. These solvents have demonstrated promising performance in this application due to their environmental friendliness and compatibility with biorefinery processes, which can also be synthesized using sustainable biomass feedstocks such as proteins, carbohydrates, vegetable oils, and animal fats via enzymatic conversion, fermentation, and chemical transformation processes [76]. THF has high polarity and a low boiling point, as well as a high vapor pressure at room temperature which makes it easy to recover, and can be synthesized by the decarboxylation of furfural, followed by hydrogenation. Zhao et al. [77] separated lignocellulose using a THF/water system at 200 °C for 1 h, achieving a 91.4% lignin removal rate and 140.4 mg/mL enzymatic glucose yield. Accordingly, Liang et al. [78] showed via MD simulations that THF exhibits weaker hydrogen bonding with lignin, where the strength of hydrogen bonding determines depolymerization efficiency. Consequently, lignin molecules in the THF system have more stable conformations and are less physically entangled, which effectively prevents excessive depolymerization and intermolecular condensation. This molecular-level explanation provides a rationale for THF separation of lignocellulose, which possessed higher β-O-4 bond retention rates of lignin with eliminating G-condensation units and increasing the content of aliphatic hydroxyl groups.
GVL is another biomass-derived solvent produced by hydrogenating levulinic acid (LA), which has been extensively investigated for its role in delignification and in enhancing enzymatic hydrolysis. Huber et al. [79] systematically investigated the structural evolution characteristics of poplar lignin during GVL-assisted separation. The results revealed that the content of β-O-4 linkages and aliphatic hydroxyl groups, and relative molecular weight of lignin are comparable to those of lignin by enzymatic hydrolysis. Based on these results, it can be inferred that the GVL separation method enables the efficient separation of lignin with high quality. In addition, researchers have explored strategies to improve the separation efficiency of GVL. Zhang et al. [80] employed a GVL/water system combined with hydrochloric acid (HCl). The results showed that the hemicellulose and lignin removal rates were 80% and 68% respectively, and a cellulose enzymatic hydrolysis yield of 65%. They also observed that the chloride ions in the hydrochloric acid interact with carbocations during lignin depolymerization, thereby promoting further lignin removal. Yin et al. [81] improved the GVL system by substituting inorganic acid with PTSA and chose bamboo as the substrate for achieving efficient removal of lignin (with short side chains, uniform molecule weight distribution and high degree of purify) and hemicellulose under mild conditions, while retaining high cellulose content and enhancing enzymatic hydrolysis efficiency. MD and DFT results jointly demonstrated that GVL inhibits lignin condensation through optimized compatibility, physical barrier, and electronic interactions, synergizing with the acid-catalytic effect of PTSA for the efficient lignin removal and high-purity structure retention of lignin in the experiment.
Besides THF and GVL, other emerging biomass-derived solvents have also been developed. Dimethyl isosorbide (DMI) can be synthesized through the catalysis of D-glucose. Yang et al. [82] separated lignocellulose using a DMI/water system with sulfuric acid as the catalyst. The results showed this method exhibits excellent component separation and conversion performance, and the purity of lignin recovered was as high as 92.9%, and over 90% of DMI could be retrieved through distillation. Subsequently, Yang et al. [83] investigated the DMI mechanism through MD simulations to elucidate the molecular mechanisms of lignin dissolution. Lignin exhibits a collapsed structure in pure water; whereas in the DMI/water system, it adopts an extended conformation with a significantly increased solvent-accessible surface area. The interactions are predominantly van der Waals forces and the DMI/water (9/1, V/V) achieved the lowest non-bonded interaction energy, as well as the number of contact pairs between lignin and water molecules is 2−5 times higher than that in pure water. Additionally, calculations analyzing the σ-potential confirmed that the intermolecular interactions between DMI and cosolvents are weak, while their affinity for lignin is stronger. At a DMI/water ratio of 9/1, the hydrogen bond acceptor capacity is optimal, with the σ-potential becoming more negative in the hydrogen bond acceptor region, further enhancing interactions with lignin thus this high dissolution efficiency of this ratio is verified from the thermodynamic perspective (FIG. 9). However, there are several limitations to biomass-derived solvents. The capital and operational costs of these solvents are considerably high. Although they can achieve high lignin removal efficiency under harsh conditions, they cause structural destruction of lignin, reducing its potential for high-value utilization. In contrast, mild conditions preserve the lignin structure, but result in high residual lignin content. Currently, the molecular interactions underlying solvent-induced structural changes are unclear, and it is not possible to predict lignin solubility using a single parameter. The predictive value of existing quantum models is also limited [76].
-
As an increasing number of organic solvents have been developed and utilized, some studies have demonstrated that it is often difficult to achieve the synergistic optimization of component separation in terms of efficiency, selectivity, and the subsequent utilization of value-added products in homogeneous solvents. Consequently, researchers have adopted multiphase solvents, which are constructed by combining various organic solvents for synergistic and complementary separation of lignocellulose. Grande et al. [84] developed a biphasic system consisting of water and 2-methyltetrahydrofuran with the addition of oxalic acid (OA). The results showed that hemicellulose and lignin can be dissolved in the aqueous phase and organic phase, respectively, enabling the simultaneous component separation. Additionally, biphasic methods based on MIBK have also been explored for their superior performance in converting carbohydrates to high-value platform compounds. Sweygerset et al. [85] employed MIBK and water to separate bamboo at 177 °C for 1 h. The results showed that since HMF and furfural can be rapidly dissolved in the organic MIBK phase, the formation of LA is effectively inhibited, resulting in a high conversion efficiency of cellulose and hemicellulose into furfural and HMF. And the kinetic analysis revealed that the core mechanism of bamboo hydrolysis is particle size-governed reaction kinetics. Particles measuring less than 2.5 mm follows homogeneous first-order kinetics, while particles measuring 2.5 mm or more fit the shrinking core model. Moreover, the larger the particle size, the lower the acid diffusion and reaction contact efficiency, leading to a significant decrease in the hydrolysis rate constant (FIG. 10(a)). Furthermore, Zhang et al. [86] proposed a biphasic system involving phenoxyethanol and water that is low in water consumption, alkali assisted and recyclable. Notably, when the recovered phenoxyethanol was recycled, the removal rate of lignin remained at around 80%, and the enzymatic hydrolysis yield of the residue was 71.26%. Additionally, the merits of this method in preserving lignin structure and enhancing reactivity have also been widely studied. Gao et al. [36] separated corn stover using a pentanol-water biphasic system. Under optimal conditions, they achieved a lignin removal rate of 82.8%, a xylan removal rate approaching 100%, and a stable glucan recovery rate of 94.3%. The results demonstrated lignin can rapidly dissolve into the pentanol phase, effectively inhibiting the repolymerization of lignin and significantly enhancing reactivity. Researchers have further improved the efficiency of separation through synergistic catalysis. Meysam et al. [87] modified this biphasic system by incorporating PTSA and AlCl3 in poplar separation. DFT calculations revealed that the H+ ions from PTSA and Al3+ weaken the ester and ether bonds of LCC via electrostatic attraction. Meanwhile, PTSA and pentanol replace the original intermolecular hydrogen bonds in the complexes by forming stronger hydrogen bonds. Specifically, combined with the phase separation effect of pentanol, the depolymerized lignin dissolves in the organic phase, achieving complete separation from the carbohydrates and ultimately completing the synergistic disintegration of the LCC. And the results showed that scaling this biorefinery model to process 140 million tons of poplar biomass annually reduces CO2 emissions by 75.3 million tons and provides socioeconomic savings of $17.3 billion, supporting sustainable industrial transformation (FIG. 10(b)). Thus, incorporating auxiliary reagents or synergistic catalysts into biphasic systems can weaken the key chemical bonds of LCC and compete with intermolecular hydrogen bonds for replacement, thereby accelerating the separation of lignocellulose components. Meanwhile, this process can prevent adverse reactions such as lignin repolymerization and by-product formation. It can also promote the conversion of target components into high-value products and significantly improve the efficiency of separation and subsequent valorization processes. In summary, biphasic solvents achieve precise component separation by exploiting phase separation, thereby overcoming the insufficient separation selectivity of homogeneous solvents. Furthermore, the synergistic effect between the organic and aqueous phases accelerates mass transfer, while the recyclability of solvents balances separation efficiency and cost. Most importantly, they are more effective at preserving the active structures of components. This effectively overcomes the shortcomings of homogeneous solvents in the synergistic optimization of multiple objectives, making them a key area of research.
-
Table I systematically summarizes the key characteristics of diverse solvent systems applied in lignocellulose component separation, encompassing the typical types of solvents, their core separation mechanisms, prominent performance advantages, existing technical limitations as well as applicable biomass substrates. This tabular compilation provides a concise and intuitive comparative perspective on the applicability and technical trade-offs of different solvent systems, offering a quick reference for the selection and optimization of solvent-based lignocellulose separation strategies in subsequent research and industrial practice.
-
ILs, also known as molten salts, typically consist of asymmetric organic cations and inorganic anions. However, some ILs consist of organic cations and anions, all of which are in the liquid state under most ambient conditions due to the combination of larger organic cations whose positive moieties are affected by steric hindrance or shielding effects, and smaller inorganic anions [88]. Due to their cation and anion composition, ILs also possess low volatility, non-flammability, favorable electrochemical properties, and high thermal stability [89]. The types of cations and anions can be tailored to produce distinct physicochemical properties such as viscosity, miscibility, polarity, hydrogen bonding, basicity, and melting point [90]. Thus, ILs with desired physicochemical properties can be produced to meet specific research requirements. For example, cellulose is more soluble in ILs with small molecule cations because large molecule cations induce steric hindrance effects with cellulose, making it difficult to form effective hydrogen bonding interactions and impairing the dissolution process [91].
-
The most common ILs used for separating lignocellulose are imidazolium, pyridinium, and quaternary ammonium salts. Among them, imidazolium salts are primarily used for cellulose dissolution, whereas quaternary ammonium salts are used for lignin removal. Xu et al. [92] employed 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium acetate ([Bmim]OAc) to extract cellulose and added a certain proportion of LiCl, LiOAc, LiNO3 or LiBr to the solvent. The results demonstrated that the solubility of cellulose in the ILs increases significantly and Li+ ions form non-covalent interactions with oxygen atoms in some cellulose hydroxyl groups thus disrupting the intermolecular hydrogen bonds of cellulose. Shuai et al. [93] developed a series of superbase dicarboxylate ILs, which achieved precise regulation of amphiphilicity by adjusting the carbon chain length (C2–C10) of dicarboxylate anions to control the cellulose dissolution and regeneration. Studies revealed that cellulose possesses both hydrophobic (pyranose ring skeleton) and hydrophilic (hydroxyl groups) properties, in which hydrophobic chains (C5–C6) can interact with the pyranose rings of cellulose to facilitate solvent penetration, while hydrophilic anion heads form hydrogen bonds with the hydroxyl groups (FIG. 11(a)). Additionally, Zhang et al. [94] designed novel ILs produced by proton transfer reaction between superbases and dicarboxylic acids, and it endows the solvents with more hydrogen bonding sites, achieving synergistic enhancement of dissolution efficiency and material functionalization. Moreover, in addition to cationic structures, researchers have also been attracted to the influence of anionic components on component separation. Miranda et al. [95] synthesized various ILs, and the results demonstrated that the propionate anion has a stronger affinity for lignin, thus making it easier to cleave the β-O-4 ether bonds in lignin. Simplifying the synthesis and reducing the cost of ILs can be also important direction for promoting their industrial application. Gladden et al. [96] developed a new method for in-situ synthesis of ILs in which they used hydroxyethylammonium acetate ([Eth][OAc]) for the direct separation of sorghum. The results showed that these ILs achieve comparable sugar yields to the pre-synthesized ILs. Furthermore, it can be concluded that the complex macromolecular network structure of lignocellulose can be used as a heat sink to efficiently absorb the excess heat generated by the acid-base neutralization reaction between ethanolamine and acetic acid, thus reducing energy consumption, realizing efficient energy utilization, and eliminating subsequent ionic solvent purification steps. The LCA results also demonstrated a GHG emission footprint of 1.4 kg CO2 eq·kg−1PIL−1, representing a 59% reduction compared to solvent-based synthesis and a 30% decrease relative to solvent-free synthesis, fully meeting the target of over 30% GHG reduction.
Introducing functional groups is an effective way to enhance the dissolution of lignocellulose. Zhu et al. [97] discovered that incorporating amino or hydroxyl functional groups into ILs can enhance the solubility of lignocellulose and inhibit cellulose degradation. 3-Aminopropanol was found to significantly improve the solubility of wheat straw in 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium acetate ([EMIM]OAc). It is worth noting that the above studies mainly focused on cellulose dissolution. However, understanding of lignin dissolution mechanisms in ILs is crucial for promoting the efficient component separation of lignocellulose, and the related research is becoming increasingly in-depth. Manna et al. [98] investigated the molecular mechanism of lignin dissolution using a lignin cluster composed of 5-guaiacyl decamer chains in [EMIM]OAc/water system via MD simulations. The results showed that lignin forms compact aggregates in pure water. In contrast, in [EMIM]OAc system, lignin undergoes chain disentanglement and extensive dynamic motion, adopting an extended conformation. The results also showed that OAc primarily interacts with the alkyl chains and hydroxyl groups of lignin, while the tail of Emim+ interacted with the benzene rings and the head with the methoxy and hydroxyl groups (FIG. 11(b)). Additionally, Hou et al. [99] separated rice straw with choline cationic solvents and demonstrated through DFT and MD simulations that the deconstruction efficiency of choline-based solvents depends on the balance between low solvent interaction energy and high interaction energy with lignin. Anions disrupt intramolecular hydrogen bonds in lignin through strong hydrogen bonding or electrostatic interactions, while cations stabilize these bonds via van der Waals forces. Furthermore, the interaction strength is directly regulated by the functional group type and alkyl chain length of solvent (FIG. 11(c)). Due to the high cost and difficulty of recovering ILs, Achinivu et al. [100] developed an innovative method for separating lignocellulose using distillable ILs. The results demonstrated that the single recovery rate of ethanolamine acetate ([EthA][OAc]) reached 85%, with the recovered product being reusable without additional purification and no significant by-products during the recycling process. Based on a biomass processing scale of 2000 dry tons per day, a comprehensive technology and economic analysis (TEA) was conducted covering the entire process flow, including separation, enzymatic hydrolysis, ILs recovery, sugar purification, wastewater treatment, and energy generation. The results indicated that the distillation method is more costly than conventional processes. However, the sugar cost can be reduced to $0.57 kg−1 by optimizing vacuum levels, IL recovery rates, and solid loading capacity (FIG. 11(d)).
-
Recently, researchers have also used water or certain organic solvents as cosolvents for synergistic component separation with ILs where cosolvents can reduce the consumption of ILs and improve the dissolution of lignocellulose. To address the limitations of ethylenediamine (EDA) alone in separating corn stalks, particularly its limited lignin removal efficiency and insufficient potential for high-value product production, Jia et al. [101] developed a synergistic separation system combining 1-butyl-3-ethylimidazolium chloride and EDA. This system achieved a 96.05% lignin removal rate and nearly 100% removal of hemicellulose. DFT and MD calculations demonstrated that the ILs enhance the binding energy between EDA and lignin dimers, increase the maximum penetration distance, and reduce the frontier orbital gap. The cationic alkyl chain of the ILs dissolves the aromatic rings of lignin, while the anion and EDA cooperatively stabilize lignin hydroxyl groups, thus disrupting intermolecular hydrogen bonds and π-π stacking interactions, which effectively inhibits condensation of lignin and ensures its structural integrity and nitrogen doping efficiency (FIG. 12(b)). Furthermore, Chen et al. [102] demonstrated that coupling ILs with common organic solvents such as ethanol, butanol, and acetone for separating miscanthus and pine wood is feasible and the recovered lignin contains α-alkoxy ether units, which can inhibit lignin condensation reactions. The results also showed the IL regeneration model was established with flash distillation as the core, focusing on energy consumption and costs in the separation stage for triethylammonium. When the organic solvent content exceeds 40%, the energy consumption of the hybrid process is significantly lower than that of traditional ion solvent process, while lignin valorization can further enhance revenue. If the biorefinery self-supplies ethanol, it can further reduce the procurement cost of organic solvents, improving economic feasibility. To address the challenges of high separation costs and difficult separation of components in traditional IL systems, Zhang et al. [103] developed a two-phase cosolvent system using protonic ionic liquid 2-hydroxy-N-(2-hydroxyethyl)-N-methylethanaminium ([BHEM]) and pentanol for corn straw separation. Under optimal conditions, the system achieved a cellulose retention rate of 91.6%, hemicellulose removal rate of 89.3%, lignin removal rate of 82.9%, and enzymatic glucose yield of 91.6%. DFT calculations elucidated the core mechanism that the two-phase system synergistically enhances interactions between different C−O bonds of lignin through strong hydrogen bonding in the ILs and hydrophobic assistance from pentanol, significantly reducing binding energy and promoting lignin degradation and dissolution. Moreover, the two-phase characteristics resolve the issue of difficult separation and mixing in single-phase systems (FIG. 12(a)).
Expanding the research to morpholinium-based ILs and different cosolvents, Mehrizi et al. [104] used morpholinium-based ILs with N-allyl-N-methylmorpholinium ([AmMorph]+) cation as separation solvents. The results indicated that organic anions possess a stronger ability of breaking hydrogen bonds, enabling more efficient disruption of the lignocellulose structure and facilitating cellulose exposure and enzymatic hydrolysis reactions. Recently, research has focused on designing novel solvents to improve cellulose dissolution. Wang et al. [105] developed a separation system consisting of superbase-derived ILs and various dipolar aprotic cosolvents. This system achieved the rapid dissolution of natural cellulose, with a 92% recovery rate for the solvents. Studies have shown that the cosolvents used can enhance the hydrogen bond acceptor capacity, thus disrupting the intermolecular and intramolecular hydrogen bonds of cellulose. Furthermore, introducing cosolvents into pure ILs significantly reduces viscosity, accelerating the transport of ions into the interior of cellulose. Furthermore, to address the challenges of stubborn tea stem structure, difficult lignin removal, and insufficient high-value utilization, Wang et al. [106] developed a series of biocompatible choline-based organic carboxylate ionic liquids (Ch-OAC-ILs) separation systems, among which choline acetyl propionate demonstrated optimal performance. The lignin removal rate reached 57.9%, with high cellulose retention and a subsequent enzymatic hydrolysis glucose yield of 81.4%. DFT calculations clarified the core mechanism that Ch-OAC-ILs selectively disrupt lignin β-O-4 and β-5 bonds via a synergistic mode of anionic strong interaction (hydrogen bonds) and cationic weak auxiliary interaction (van der Waals forces), while the electrostatic properties of weak hydrogen bonds prevent cellulose degradation (FIG. 12(c)).
-
Table II systematically summarizes the key performance metrics of diverse ionic liquid systems for lignocellulosic component separation, including raw material types, solvent compositions, separation efficiency (lignin/hemicellulose removal rates and cellulose retention rate), component valorization pathways, lignin application directions, and solvent recyclability.
-
DESs have also been widely used in component separation due to their green solvent properties, compared with traditional organic solvents and ILs. DESs are deep eutectic salts that are formed from hydrogen bond donors (HBDs) and hydrogen bond acceptors (HBAs) through hydrogen bonding, van der Waals forces or electrostatic interactions. Unlike organic solvents, which undergo molecular dissolution, and in contrast to fully ionized ILs, DESs can optimize the Kamlet−Taft hydrogen bond parameters (α/β) by regulating the type and ratio of HBDs/HBAs to construct multicomponent, synergistic hydrogen bond networks. These networks facilitate the precise deconstruction of LCC, enabling efficient and selective lignin removal and the directional regulation of cellulose crystallinity. By contrast, organic solvents mostly rely on a single dissolution effect and are inefficient for disrupting LCC. ILs, on the other hand, primarily achieve component separation through hydrogen bond competition and the electrostatic interactions of cations and anions. In the process of component separation, DESs can form hydrogen bonds with lignin and cellulose through the synergistic effect of various components, disrupting the chemical linkages including ether and ester bonds between the three main components of lignocellulose. Meanwhile, DESs selectively dissolve lignin components, thereby weakening their physical wrapping effect on cellulose and hemicellulose. And they can also break down the crystalline structure of cellulose and induce swelling of the fiber matrix, ultimately creating more favorable conditions for subsequent processes, such as enzymatic hydrolysis and conversion [107].
-
Choline chloride (ChCl) has become a popular choice for use as HBAs in recent years owing to its biocompatibility, biodegradability and low cost. Sheng et al. [108] employed microwave-assisted ChCl-based DESs for bamboo separation to enhance enzymatic saccharification and obtained lignin with high purity and a highly active hydroxyl substructure. The DFT and MD results revealed that the intermolecular hydrogen bond dynamics of DESs strongly correlates with lignin (R2=0.97) and xylan (R2=0.98) removal, where ChCl/formic acid (FA) system features active intermolecular hydrogen bonds of −25.3 kJ·mol−1, achieving 86.14% delignification, 95.82% xylan removal, and 76.23% glucose yield. Specifically, MD results showed ChCl/FA increases the interaction force and hydrogen bond number between the three components to disrupt LCC structure. Miao et al. [109] used two DESs including ChCl/OA and ChCl/OA/EG, where DFT results confirmed that EG substitution at Cα position of lignin alters the local potential of β-O-4 bonds, impeding H+ ion attack, as well as MD results revealed the diffusion efficiency of lignin in DESs is the key factor governing its extraction and dissolution (FIG. 13(a)). Zhao et al. [110] also employed ChCl and combined it with multiple HBDs, and DFT calculations revealed that the presence of LCC not only raises the energy barrier (274.2 kJ·mol−1) for levoglucosan (LG) formation, inhibiting directional dehydration of cellulose into sugars, but also lowers the energy barrier (257.4 kJ·mol−1) for hydroxyacetaldehyde formation, promoting cellulose ring-opening fragmentation. Consequently, the core function of DES separation system lies in cleaving ester bonds within LCC to reduce LCC residues, thereby directionally enhancing LG production (FIG. 13(b)). Following this research trend, Li et al. [111] developed a binary trifunctional DES consisting of ChCl and glyoxylic acid (GA). DFT calculations revealed that the synergetic interaction of ChCl and GA reduces the Gibbs free energy of the acetal reaction, generating carboxylic acid methylidene acetal structures via reacting with α-OH and γ-OH in lignin, which stabilizes β-O-4 linkages, shields hydroxyl groups, and inhibits condensation by capturing reactive intermediates, resulting in a delignification ratio exceeding 88% and light colored lignin with > 98.5% high purity, and a near-theoretical aromatic monomer yield (FIG. 13(c)).
Introducing one or more components into binary DESs not only retains the inherent functions and performance of binary DESs, but also enhances the synergistic effect of these solvents and expands their functionalities. Cao et al. [112] employed a DES consisting of ChCl, FA, and OA. The results showed that this DES increases the phenolic hydroxyl content of lignin by 50.4%, while efficiently cleaving β-O-4 ether and ester bonds. In addition to combining organic components to form ternary DESs, the introduction of metal salts to optimize the performance of DES systems has also become a research focus. Multiol-based DESs are known to possess excellent solubility, stability, and biomass compatibility. Polyols and acid solvents can also be introduced into the system simultaneously to act as co-HBDs, thus providing support for the efficient and selective component separation of lignocellulose. Ge et al. [113] designed a three-component DES system composed of ChCl/glycerol/AlCl3·6H2O, achieving a lignin extraction rate of 95%, significantly higher than that of two-component systems such as ChCl/glycerol. MD results revealed that the interaction between solvent and lignin is dominated by van der Waals forces, assisted by Cl− electrostatic interactions, with the hydrophobic surface of lignin being the key to dissolution. DFT calculations further clarified the catalytic mechanism where Al3+ forms a [Al(C3H3O3)2]3+ chelate with glycerol, reducing the β-O-4 bond-breaking energy barrier via Lewis acid catalysis, thereby producing more soluble small molecular lignin fragments. Zhang et al. [114] also employed the ChCl/glycerol system, introducing a small amount of Brønsted acid to enhance the removal of DESs capacity for lignin and hemicellulose, achieving a lignin removal rate of 90.08%, complete hemicellulose removal, and a cellulose retention rate exceeding 70%. DFT and MD results elucidated the core mechanism including that DESs encapsulates lignin through Cl−H, HO−H hydrogen bonds and CH-π interactions, disrupting the LCC structure, and the H+ ions provided by Brønsted acids protonate lignin α-OH to form a benzyl carbocation, which catalyzes the cleavage of β-O-4 ether bonds. Simultaneously, the acid enhances the interaction energy between DESs and lignin, inhibiting lignin recondensation (FIG. 13(d)). Additionally, Zhu et al. [115] employed a ternary DESs system (ChCl/PTSA/EG) to separate bagasse, achieving a lignin removal rate of 97.94% and a hemicellulose removal rate of 100% under optimized reaction conditions. DFT results revealed that EG reduces DES viscosity by reconstructing the hydrogen bond network while enhancing the hydrogen bonding between Cl− and lignin. Recently, Wang et al. [116] achieved a high lignin removal rate of 96.1% at 130 °C within 150 s by combining microwave heating with ternary DESs. The mechanism elucidates that microwave reinforces the delignification efficiency of DESs with relatively high π* and α, as corroborated by comparative analysis with conventional heating (CH) pretreatment. LCA further manifests the environmental benefits of microwave-assisted DESs in mitigating impacts by 63.1%, including global warming potential, resource depletion-fossil fuels, and ecotoxicity, in comparison to CH separation.
-
In-depth research on DESs has made the development of novel DES methods a key way of improving separation efficiency and expanding applications. Zhou et al. [117] employed polyethylene glycol (PEG 200) as an HBDs combined with OA to separate tea stems. The results achieved lignin removal of 70.89%, hemicellulose removal of 97.02%, and the cellulose retention of 82.03% under optimal conditions, as well as producing lignin with a lower molecular weight and nanoscale particle size for chemicals and materials. DFT calculations revealed that the DESs synergistically disruptes intramolecular hydrogen bonds of lignin and LCC structure through hydrogen bonding and van der Waals forces, achieving efficient dissolution. Chen et al. [118] employed a new ternary DESs system consisting of guanidine hydrochloride, EG, and PTSA. This system exhibited excellent performance in separating willow branches. Tang et al. [119] developed a cetyltrimethylammonium bromide (CTAB)/LA/Fe3+ ternary DES system for separating straw, achieving lignin removal of 83.2% and xylan removal of 76.3%. DFT calculations also revealed that the positive potential of Fe3+ and the negative potential of the carboxyl oxygen in LA form a stable interaction, enhancing the acid catalytic center and providing conditions for the cleavage of β-O-4 bonds and β-1,4-glycosidic bonds. Additionally, the long alkyl chain region of CTAB exhibits strong attraction, significantly interacting with the hydrophobicity of lignin aromatic rings, thereby providing a thermodynamic basis for efficient lignin dissolution. MD simulations further demonstrated that the DES system primarily relies on hydrogen bonding for xylan and van der Waals forces for lignin removal, enabling efficient removal of both components (FIG. 14(a)). Furthermore, Tang et al. [120] enhanced the aforementioned system by substituting CTAB with n-tetradecyltrimethylammonium bromide (TTAB), achieving 89.2% lignin removal and 77.9% xylan removal rates, both showing significant improvements. DFT results revealed that the shorter alkyl chain of TTAB achieves a better balance between hydrophobicity and permeability. It effectively encapsulates lignin fragments through hydrophobic interactions while rapidly diffusing into the biomass to disrupt the LCC structure, thereby delivering superior pretreatment performance (FIG. 14(b)). Li et al. [121] proposed another novel ternary DESs system targeting mild-condition component separation. They used a ternary DES consisting of triethylbenzylammonium chloride (TEBAC), PTSA, and EG to separate poplar. The results showed that the enzymatic hydrolysis efficiency of cellulose in poplar increased by around 15 times compared with the untreated sample. And the results also revealed the synergistic effect of the components in this system. Among them, PTSA provides sufficient H+ ions to specifically cleave the β-O-4 ether bonds in lignin. EG reduces the viscosity of DES to enhance its penetration into poplar and promote contact between H+ ions and the lignin, and EG forms hydrogen bonds with lignin degradation products through its hydroxyl groups. TEBAC facilitates the elution of lignin degradation products from within poplar, thereby accelerating the removal of lignin.
Furthermore, to achieve high-value utilization of all components within lignocellulosic biomass, Tan et al. [122] designed a ternary supramolecular DES composed of ethylene glycol, citric acid, and β-cyclodextrin. Lignin model compound adsorption kinetics demonstrated that the introduction of β-CD with superior ability of both adsorption and in-situ lignin protection to efficiently remove lignin with intact structure from cellulose surface (FIG. 14(c)). Finally the delignification rate, cellulose enzymatic digestibility, and hemicellulose removal reached 90.45%, 97.36%, and 87.24%. Similarly, Wang et al. [123] developed a bio-based ternary DES comprising dimethyl isosorbide/EG/OA. The mechanistic insights into delignification were elucidated through Hansen solubility theory, revealing that the lower relative energy difference, strong hydrogen bonding cohesion, and EG incorporation enabled efficient utilization of the sugar platform without compromising the structural intactness of lignin thus obtaining ligin with good UV-blocking performance (FIG. 14(d)). In general, the aforementioned novel ternary DES systems exhibit stronger designability and higher regulatory flexibility than binary DESs. By adjusting the component ratios, it is possible to achieve precise control of the key physicochemical properties of solvents. These properties significantly impact the solubility of lignin in DESs, providing greater potential to optimize the efficiency of component separation and paving the way for the industrial application of DESs.
-
Table III comprehensively summarizes the performance parameters of various deep eutectic solvent systems for lignocellulosic component separation, covering raw materials, solvent compositions, separation efficiency (lignin/hemicellulose removal rates, cellulose retention rate), enzymatic hydrolysis yield, lignin application directions, and solvent recyclability.
-
This review summarizes the current advances in component separation methods of lignocellulosic biomass by organic solvents, ionic liquids (ILs), and deep eutectic solvents (DESs) methods. The construction of separation methods, understanding of reaction mechanisms, and design of separation methods in each method are highlighted and discussed in detail. It also introduces three main components (cellulose, hemicellulose and lignin) as well as their valorization in chemical raw materials and energy production. Our goal is to elucidate the separation mechanisms of three methods and the principles of separation method design, providing guidance for the development of efficient component separation methods of lignocellulose and the rational utilization of these components in energy production and other fields.
Based on the summary of the aforementioned component separation methods, we further carry out a comparative analysis of their advantages, challenges, and further developments from a mechanistic and industrialized perspective. The organic solvents have been the most investigated owing to their selective dissolution for components, low cost, environmental friendliness, and recyclability. However, they still have insufficient solubility for condensed lignin, leading to a high residual lignin content in the solid residue after separation, which directly affects the purity and performance of subsequent cellulose-based products for subsequent valorization. Furthermore, they tend to undergo etherification and condensation side reactions with hemicellulose degradation products during high temperature separation, thus the generated heterocyclic impurities significantly reduce the subsequent enzymatic hydrolysis efficiency. The ILs have significant advantages for component separation due to their unique molecular structure, which enables them to efficiently dissolve cellulose, hemicellulose, and lignin. They can also disrupt the dense cell wall structure and hydrogen bond network of lignocellulose, thereby greatly improving the efficiency of subsequent enzymatic hydrolysis or conversion. The DESs possess the characteristics of biocompatibility, biodegradability, and low cost, and this method has been optimized to enable diverse, multifunctional upgrades by integrating auxiliary technologies to enhance efficiency. However, their high inherent viscosity significantly restricts the efficiency of solid−liquid mass transfer, which can only be alleviated by adding extra components or optimizing processes.
Specifically, the organic solvent method exhibits moderate to high selectivity, with separation efficiency enhanced through catalyst/biphasic systems. It offers high scalability and excellent equipment compatibility, with pilot-scale cases already established. Solvent recovery rates are high, primarily achieved via the well-established distillation recovery method. The ILs exhibit high selectivity and can be specifically engineered based on their cationic and anionic structures. However, they possess moderate scalability and suffer from drawbacks such as corrosiveness and high viscosity, which constrain processing methods. Solvent recovery rates vary considerably, primarily depending on the solvent employed, with distillation or reverse extraction methods yielding overall lower recovery than organic solvent-based approaches. The DESs method exhibits moderately high selectivity, with performance optimization achievable through adjustment of the HBDs/HBAs ratio. However, its scalability is comparable to that of ILs, presenting challenges in high viscosity and thermal stability that require optimization. While solvent recovery rates rival those of organic solvent methods, it should be noticed that certain components are prone to degradation.
It is worth noting that significant differences exist between laboratory-scale studies, pilot-scale research, and industrial-scale application technologies. Previous discussions have focused solely on the mechanisms of various technologies and newly designed or emerging methods for separating lignocellulose at the laboratory scale in recent years. However, their translation to industrial scale still faces various challenges, including economic viability, process engineering, environmental compatibility, and system stability so that we should gain a clearer understanding of these challenges. The high cost of synthesis feedstocks for ILs remains the primary obstacle to their large-scale application. Whilst distillable ILs and in-situ synthesis offer potential cost-reduction pathways, their economic viability requires further evaluation. DESs feedstocks such as ChCl are comparatively inexpensive, yet the stable supply of bio-based choline remains difficult. Conventional organic solvents, however, hold a distinct cost advantage in bulk chemical production. Regarding solvent recovery and recycling, the industrialization process hinges on establishing efficient solvent recovery and circulation systems. Organic solvents typically achieve high recovery rates via distillation, though energy consumption and volatile organic compound management pose challenges. Recovery of ILs and DESs is more complex, involving multi-step separation processes (e.g., distillation, counter-extraction, membrane separation). These processes entail solvent degradation, impurity accumulation, and consequent reductions in recovery rates alongside increased purification costs.
Furthermore, acidic organic solvent systems and acidic DESs exhibit strong corrosivity towards conventional carbon steel equipment, necessitating the use of costly corrosion-resistant alloys or non-metallic materials, significantly increasing initial investment costs. The corrosivity of ILs varies with their structure and requires targeted assessment. It should also be noted that laboratory studies are predominantly conducted at low solid contents (typically < 10%) to ensure favorable mass transfer. However, industrial applications must pursue high solid content operations to achieve economic viability. At elevated solid contents, system viscosity increases dramatically particularly for DESs and ILs, leading to mixing difficulties, sharply reduced mass transfer efficiency, reaction non-uniformity, and localized overheating. These issues severely compromise separation efficiency and product consistency. Therefore, developing efficient mixing equipment and process intensification techniques such as ultrasonic or microwave assistance is essential to overcome this bottleneck. Concurrently, industrialized processes must possess sufficient tolerance to raw material variations including differences in biomass components from diverse sources, varieties, or parts. Many optimized solvent systems currently demonstrate remarkable efficacy for specific raw materials, though their universal applicability remains to be verified. Furthermore, the development of continuous production processes lags significantly behind batch processes, despite continuous operation being pivotal for achieving large-scale, stable, and low-cost production. Consequently, we can anticipate future efforts in process integration and optimization that prioritize the industrialization of the most mature organic solvent method, with a focus on tackling closed-loop solvent circulation systems and high-solid-content continuous processes. Innovating separation methods of ILs and DESs should concentrate on the molecular design of novel, low-cost, low-viscosity, easily recoverable solvents, while simultaneously developing matching low-energy-consumption enhanced separation technologies.
Advances in Component Separation Methods of Lignocellulosic Biomass†
- Received Date: 09/12/2025
- Available Online: 27/02/2026
-
Key words:
- Lignocellulosic biomass /
- Component separation /
- Organic solvent /
- Ionic liquid /
- Deep eutectic solvent
Abstract: Lignocellulosic biomass is the most abundant renewable resource on Earth, boasting advantages such as wide availability and negative carbon emissions. Especially, efficient separation of lignocellulose into cellulose, hemicellulose and lignin, and realizing valorization of these components are more responsive to the development needs of biomass refinery and the green chemistry era. This review outlines the main components of lignocellulose and briefly summerizes their utilization in chemical raw materials and energy production. It mainly focused on current advances in component separation methods of lignocellulose by organic solvents, ionic liquids and deep eutectic solvents. The design of separation methods, understanding of separation mechanisms, and optimization of reaction systems in each method are highlighted in detail. Furthermore, the ongoing challenges and future directions based on mechanism and industrialization are critically discussed. Our goal is to elucidate the separation mechanisms and principles of method design, providing guidance for the development of highly efficient component separation methods of lignocellulose.
首页
登录
注册


DownLoad: