2024 Volume 33 Issue 10
Article Contents

Cui-E Hu, Mu-Xin Jiao, Xue-Nan Yang, Zhao-Yi Zeng, Jun Chen. Thermal conductivity of iron under the Earth’s inner core pressure[J]. Chinese Physics B, 2024, 33(10): 106501. doi: 10.1088/1674-1056/ad6078
Citation: Cui-E Hu, Mu-Xin Jiao, Xue-Nan Yang, Zhao-Yi Zeng, Jun Chen. Thermal conductivity of iron under the Earth’s inner core pressure[J]. Chinese Physics B, 2024, 33(10): 106501. doi: 10.1088/1674-1056/ad6078

Thermal conductivity of iron under the Earth’s inner core pressure

  • Received Date: 18/04/2024
    Accepted Date: 20/06/2024
    Available Online: 01/09/2024
通讯作者: 陈斌, bchen63@163.com
  • 1. 

    沈阳化工大学材料科学与工程学院 沈阳 110142

  1. 本站搜索
  2. 百度学术搜索
  3. 万方数据库搜索
  4. CNKI搜索

Figures(7)

Article Metrics

Article views(696) PDF downloads(6) Cited by(0)

Access History

Thermal conductivity of iron under the Earth’s inner core pressure

Abstract: The thermal conductivity of ε-iron at high pressure and high temperature is a key parameter to constrain the dynamics and thermal evolution of the Earth’s core. In this work, we use first-principles calculations to study the Hugoniot sound velocity and the thermal transport properties of ε-iron. The total thermal conductivity considering lattice vibration is 200 W/mK at the Earth’s inner core conditions. The suppressed anharmonic interactions can significantly enhance the lattice thermal conductivity under high pressure, and the contribution of the lattice thermal conductivity should not be ignored under the Earth’s core conditions.

1.   Introduction
  • Iron (Fe) is a material of key importance to condensed matter physics and Earth sciences, which is reported to be the major element in Earth’s core. The solid inner core is almost fully filled with Fe, the other elements are commonly assumed to be 5% to 10% Ni and 2% to 4% light elements (e.g., Si, C, S).[1–3] To investigate the properties of Fe under the Earth’s core conditions, it is essential to know the structure of Fe under high pressure. The stable phase of Fe in the inner core is widely reported to be ε-Fe with a hexagonal-closed-packed (hcp) structure.[4–9] However, this conclusion has been challenged by some theoretical investigations. Vocadlo et al.[10] and Belonoshko et al.[11,12] proposed that body-centered cubic (bcc) Fe may be stable under inner core conditions. Previously, we calculated the phonon dispersion of bcc-Fe and hcp-Fe under high temperature and high pressure with the self-consistent ab initio lattice dynamics method.[13] Though the bcc-Fe and hcp-Fe are both dynamically stable under the Earth’s core conditions, the free energy of hcp-Fe is lower than that of bcc-Fe. We also investigated the equation of state, elastic constants, phase transition and magnetic of Fe under high pressure,[13–15] and all the results showed that the most stable phase is nonmagnetic ε-Fe at high pressure.[15] Therefore, we restrict the structure to ε-Fe in this work.

    The thermal conductivity of Fe under high pressure and high temperature is of central importance to understanding the thermal evolution of the Earth’s core and the energetics of the geomagnetic field. In the past few years, many investigations of Fe under the Earth’s inner core conditions have been done from theory and experiment, but there is still a significant discrepancy in thermal conductivity at the core–mantle boundary (CMB).[16–23] By the laser heated diamond anvil cell (DAC) experiments, the data of thermal conductivity are 33±7 W/(m⋅K)[22] at the CMB conditions and 70–80 W/(m⋅K)[24] (with an uncertainty of 40%) up to 134 GPa. In contrast, through the resistivity measurements in DAC, thermal conductivity was reported up to 226−31+71 W/(m⋅K).[20] But with similar experiments, Zhang et al. found that the thermal conductivity of Fe was ∼100±10 W/(m⋅K).[19] Theoretically, the thermal conductivity near the CMB estimated from first principles was 150 W/(m⋅K),[21,23] ∼100±10 W/(m⋅K),[19] and 97±10 W/(m⋅K),[18] respectively. However, these data are three to five times higher than geophysical estimates and shock experiments. For metal, the thermal conductivity is mainly attributed to the electronic conductivity, and the contribution of the lattice thermal conductivity is ignored. Because of the harmonic phonon interactions, the heat transfer processes have no thermal resistance, which means the infinite thermal conductivity. The suppressed anharmonic interactions can enhance the lattice thermal conductivity obviously under high pressure. In this work, we calculated the thermal conductivity of Fe under the Earth’s core condition with the Boltzmann transport theory.

2.   Theoretical methods
  • All the calculations are performed by the Vienna ab initio simulation package (VASP). The exchange–correlation interactions are treated using the spin-polarized generalized gradient approximation within the Perdew–Burke–Ernzerhof formulation and the project augmented wave. The plane-wave cutoff energy is set to 500 eV and the k-point sampling grid in the Brillouin zone is chosen to be 11×11×11 in the geometry optimization. The energy convergence criterion is set to a precision of 10−6 eV and the forces on all relaxed atoms are less than 0.001 eV/Å. Based on a full iterative solution to the Boltzmann transport equation, the phonon dispersions of ε-Fe are obtained by finite displacement method with a 4×4×4 supercell containing 128 independent atoms. The third-order force constants are also considered with 128 atoms. The k-point meshes of 9×9×9 are selected for both second-order force and third-order force calculations.

    The Helmholtz free energy F can be accurately separated as

    where Estatic(V) is the energy of a static lattice at zero temperature T and volume V, Felec(V,T) is the thermal free energy arising from electronic excitations. Both Estatic(V) and Felec(V,T) can be obtained from static first-principles calculations directly. The nonequilibrium vibrational contribution Fphon(V,T) is given by

    where Ω is the volume of the Brillouin Zone, kB is the Boltzmann constant, ℏ is the Plank constant and ωqs are the phonon frequencies. This is obtained within the quasiharmonic approximation (QHA) by small displacements method.

    The elastic constants are defined by means of a Taylor expansion of the total energy, E (V, δ), for the system with respect to a small strain δ of the lattice primitive cell volume V. The energy of a strained system is expressed as

    where E(V0, 0) is the energy of the unstrained system with equilibrium volume V0, τi is an element in the stress tensor, and ξi is a factor to take care of Voigt index. The elastic strains are generated by the VASPKIT code.[25]

    The lattice thermal conductivity kl can be obtained busing the phonon Boltzmann transport equation (BTE) given by[26]

    where Ω is the volume of the unit cell, N is the number of atoms, Cq is the heat capacity, υq is the group velocity and τq is the phonon relaxation time. The Cq can be evaluated from the phonon density of states. The υq are obtained by calculating the gradient of the phonon dispersion relation. The τq are calculated from Fermi’s golden rule using the harmonic and third-order anharmonic force constants from DFT calculations. In this work, the phonon–phonon scattering contribution is considered, and the phonon–electron scattering process is neglected. The electrical thermal conductivity ke and the electrical resistivity ρ are connected by the Wiedemann–Franz law

    where T is the temperature. The electrical resistivity ρ is mainly attributed to the electron–electron scattering contribution. The electrical resistivity ρ can be obtained from the electrical conductivity tensor σe directly (ρ = 1/σe). The σe/τe can be obtained using the BTE with the relaxation time approximation, where τe is the electronic relaxation time. With this approximation, (σe/τe) only depends on the electronic band structure and the values can be obtained from DFT-BTE calculations using VASP and the BoltzTrap code.[27]

3.   Results and discussion
  • The Earth’s core is at extreme conditions of high temperatures and pressures. Under the Earth’s core conditions, the variation of the axial ratio c/a is a direct response to the changes of elastic anisotropy. In present work, for a fixed axial ratio c/a, we calculate the total energies E at different cell volumes V, and then obtain the lowest energy for the given ratio c/a. The value of c/a is 1.603 at 135 GPa, and it increases a little with the increasing pressure up to Earth’s inner core condition. The nearly constant value of the c/a ratio agrees with other data (1.596–1.608).[28–31] We calculated the phonon dispersions of ε-Fe at different pressures (Fig. 1). As the phase transition of Fe from bcc phase to hcp phase occurs at 13 GPa,[32] the obtained phonon dispersions in the present work started from this pressure. The frequency of phonon dispersion increases with the increasing pressure. Near the Γ point, the slope of the acoustic branch increases significantly, which shows that the group velocity increases with the increasing pressure.

    In a shock wave experiment, conservation of mass, momentum, and energy require that the pressure PH, the molar internal energy UH, and the molar volume VH in the compression wave are related by the Rankine–Hugoniot formula

    where U0 and V0 are the molar internal energy and volume in the initial state (zero pressure P0) before the arrival of the wave. Considering the thermal free energy arising from electronic excitations and phonon contributions, the obtained Hugoniot curves of Fe are shown in Fig. 2. At 135 GPa, the present Hugoniot temperature (TH) is about 2500 K, which is consistent with the data from the experimental,[33] theoretical results[34] and the preliminary reference Earth model (PREM)[35] at the CMB. At 330 GPa, the present TH is close to 6500 K, which agrees with the temperature (∼ 6000 K) at ICB.[36]

    We calculate the elastic constants along Hugoniot, and then obtain the bulk and shear modulus (B and G) from the elastic constants. The compressional sound velocity VP and shear sound velocity VS can be obtained as follows:

    where ρ is the density. The sound velocities along Hugoniot state are shown in Fig. 3. It can be seen that the sound velocities increase with the increasing pressure. Our results are generally consistent with the shock wave experimental data below 160 GPa.[3,7,8,34] The small discrepancies between our results and experimental data may be due to the fact that we neglected the electronic thermal effects when evaluating its elastic properties. Above 160 GPa, our results deviate from the experimental data. As those P–T conditions approach the region of shock-induced melting of Fe, the shock experimental data show nonlinear relation with pressure. Above 200 GPa, the shock shear sound velocities VS decrease dramatically to zero, which indicates the melting of Fe.[3,7,8,34] In our model, the QHA for one phase cannot simulate the shock melting. However, our results can provide useful references for understanding the sound velocity under the Earth’s core conditions. Under the ICB pressure, the VP and VS are about 12.2 km/s and 5.5 km/s, which generally agree with the data (6600 K at 360 GPa and 7000 K at 360 GPa) from ab initio molecular dynamics simulations (AIMD).[37] But our results are larger than that of PREM data.[35] The difference between our results and the PREM seismic data is marginally within mutual uncertainties. The differences may be accounted for by the presence of other light elements (e.g., S, Si and C) and heavy element alloy (e.g., Ni). Meanwhile, a possible explanation for the large discrepancy may be that parts of the inner core are partially molten. In order to understand the seismic data, further systematic studies are needed to improve our knowledge.

  • The thermal conductivity of ε-Fe is crucial to understanding the thermal history of the core and the geodynamo. As shown in Fig. 4, the kl increases linearly along Hugoniot curve. The increasing of the phonon group velocity surpasses the decreasing phonon scattering, and it becomes the main contribution for the increase of kl. The data of the kl are 6.05 W/(m⋅K) at CMB and 12.63 W/(m⋅K) at ICB, respectively. We analyzed the contribution of each phonon model (one longitudinal acoustic branch LA, and two transverse acoustic branches TA1, TA2) to the total lattice thermal conductivity, which is shown in Fig. 5(a). It is found that the acoustic branches dominate the contribution of the lattice thermal conductivity. The contribution of the acoustic branch to the lattice thermal conductivity is 81% at 135 GPa, and 92% at 330 GPa. The energy of the optical branches is lower than that of acoustic branches, and thus it can be excited more easily. As shown in Fig. 5(b), the cumulative thermal conductivity is primarily governed by the acoustic phonon modes at low-frequency regions.

    To explore the physical mechanism of the thermal conductivity, we investigate the phonon group velocity, phonon scattering rate and Grüneisen parameter under high pressures. The group velocities vg can be obtained from the slope of the phonon dispersion. The relationships between the phonon group velocities and frequencies are shown in Figs. 6(a) and 6(b). The group velocities of acoustic branches are larger than that of optical branches, which confirms that the acoustic branches play a major role in the lattice thermal conductivity. The group velocities of the LA branch are the highest of all phonon modes and the largest contribution to the lattice thermal conductivity is from the LA branch. Near the Γ point, the maximum of the group velocities at 135 GPa and 330 GPa are 5.72 km/s and 6.85 km/s, respectively.

    The phonon scattering intensity is dependent on the mode-dependent Grüneisen parameter γ, which reflects the anharmonicity of the phonon. The γ can be obtained from the relationship between phonon frequency and volume change as follows:

    where ω is the frequency and V is volume. The relationships between Grüneisen parameter and frequencies are shown in Figs. 6(c) and 6(d). The negative value of the Grüneisen parameter at 135 GPa, which indicates the large anharmonic terms beyond third-order terms. However, the absence of negative Grüneisen parameters at 330 GPa indicates that the high pressure suppresses the anharmonicity.

    The scattering rates at different pressures are shown in Figs. 6(e) and 6(f). It can be seen that the acoustic branch occupies the middle- and low-frequency portions and the optical branch occupies the high-frequency portion. As the frequency increases, the scattering rates of acoustic branches increase gradually and remain between 1 ps−1 and 10 ps−1. The phonon scattering increases under pressure, which is attributed to the increased anisotropy. As shown in our previous investigations, Fe is elastically anisotropic at the inner core.[14] At 135 GPa, the small phonon scattering rate results from the relatively isotropic phonon branches. Such phonon dispersions provide few scattering channels, so the scattering rate is small. However, at 330 GPa the three phonon branches are relatively far from each other. This change opens more scattering channels and the phonon–phonon scattering is consequently increased.

    The electron thermal conductivity (ke) is dominant in the thermal transport properties of ε-Fe. We obtained the electronic thermal conductivity ke of ε-Fe along Hugoniot. At 135 GPa and 330 GPa, the data of electron thermal conductivity are 106 W/(m⋅K) and 108 W/(m⋅K), respectively. The results of the total thermal conductivity (k = ke + kl) are shown in Fig. 7. At the CMB conditions, the value of k is 112 W/(m⋅K), which is in agreement with the value of 97±10 W/(m⋅K)[18] and 100±10 W/(m⋅K).[19] Near the ICB, the value of k is 200 W/(m⋅K), which is consistent with the previous results.[23,38] The proportion of lattice thermal conductivity enhances from 5.4% at CMB up to 6.3% at ICB, which indicates that the contribution of the lattice thermal conductivity should not be ignored under Earth’s core conditions. Our thermal conductivity at the CMB is 112 W/(m⋅K), and it can also verify the viewpoint that the geodynamo is driven by thermal convection.

    From thermal conductivity, the adiabatic heat flow (Qa) of ε-Fe corresponding to the top of the liquid core can be obtained as follows:

    where r is the radius, α is Grüneisen parameter, g is the gravitational acceleration (gCMB = 10.6823 m/s2) and ϕ is the seismic parameter (ϕCMB = 65.05 km2/s2).[39] The high thermal conductivity 112 W/(m⋅K) at the CMB indicates an adiabatic heat flow Qa of ∼14.7 TW. While the present-day CMB heat flow across the lowermost mantle (QCMB) is constrained to be 10–12 TW based on the estimated thermal conductivity (∼10 W/(m⋅K)) of the mantle minerals.[40] The geodynamo is maintained by fluid convection in the outer core. It is believed that the fluid convection is mainly driven by thermal or compositional buoyancy, where the former requires a higher QCMB than the Qa based on the Schwarzschild criterion.[41] The high thermal conductivity of ε-Fe makes Qa > QCMB, and thus hinders thermal convection. However, chemical buoyancy released at the ICB by inner core growth could still drive convection at depth. As a result, the present-day geodynamo would be mainly driven by compositional convection.

4.   Conclusions
  • In summary, the phonon dispersion, Hugoniot equation of state and thermal transport properties of the ε-Fe were investigated by first-principles calculations together with Boltzmann transport theory. The phonon dispersion curves under high pressure show that the ε-Fe is a stable phase at Earth’s core conditions. The Hugoniot sound velocities agree with the previous investigations. Considering the contribution of lattice vibration, the total thermal conductivity is much closer to the experimental data than the result which is obtained only by considering the electron thermal conductivity. The total thermal conductivity for ε-iron is 200 W/(m⋅K) at the ICB. The variation trend of lattice thermal conductivity is obviously affected by pressure. The suppressed anharmonic interactions can significantly enhance the lattice thermal conductivity under high pressure, and the contribution of the lattice thermal conductivity should not be ignored under the conditions of the Earth’s core.

Figure (7)  Reference (43)

Catalog

    /

    DownLoad:  Full-Size Img  PowerPoint
    Return
    Return