2024 Volume 33 Issue 10
Article Contents

Mingyue Ge, Likang Xiao, Xiaoru Liu, Lin Pan, Zhangyang Zhou, Jianghe Lan, Zhengwei Xiong, Jichuan Wu, Zhipeng Gao. Enhanced soft magnetic properties of SiO2-coated FeSiCr magnetic powder cores by particle size effect[J]. Chinese Physics B, 2024, 33(10): 107503. doi: 10.1088/1674-1056/ad6556
Citation: Mingyue Ge, Likang Xiao, Xiaoru Liu, Lin Pan, Zhangyang Zhou, Jianghe Lan, Zhengwei Xiong, Jichuan Wu, Zhipeng Gao. Enhanced soft magnetic properties of SiO2-coated FeSiCr magnetic powder cores by particle size effect[J]. Chinese Physics B, 2024, 33(10): 107503. doi: 10.1088/1674-1056/ad6556

Enhanced soft magnetic properties of SiO2-coated FeSiCr magnetic powder cores by particle size effect

  • Received Date: 09/05/2024
    Accepted Date: 02/07/2024
    Available Online: 01/09/2024
通讯作者: 陈斌, bchen63@163.com
  • 1. 

    沈阳化工大学材料科学与工程学院 沈阳 110142

  1. 本站搜索
  2. 百度学术搜索
  3. 万方数据库搜索
  4. CNKI搜索

Figures(10)  /  Tables(1)

Article Metrics

Article views(636) PDF downloads(3) Cited by(0)

Access History

Enhanced soft magnetic properties of SiO2-coated FeSiCr magnetic powder cores by particle size effect

Abstract: It has been known that metal FeSiCr powders with large average particle sizes have been typically employed to prepare magnetic powder cores (SMCs), with few studies reported on the influence of magnetic properties for original powders with various average particle sizes less than 10 μm. In this work, SiO2-coated FeSiCr SMCs with different small particle sizes were synthesized using the sol–gel process. The contribution of SiO2 coating amount and voids to the soft magnetic properties was elaborated. The mechanism was revealed such that smaller particle sizes with less voids could be beneficial for reducing core loss in the SMCs. By optimizing the core structure, permeability and magnetic loss of 26 and 262 kW/cm3 at 100 kHz and 50 mT were achieved at a particle size of 4.8 μm and ethyl orthosilicate addition of 0.1 mL/g. The best DC stacking performance, reaching 87%, was observed at an ethyl orthosilicate addition rate of 0.25 mL/g under 100 Oe. Compared to other soft magnetic composites (SMCs), the FeSiCr/SiO2 SMCs exhibit significantly reduced magnetic loss. It further reduces the magnetic loss of the powder core, providing a new strategy for applications of SMCs at high frequencies.

1.   Introduction
  • Metallic soft magnetic composites are known for their high effective permeability (μeff), low coercion (HC), and minimal residual magnetic induction, therefore have a wide range of uses in areas such as city power supply.[1,2] FeSiCr soft magnetic powder cores (SMCs) exhibit high Curie temperature and saturation magnetization. Compared to pure iron powder cores, addition of Si and Cr elements provides them with higher temperature stability, better DC superposition characteristics, lower power losses, and resistance to aging.[3,4] However, conventional all-metal magnetic powder core materials face challenges associated with low resistivity, frequency instability, and performance deterioration at increased temperatures, thereby limiting their utilization in applications. Typically, coating the surface of FeSiCr SMCs with an insulation layer can effectively increase the electrical resistivity and reduce the losses.[5,6] These composites can be categorized based on the cladding material into organic and inorganic coatings, with inorganic coatings offering more superior thermal stability and insulation properties relative to the organic counterparts.[7–15] As a representative inorganic material, SiO2 is easy to synthesize with a low melting point, which is advantageous for forming a uniform glassy coating during annealing. Thus, SiO2-coated FeSiCr SMCs were favored by many researchers.[16,17]

    So far, a number of researchers have studied the variations in magnetic properties of soft magnetic powder core materials at a fixed particle size. For instance, Yu et al. employed the sol–gel method to fabricate FeSiCr/SiO2 SMCs with an average particle size of 8 μm, achieving a maximum density of 6.2–5.8 g/cm3 and a minimum magnetic loss of 418.32 kW/cm3.[16] Li and his team prepared FeSiCr/SiO2 SMCs with an average particle size of 10.3 μm and obtained a minimum magnetic loss of 493.3 kW/cm3.[17] Despite using the same raw material and coating method, previous FeSiCr/SiO2 SMCs with various average particle sizes all exhibited void defects, which led to different degrees of magnetic loss deterioration. Moreover, studies on other iron-based SMCs with different particle sizes have also been reported.[18–20] Zhou et al. examined the effect of powder size on the magnetic properties of FeSiBC SMCs with three particle sizes (20–90 μm) using water atomized FeSiCr powders and found that smaller particle sizes reduced voids and decreased magnetic losses to 239.15 mW/cm3.[18] Woo et al. revealed that FeSiCrB SMCs with the smallest particle size (25 μm) possessed the optimal void structure and loss reduction achieved.[19] Dirk conducted theoretical calculations to analyze the impact of particle sizes on the effective initial magnetic permeability, showing that the void structures in the SMCs were decreased, and the magnetic properties were improved as the particle size decreased from 500 μm to 63 μm.[20] From these earlier results,[16–20] it could be inferred that smaller particle sizes were advantageous for enhancing the magnetic performance of SMCs. However, most research has typically employed metal powders with larger average particle sizes, with fewer studies reporting on the influence of magnetic properties for original powders with an average particle size less than 10 μm. Unfortunately, FeSiCr-based SMCs with different particle sizes less than 10 μm have been rarely fabricated, and the effect of such smaller FeSiCr particle sizes with SiO2 insulation coating on SMCs magnetic properties remains unexplored to date.

    In this work, FeSiCr/SiO2 SMCs were prepared by using the sol–gel method. The differences in magnetic performance between two different particle sizes of FeSiCr SMCs are compared. The coating thickness of the samples is modified by adjusting the amount of tetraethyl orthosilicate (TEOS). The sample’s magnetic properties as well as the DC, hysteresis loss and eddy current loss are studied systematically.

2.   Experimental procedure
  • Two FeSiCr powders with different average particle sizes, labeled as S1 and S2, were prepared using the casting method. The experimental schematic is shown in Fig. 1. As a coupling agent and silicon source, silane coupling agent (C9H23NO3Si, APTES, Chron Chemicals) and tetraethyl orthosilicate (C8H20O4Si, TEOS, Chron Chemicals) were employed, respectively. FeSiCr powder (20 g) was used with 170 mL of absolute ethanol and placed in a water bath. A mixture of 5 mL of APTES and 30 mL of deionized water was then added to the solution, and the mixture was maintained under mechanical stirring at 500 rpm for one hour. Following the APTES reaction for one hour at room temperature, TEOS was added (0 mL/g, 0.05 mL/g, 0.1 mL/g, 0.15 mL/g, 0.2 mL/g, and 0.25 mL/g), and the temperature was further raised to 60 °C. After heating the solution for two hours, FeSiCr/SiO2 powder was obtained. The coated powder was dried at 60 °C for 24 hours. Epoxy resin (1 wt%) was dissolved in acetone, then the coated powder was added and stirred until the acetone was evaporated. As a lubricant, 0.5 wt% zinc stearate was added to the coated powder before pressing. The powder mixture was pressed into an annular sample with an outer diameter of 12.8 mm and an inner diameter of 6.4 mm under a pressure of 1950 MPa. Following annealing at 600 °C for two hours in a vacuum atmosphere, the sample was cooled in the furnace.

  • Losses were tested using a B–H analyzer to measure the total loss of samples. To investigate the response mechanism of insulation-coated SiO2 to reduce eddy current losses, we performed loss separation of the total losses to obtain the corresponding different types of losses. The total losses (Pcv) can be expressed as[21,22]

    where Ph is the hysteresis loss, f is the frequency, H is the magnetic field, and B is the magnetic induction, Pe is the eddy current loss, C is the proportionality constant, B is the flux density, ρ is the resistivity, and d is the thickness of SMCs.

    Based on the above equations, the power loss can be expressed as

    where Ch and Ce are two constants. Thus, Ph is proportional to f, Pe is proportional to f2, Pex is often negligible. Therefore, we can fit a Pcv/f vs. f curve linearly. The intercept and slope in the Pcv/f vs. f curve are Ch and Ce.

    Thus, Ph and Pe can be calculated according to the following equations:

  • Particle size analysis was conducted by employing a laser particle size analyzer (Malvern Rasterizer 3000). The microstructure of the FeSiCr/SiO2 powder cores was examined via scanning electron microscopy (SEM, TM4000, Hitachi). To characterize the silica insulating coating, energy dispersive spectroscopy (EDS) elemental mapping was employed. The resistivity of the powder cores was assessed using a four-probe resistance tester (RTS-8). The density of SMCs was determined using the density balance. The AC magnetic properties of the samples were evaluated utilizing a B–H curve analyzer (SY-8218, Iwatsu) across a frequency range of 10–100 kHz, with a B value of 50 mT. Furthermore, the DC superposition characteristics of the powder cores were investigated by employing a TH1776 DC bias current source. The TH1776 DC bias current source was employed to measure the inductance (L) of SMCs without magnetic field as L0. The L/L0 characterizes the reduction of inductance with applied magnetic field, the larger the L/L0 the better the DC bias performance.

3.   Results and discussion
  • Figure 2 shows the particle size distribution of the two FeSiCr powders. According to the data in Fig. 2(a), the average particle size of the two powders can be calculated using the formula[23]

    where i represents the i-th column in the histogram, there are a total of n columns in the figure. Di represents the geometric mean of the particle size of the i-th column, which is the square root of the upper particle size times the lower particle size. As a result, the average particle sizes of S1- and S2-type FeSiCr powders are 4.8 μm and 7.2 μm, respectively.

    As shown in Fig. 3, only three diffraction peaks of the Fe phase with the simple cubic structure can be observed in the XRD pattern of pure Fe powders without SiO2 coating. By comparison, after SiO2 coating, in addition to the three diffraction peaks of the Fe phase, a “round hump” appears at 2θ = 15°–30°, indicating that the coated SiO2 is amorphous phase.

    Figures 4(a) and 4(b) present the electrical resistivity and density of FeSiCr/SiO2 SMCs prepared with different TEOS addition amounts. As the number of cladding increases, the resistivity increases, indicating that more SiO2 formation leads to an increase in the insulating properties of the SMCs. Also, the values of resistivity of S1 and S2 are close to each other, indicating the close amount of SiO2 cladding [Fig. 4(a)]. For comparison, we tested the average particle size of pure FeSiCr and SiO2-coated FeSiCr powders using a laser particle sizer. As shown in Fig. S3 of supplementary material, the average particle sizes of SMCs with the TEOS amounts of 0 mL/g, 0.1 mL/g, and 0.2 mL/g are 4.8 μm, 13.6 μm, and 18.8 μm, respectively. Obviously, the particle size of FeSiCr powders increases with the TEOS amount, which can be attributed to the increase of silica coating thickness derived from TEOS hydrolysis. The result has also been demonstrated that the increase of TEOS contents induces the thicker silica coating in previous works on SiO2-coated Fe-based SMCs using the sol–gel method.[16,17] The more insulating SiO2 shell on the FeSiCr core induces the increased resistivity, which is a direct inducement to reduce the eddy currents (Pe).[10] The density of SMC increases gradually with the increase of TEOS contents [Fig. 4(b)], which is related to the number of voids. The void rate (P) can be calculated by the formula

    where ρ0 represents the actual density of FeSiCr/SiO2 SMCs; ρFeSiCr [Fig. 4(b)] denotes the measured density of FeSiCr SMCs without coating (4.6 g/cm3), while ρSiO2 signifies the theoretical density of SiO2 (2.6 g/cm3), x is the mass fraction. Noteworthily, with a relatively lower TEOS content, the decline degree of density is smaller than that of larger contents. Correspondingly, the P shows two different trends, displaying that the P decreases at first and then increases with the increase of TEOS contents. There are two types of structural changes in SMCs: the first is the increase of SiO2 thickness. This results in a decrease in the overall density of SMCs since the atomic mass fraction of SiO2 is significantly lower than that of FeSiCr. The second type is the void variation. With a lower amount of SiO2 coating, the void tends to decrease. It indirectly suggests that a thin SiO2 coating can better maintain the integrity of the SMCs’ sphericalshell structure, thereby enhancing their overall magnetic properties. In contrast, as the amount of SiO2 coating increases, the P becomes significantly greater in company with the more pronounced downward trend of densities. The overuse of TEOS causes the shedding of the SiO2 layer [Fig. 4(b)]. The resulting heterogeneous cladding structures generate more voids. Therefore, the P first decreases and then increases, with a minimum of 2% at TEOS of 0.1 mL/g. From 0 mL/g to 0.1 mL/g TEOS contents, the decrease of P for S1- and S2-type SMCs is 8% and 6%, while the increasing P of S1- and S2-type SMCs is 36% and 23% from 0.1 mL/g to 0.25 mL/g, respectively. Obviously, the changed degree of P in the S1-type SMCs is greater than that of S2. Thus, smaller particle size of SMCs has higher densities and lower voids.

    Figure 5 shows noteworthy distinctions in the magnetic properties between the S1- and S2-type SMCs, employing identical preparation conditions. For the S1-type SMCs, the μeff is notably higher than those of the S2-type SMCs, and the μeff decreases with the addition of TEOS [Fig. 5(a)]. In the uncoated case, the μeff of S1 is much larger than that of S2, because the non-magnetic voids of S1 are less than that of S2 [Fig. 4(b)]. With the increase of TEOS contents, the SiO2 coatings with larger average particle sizes are more likely to drop off (Fig. S2 in supplementary material), because the SiO2-coated FeSiCr powder particles with larger average particle sizes have the greater contact areas. In this case, the adhesion of SiO2 shell on the larger FeSiCr particles is weaker, making the coating easier to drop off under high-pressure compression. After the SiO2 coatings drop off, the FeSiCr particles are exposed, consequently inducing that the μeff decreases more slowly. Compared to the S2-type FeSiCr/SiO2 SMCs, the S1-type core exhibits a smaller core loss (Pcv) [Fig. 5(b)], lower coercivity (HC) [Fig. 5(c)], and greater remanence (Br) [Fig. 5(d)]. This is due to the fact that smaller sized particles have less voids, resulting in a weaker pinning effect, making the smaller HC and Pcv of S1. The more voids mean the lower magnetism. Thus, the Br of S1 is greater than that of S2. As shown in Figs. 5(b)–5(d), with the increase of TEOS addition, the Pcv and HC of SMCs are both decreased, and then increased, while the Br is decreased. Overall, the S2-type SMCs have a lower degree of variability in Pcv, HC and Br than that of S1. The increase of voids and the contents of non-magnetic SiO2 act to anchor the domain walls, which in turn require additional energy to achieve the same magnetization or demagnetization processes, thereby increasing the HC.[24] On the contrary, the decreased voids could induce the reduction of HC. As a result, the HC is correspondingly decreased and then increased [Fig. 5(c)]. The magnitude of change in HC of S1 is larger than that of S2 because of the large change in the void of S1 (Fig. 4). The increase of non-magnetic SiO2 could further result in the decrease of Br [Fig. 5(d)], meaning the weakening of magnetic properties. The magnitudes of changes in HC and Br of S1 are larger than those of S2 because of the greater changes in the void of S1 (Fig. 4).

    Based on the superior magnetic properties, the S1 type of FeSiCr powders are adopted to investigate the coating process on its magnetic performance. The magnetic loss mechanism is further analyzed in the following. Figure 6 displays the surface morphologies for the S1-type FeSiCr powders coated with different TEOS amounts. From Fig. 6(a), pure FeSiCr powder presents an obvious spherical structure. As the coating amount increases, the insulating coating layer progressively builds up. A uniform layer of coating is formed on the outer surface of the FeSiCr particles [Fig. 6(b)]. The Si and O elements are uniformly distributed on the surface of the FeSiCr particles (Fig. S1). In combination with XRD analysis, the coated SiO2 is demonstrated to exhibit amorphous state (Fig. 3). Therefore, we can conclude that the amorphous SiO2 coating is uniformly clad on the crystalline FeSiCr particles. With further increase of TEOS amount, the coating layer on the outer surface of FeSiCr particles starts to exhibit flocculent matter, as seen in Fig. 6(c).

    As shown in Fig. 7(a), the annealed S1-type SMCs exhibit a complete spherical structure as the TEOS coating amount is 0.1 mL/g. In Fig. 7(b), with increasing the coating amount to 0.25 mL/g, excessive SiO2 coating leads to partial coating layer detachment, resulting in an incomplete spherical shell structure of the SMCs. Further elemental analysis of the incomplete coating layer (Fig. S2) indicates the presence of only Si and O elements, suggesting that the excessive SiO2 coating is unfavorable for the formation of the complete sphericalshell structure in SMCs, which may influence the magnetic performance.

    Since the Pcv of the SCMs are primarily composed of Ph and Pe, we further divide the Pcv into Pe and Ph to investigate the influence of the coating process on the SMCs losses.[10,23] Figure 8 illustrates the soft magnetic performance of FeSiCr/SiO2 SMCs. In Fig. 8(a), it can be observed that the μeff remains nearly constant with varying frequencies. The Pcv [Fig. 8(b)], Ph [Fig. 8(c)], and Pe [Fig. 8(d)] all increase with an increase of frequencies. With an increase of TEOS addition, the μeff decreases [Fig. 8(a)], owning to the increase of the non-magnetic SiO2 contents within the SMCs. In Fig. 8(b), the Pcv shows a trend of decreasing first and then increasing with changes of TEOS addition.

    Figure 9 gives the magnetic loss as a function of TEOS addition. The S1-type SMCs with the smaller particle size have lower Pcv, Pe and Ph than those of S2-type SMCs. The resistivities of S1 and S2 are comparable [Fig. 4(a)], so the difference in Pe is not significant, demonstrating the close amount of SiO2 coating on the particle surface with different sizes. The Pe decreases with the increase of TEOS amount. The more non-magnetic SiO2 content increases the resistivity and thus reduces Pe.[23] The Pe does not change obviously, which might attribute to the thinner cladding layer relative to the large particles. The Ph for S1-type SMCs is smaller than that of S2, because the P of S1 is less than S2 [Fig. 4(b)], resulting in a more pronounced pinning effect for the S2. Overall, the Ph plays a dominant role in the Pcv, inducing that the total Pcv of S1 is less than that of S2. Notably, increasing the amount of TEOS results in a decrease of Ph initially, followed by an increase (Fig. 9). The Ph refers to the energy consumed during the repeated magnetization process of ferromagnetic materials due to the magnetic hysteresis. These losses are primarily caused by the pinning effect of domain walls during the magnetization process.[25] With the increase of TEOS contents, the voids first decrease and then increase [Fig. 4(b)]. During the magnetization process, the P can act as pinning centers for domain walls, impeding the movement of domains. Consequently, the HC first decreases and then increases, leading to a similar trend in the Ph, which initially decreases and then increases. The addition of the coating layer could fill the voids, making the denser structure and reduced P. Later, with the overuse of the TEOS contents, the coating layer is broken [Fig. 7(b)], forming the heterogeneous sphericalshell structure with the larger P. In the smaller particlesize SMCs, the less voids signify that the same amount of SiO2 is more likely to fill the voids, presenting the more obvious variations of voids in the S1-type SMCs. Therefore, smaller particle sizes with less voids are beneficial for reducing Pcv in the SMCs. As the TEOS coating increases, the Ph dominates the Pcv, causing the Pcv to first decreases and then increases.

    After optimizing the insulation coating processes, the magnetic performance of the FeSiCr/SiO2 SMC reaches its optimum at B = 50 mT and f = 100 kHz, with a μeff of 26 and Pcv of 262 kW/m3. Table 1 provides a comparison of the effective permeability and losses of different types of soft magnetic composite materials. Researchers previously prepared FeSiCr SMCs with four particle sizes of 820 μm, which were obtained as the μeff of 16.3–45.52 and Pcv of 239–1500 kW/m3 at a magnetic field of 50 mT and a frequency of 100 kHz.[16–18,26,27] Geng et al. reported FeSi/ZrO2 SMCs (45 μm), with a Pcv of 489 kW/m3 (B = 50 mT and f = 50 kHz).[28] Lei et al. fabricated Fe/Al2O3 SMCs (70 μm), resulting in a μeff of 35 and Pcv of 400–500 kW/m3 (B = 20 mT and f = 100 kHz).[29] Wang et al. prepared FeSiCr/CaCO3 SMCs (40 μm), achieving a μeff of 27 and Pcv of 466.5 kW/m3 (B = 50 mT and f = 100 kHz).[30] Our FeSiCr/SiO2 SMCs have relatively higher μeff of 26 and lower Pcv of 262 kW/m3 at B = 50 mT and f = 100 kHz under the same test conditions, making the SMCs more conducive to device applications.

    Figure 10 shows a comparison of the magnetic performance among the FeSiCr/SiO2 SMCs produced in this study and currently available commercial FeSi-based SMCs. Compared to the FeSi-based SMCs with a size of 0.356 cm3 produced by Beijing Seven Star Flight Electronics Co., Ltd. (SSFE), the FeSiCr/SiO2 SMCs prepared in this study has a slightly lower μeff (56%), surprisingly companying with a significantly lower Pcv (62%).[31] Relative to the Magnetics (MAG) in U.S.A. (size 222 mm3) and Chang Sung Corporation (CSC) in South Korea (size 14.048 cm3), our SMCs shows lower μeff (56%) and reduced Pcv, with decreases of 62% and 71%, respectively.[32,33] In comparison to the FeSi-based SMCs with a size of 0.356 cm3 prepared by Zhejiang Dongmu Keda Magnetics & Electronics Co., Ltd. (KDM), the SiO2-coated FeSiCr SMCs prepared here has the same μeff of 26 and reduced Pcv by 47%.[34] Therefore, the FeSiCr/SiO2 SMCs developed in this work have lower losses and are expected to be a valuable resource for domestic applications of SMCs at high frequencies.

    The presence of a DC component in an AC power system can lead to a decay in L, which is called the DC bias performance.[35,36] Compared to the FeSiBNbCu/ZrO2 SMCs prepared by Zhou et al. with a DC bias performance of 59.3% at 100 Oe, our SMCs have a comparable Pcv and better DC bias performance (65%) at the same initial permeability. Therefore, the FeSiCr/SiO2 SMCs could meet the requirements of relatively low Pcv and high DC bias performance, indicating a good application prospect for power magnetic devices.

4.   Conclusions
  • The FeSiCr/SiO2 powder cores were prepared using the solgel method. Suitable TEOS amount was added to produce the SiO2 coating outside the FeSiCr particles to form a coreshell structure, while the overuse of TEOS caused the shedding of the SiO2 layer. The influence of magnetic SMCs properties for original FeSiCr powders with different particle sizes less than 10 μm is explored. During the process of SMCs synthesis, the cooperative effect of the SiO2 coating and voids on the soft magnetic properties of SMCs is revealed. With the increase of TEOS contents, the slight increase of SiO2 thickness relative to the micron-sized particles induces the weak variations of resistivity and eddy current loss. In addition, the voids are first decreased and then increased. With a lower amount of SiO2 coating, the voids tend to decrease, suggesting that a thin SiO2 coating could well maintain the integrity of the SMCs’ spherical-shell structure, thereby enhancing their overall magnetic properties. More SiO2 coating induces the greater voids in company with the more pronounced downward trend of densities. The fluctuation of voids generates the consistent variations of coercion, hysteresis loss and total loss, which first decrease and then increase. By contrast, the voids are more important and are related to the SiO2 coating thickness, playing a major role of hysteresis loss in the total loss. Using the smaller particle sizes could be capable of decreasing the voids, further reducing core loss in the SMCs. According to the coating optimization, we achieve μeff and Pcv of 26 and 262 kW/cm3, respectively, at 100 kHz and 50 mT for the SMCs. Under identical preparation conditions, our SMCs exhibit enhanced DC stacking performance, reaching up to 87%. By adopting the strategy of smaller FeSiCr particle sizes, the soft magnetic properties and DC bias superposition characteristics of FeSiCr/SiO2 SMCs are significantly improved.

Figure (10)  Table (1) Reference (36)

Catalog

    /

    DownLoad:  Full-Size Img  PowerPoint
    Return
    Return