2025 Volume 34 Issue 6
Article Contents

Yanan Feng, Xiaohu Li, Sheng-Li Qin, Tom J. Millar, Ryszard Szczerba, Zhenzhen Miao, Juan Tuo. JCMT observations of CO, SO2, and a U-line in circumstellar envelopes of four O-rich AGB stars[J]. Chinese Physics B, 2025, 34(6): 069701. doi: 10.1088/1674-1056/adbedc
Citation: Yanan Feng, Xiaohu Li, Sheng-Li Qin, Tom J. Millar, Ryszard Szczerba, Zhenzhen Miao, Juan Tuo. JCMT observations of CO, SO2, and a U-line in circumstellar envelopes of four O-rich AGB stars[J]. Chinese Physics B, 2025, 34(6): 069701. doi: 10.1088/1674-1056/adbedc

JCMT observations of CO, SO2, and a U-line in circumstellar envelopes of four O-rich AGB stars

  • Received Date: 16/11/2024
    Accepted Date: 20/02/2025
    Available Online: 01/06/2025
通讯作者: 陈斌, bchen63@163.com
  • 1. 

    沈阳化工大学材料科学与工程学院 沈阳 110142

  1. 本站搜索
  2. 百度学术搜索
  3. 万方数据库搜索
  4. CNKI搜索

Figures(2)  /  Tables(4)

Article Metrics

Article views(696) PDF downloads(2) Cited by(0)

Access History

JCMT observations of CO, SO2, and a U-line in circumstellar envelopes of four O-rich AGB stars

Abstract: The circumstellar envelopes (CSE) of asymptotic giant branch (AGB) stars are abundant in molecular emissions, offering valuable insights into the physical and chemical conditions of these evolving stars. In this paper, we report observations of two molecules (CO and SO2) toward four O-rich AGB stars using the James Clerk Maxwell Telescope (JCMT). We detected an unusual SO2 spectral feature comprising both broad and narrow components in IK Tau and AP Lyn. The broad line profiles may originate from thermal molecular emission, while the narrow profiles could come from other species (or masers) or astrophysical phenomena occurring within the CSEs of the AGB stars, such as episodic mass loss, bipolar outflows, or emissions associated with the complex physical processes near the central star. The narrow lines of SO2 may also arise from vibrationally excited emissions. Additionally, we observed the same U-line in both TX Cam and IK Tau, which may originate from the molecule N17O. We analyzed the identified molecular lines using rotational diagrams to determine their excitation temperatures, column densities, and fractional abundances. This information aids in the constructing of reliable astrochemical models for a more detailed examination of the target stars. The narrow component of the SO2 line suggests unusual astrophysical phenomena, making IK Tau and AP Lyn particularly intriguing for further investigation to fully understand the physical processes at play in these sources.

1.   Introduction
  • The mass of Asymptotic Giant Branch (AGB) stars typically fall between 0.8 and 8 solar masses. AGB stars experience mass loss through dense stellar winds, driven by radiation pressure on dust particles formed above the photosphere.[1] At this stage, the stellar wind ejects substantial amounts of matter, forming a circumstellar envelope (CSE) around the star that contains dust, molecules, and the so-called s-process elements that formed in the slow neutron capture process.[2] The star’s carbon-to-oxygen (C/O) ratio influences the stellar spectrum and wind acceleration. AGB stars with the C/O ratio < 1 are oxygen-rich (O-rich), S-type AGB stars have a C/O ratio close to 1, and carbon-rich (C-rich) AGB stars have a C/O ratio > 1.[3,4] Observations of AGB stars and their CSEs provide critical insights into the physics of mass loss and the chemical enrichment of the galaxy. The vast outflows from AGB stars play a crucial role in the formation of planetary nebulae. This process occurs when the star’s outer layers are eventually ejected, and the hot white dwarf is exposed, which ionize the ejected matter.[5]

    The chemical composition of AGB stars of different chemical types exhibits common characteristic. The types of parent molecules which formed in non-equilibrium chemistry (e.g., CO, SiO, HCN, and CS) are often independent of the photospheric C/O ratio.[6,7] However, certain specific molecules are indicative of typical O-rich or C-rich environments, such as SO, SO2, and H2S in O-rich AGB stars CSEs, and C2H2 and HC3N in C-rich CSEs. Over the years, the oxygen-bearing molecules SO and SO2 have been extensively studied in the CSEs of O-rich AGB stars. The authors in Ref. [7] suggested that SO appears to be a characteristic molecule of the CSEs of O-rich AGB stars, likely forming close to the stars. The authors in Ref. [8] found that in the chemical model of O-rich AGB stars, there were significant discrepancies for SO2, suggesting that some SO2 emissions may form in the outflow region. Chemical model simulation of O-rich CSEs show that the emission of SO and SO2 comes from the region close to the star.[9] As a “parent” molecule, in chemical models, the abundance of SO is linked to the carbon abundance and is affected by the clumpy outflow from star.[10] Most chemical models consider SO2 as a “daughter” molecule.[8,10,11] The authors in Ref. [12] proposed that the spatial distribution of SO and SO2 emissions in O-rich AGB stars with different mass-loss rates varies significantly. In sources with higher mass-loss rates, SO and SO2 exhibit shell-like structures and are more dispersed within the CSEs, whereas O-rich AGB stars with lower mass-loss rates have more compact spatial distributions. This was confirmed by Ref. [13] through ALMA observations of two O-rich AGB stars, IK Tau, and R Dor. The authors in Ref. [14] also observed this distribution pattern for SO and SO2 molecules in 17 O-rich AGB stars using ALMA.

    We have performed JCMT observations toward various evolved stars and noticed some unusual molecular spectra in a few targets. In this paper, we report the observations of CO, SO2, and a U-line (possibly N17O) in four O-rich AGB stars with different mass-loss rates (ranging from 2.4 × 10−1M⊙⋅yr−1 to 10−6M⊙⋅yr−1). Section 2 describes this work’s source selection and the details of observations. Section 3 focuses on the detected molecular emission lines, including line profiles, calculation methods, and abundance analysis. Section 4 summarizes the main conclusions of this work.

2.   Observations
  • For the selection of the four O-rich AGB stars in our sample, we first chose O-rich AGB stars with detected CO emission, some sources only had integrated intensity information for CO reported, without fractional abundance data. Then, we selected sources within one kpc.[16] Finally, We choose sources with different mass-loss rates to see if it affected the SO2 abundance. The parameters of four selected O-rich AGB stars are shown in Table 1.

    The four O-rich AGB stars were observed using the JCMT located at Maunakea, Hawaii, from August to December 2022 (proposal M22BP013). We used the Nāmakanui instrument with the 230-GHz ‘Ū’ū receiver.[20] The observations were conducted in weather band 4 using the dual sideband observation mode. The time per cycle is 220 seconds in each observation. The full width at half maximum (FWHM) of the ‘Ū’ū receiver is 20.61″ at the frequency of CO (J = 2–1). All observations were made using the ACSIS spectrometer, with a total bandwidth of 1000 MHz and a spectral channel spacing of 488.3 kHz, with 2048 channels.

    The spectral data obtained from the antenna is in terms of antenna temperature (TA*). In this paper, we use the main beam brightness temperature (Tmb) and radiation temperature (TR), which can be obtained using the following equations:

    where ηmb = 0.65, is the main beam efficiency, ηBD is the beam filling factor, θbeam is the antenna half-power beam width (HPBW), and θs is the source size.

    The data were merged using Starlink (The link is http://www.starlink.ac.uk) and processed using the GILDAS CLASS (http://www.iram.fr/IRAMFR/GILDAS) software.

3.   Results
  • We used the spectral line catalogs from the Cologne Database for Molecular Spectroscopy (CDMS, Ref. [19]) in the “Splatalogue” molecular database to identify the observed spectral lines. We detected rotational transitions in the ground vibrational state (see Table 2 for details). A total of 2 transitions (≥ 5σ) and one transition (≥ 3σ) were detected in four sources, including CO, SO2 molecules and a U-line.

    The observed spectra of CO J = 2–1, SO2J = 140,14–131,13 transitions, and an unidentified U-line are shown in Fig. 1. The parameters of all observed molecules, assuming N17O is the source of the U-line, are listed in Table 3. The authors in Ref. [15] reported on the molecules SO2 in 30 O-rich AGB stars, including those in this study with the exception of AP Lyn.

  • For AGB stars, molecular emission from spherical CSEs can result in parabolic, flat-headed, Gaussian-like, or triangular line shapes. Different line shapes might correspond to either optically thick or optically thin conditions.[21] The molecular parameters listed in Table 3 were obtained using the SHELL function of CLASS. Through fitting, we obtained the expansion velocity (Ve) and integrated intensity (∫Tmbdv) from each line profile. Additionally, the table lists parameters including peak intensity (Tmb), the local standard of rest radial velocity (VLSR), and the signal-to-noise ratio (S/N).

    The spectral profiles of CO J = 2–1 transition for the four sources are shown in Fig. 1. The authors in Ref. [22] reported the spectral profiles of three CO transitions toward the O-rich AGB star IK Tau: double-peaked, flatheaded, and parabolic. The CO J = 2–1 transition observed here has a similar parabolic profile to the J = 3–2 transition in IK Tau, indicating that both transitions are optically thick. Observations of BX Cam show that both CO J = 1–0 and J = 2–1 have flatheaded profiles.[23]

    Figure 1 shows also the line profiles of the SO2 transition observed in our sample, with that in AP Lyn being detected for the first time. The SO2J = 140,14–131,13 transitions in IK Tau and AP Lyn exhibit distinctive profiles, with a narrow emission feature superimposed on a broad feature. The authors in Ref. [24] reported similar but less pronounced profiles for 30SiO maser observations. The authors in Ref. [25] reported that the line profiles of SiO v = 0 J = 1–0 in the O-rich AGB star R Leo and the S-type AGB star Chi Cyg consist of a broad plateau and a narrow peak, leading them to speculate that this line is likely due to maser emission. The authors in Ref. [26] observed the spectral profile of SO J = 6–5 in IRAS 19312+1950 using the IRAM 30 m and found it to exhibit both broad and narrow features. ALMA observations of multiple SO2 transitions in IK Tau revealed that the 134,10–133,11 line profile exhibits both broad and narrow features.[13] The narrow component of this transition has similar width as our narrow SO2 transitions of IK Tau. This type of profile has also been observed in the CO lines of the O-rich AGB star EP Aqr.[27] The authors in Ref. [22] reported multiple SO2 observations in IK Tau, but did not find the broad-narrow profile.

    The authors in Refs. [28,29] proposed that circumstellar disks and bipolar outflows might cause the narrow peak in the middle of broad spectral line profiles. The authors in Ref. [30] pointed out that observations and analysis of the C-rich AGB stars U Ant and S Sct revealed that thermal pulses could induce episodic mass loss in the stars. The authors in Ref. [31] reported CO molecular mapping and the narrow peak in the spectral line profiles of the AGB star EP Aqr, showing that the CO emission is generally spherically symmetric, with no evidence of bipolar outflow. In summary, the cause of a narrow line profile superimposed on a broad spectral line profile remains inconclusive, but stars with such line profiles also exhibit more complex CSEs. We fit the broad and narrow components of IK Tau and AP Lyn separately (see Fig. 1), and the line widths of the narrow components of SO2J = 140,14–131,13 are 1.3 km⋅s−1 and 2.3 km⋅s−1, respectively. Table 3 shows the broad spectral line fitting results. Because the broad emission has a similar line width as the CO spectrum, this component is likely attributed to the SO2 molecule. The unusually narrower line profile might arise from maser emission, or from a different molecule, or an outflow, or episodic mass loss. In addition, the profile of the spectral lines may be related to the spatial distribution of SO2, where the mass-loss rate might influence whether SO2 exhibits a shell-like or compact distribution.[12] The authors in Ref. [13] found through ALMA observations of two O-rich AGB stars (IK Tau and R Dor), that narrow component appeared in sources where SO2 exhibited a compact distribution. Therefore, the narrow components in the SO2 molecular spectral line profiles might originate from the dense regions of the outflow.

  • The molecular spectral line shapes can help trace whether the molecules are optically thin or thick.[21,29] In this observation, except for CO (see Fig. 1), which shows a clear parabolic line shape (optically thick), other molecules do not exhibit optically thick characteristics. Therefore, assuming that the observed lines are optically thin is reasonable. Assuming local thermal equilibrium (LTE), we derived the molecules’ excitation temperatures and column densities in the four sources using the rotational diagrams method.[32] These values were obtained using the following formula:

    where Ntot represents the total column density of the molecule, Q is the partition function, Eu is the energy of the upper state, and Tex is the excitation temperature. The Boltzmann constant is represented by k, and ν refers to the rest frequency, W is the spectral line integral intensity, Sμ2 is the product of the line strength, and the square of the electric dipole moment.

    The rotational analysis not only assumes LTE and optically thin emission but also considers the beam dilution of the emission. We must know the size of the emission region for each molecule and use Eq. (2) to estimate the beam dilution factor. Therefore, in this work, we adopt θs (SO2) = 2″.[22,33] If the estimated size of the molecular emission region is too large, it will lead to an underestimation of the fractional abundance of the molecules. There are still many uncertainties in the rotational analyses. The gas kinetic temperature in the CSE is a function of radial distance and the impact is more significant for molecules such as SO2, whose emission does not originate from the inner layer or photodissociation regions.[22]

    As shown in Fig. 2, we performed the rotational analyses of SO2 molecules around four O-rich AGB stars, combining data from the literature. This includes the SO2J = 140,14–131,13 transition from IK Tau, and one newly detected transition from AP Lyn. Except for TX Cam, the integrated intensity of SO2 in the other four sources is proportional to their mass-loss rates.

    The fractional abundance of a molecule can be obtained from the ratio of its column density over the region in which it emits to that of H2 in the same region. The average H2 column density over the molecular emission region at radius R can be derived from the following equation:[34]

    where M˙ is the mass loss rate, R is the radius of the molecular emission, Vexp is the expansion velocity, mH is the mass of hydrogen, and μ the mean molecular weight of 2.8.[34]

    Table 4 lists the values of Tex and Ntot derived for SO2, as well as the source-averaged fractional abundance of SO2 for our four O-rich AGB stars. For IK Tau, we combine our results with several lines of relatively high integrated intensity from Ref. [22]. Since our fits in Fig. 2 use data from different telescopes, we consider the effects of the beam-filling factors (Eq. (2)) in the fitting process.

  • We detected SO2 emissions in four sources. Combining our observations with previous results, we used the rotational diagram method to determine the excitation temperature (Tex), column density (N), and fractional abundance (f) of SO2 in different sources (see Table 4).

    Observations and models of O-rich AGB stars indicate that the spatial distribution patterns of SO and SO2 vary among O-rich AGB stars with different mass-loss rates. Still, they all exhibit characteristics of parent molecules.[12–14] Consequently, astrochemical models generally consider SO and SO2 as parent molecules,[9,38] with an initial fractional abundance of approximately 10−6. In the observations of SO2 in IK Tau, only one transition had a signal greater than 3σ. Therefore, in calculating the abundance of this molecule, we used the excitation temperature of 40 K from Ref. [22]. The column density and fractional abundance of SO2 in IK Tau are within an order of magnitude of those reported by Refs. [22,36]. The authors in Ref. [22] observed multiple SO2 transitions and used the rotational diagram method to calculate the column density and fractional abundance. In Ref. [15], using the IRAM 30 m, the authors observed sulfur-bearing molecules, including SO2, in a sample of O-rich AGB stars. In their abundance calculations, they adopted a simplified scenario, assuming that the SO2 abundance remains constant before decreasing as a Gaussian distribution due to photodissociation by interstellar UV photons. For the fractional abundance of SO2 in BX Cam, our results are similar to those in Ref. [15].

  • Figure 1 shows the presence of an unidentified emission line in two sources IK Tau and TX Cam both of which have S/N ratios greater than 3 (see Table 3). According to the CDMS databases, there are no transitions involving molecules detected in O-rich AGB stars with frequencies close to that of our U-line (244.312 GHz). Despite the existence of the hyperfine structure of N17O J = 5/2–3/2 (244.307955 GHz, 244.3106665 GHz, and 244.3186805 GHz) very close to the unidentified line, the conclusion is that the U-line is not associated with this molecule. Molecular NO is indeed one of the detectable species in O-rich CSEs, and so is N17O, and the authors in Ref. [22] indeed reported a potential N17O hyperfine structure emission line in their IRAM 30-m telescope observations towards IK Tau, which likely supports this identification. However, one should note that the 16O/17O abundance ratio is close to 1500[13] and the line strength of the proposed transition is very small, 0.001 (Table 2) so that this identification is highly unlikely. A detection of the NO molecules in these stars would indicate whether the detection of its 17O isotope is possible.

4.   Conclusions
  • We conducted observations of molecule SO2 and a U-line (possibly N17O) toward four O-rich AGB stars using the JCMT and analyzed the data through the rotational diagram method in conjunction with previous studies. The SO2J = 140,14–131,13 transition in AP Lyn is detected for the first time, and exhibits both broad and narrow line profiles.

    The broad line profile arises from molecular emission from the large-scale mass-loss process. In contrast, the narrow profiles could stem from other species or maser emissions, although contributions from other astrophysical phenomena, particularly episodic mass loss, bipolar outflows, or unknown emissions associated with the complex physical processes close to the central star, cannot be excluded. Additionally, IK Tau exhibits the highest mass-loss rate, with its integrated SO2 intensity significantly larger than that in other three stars, while the fractional abundances show no significant differences. These findings suggest that IK Tau and AP Lyn are more attractive for further investigations to understand the complex physical processes in O-rich AGB stars.

Figure (2)  Table (4) Reference (38)

Catalog

    /

    DownLoad:  Full-Size Img  PowerPoint
    Return
    Return