2025 Volume 34 Issue 11
Article Contents

Dapeng Zheng, Siwu Li, Zeliang Xiang. PT-symmetry phase transition in a bipartite lattice with long-range interactions[J]. Chinese Physics B, 2025, 34(11): 110305. doi: 10.1088/1674-1056/addcd4
Citation: Dapeng Zheng, Siwu Li, Zeliang Xiang. PT-symmetry phase transition in a bipartite lattice with long-range interactions[J]. Chinese Physics B, 2025, 34(11): 110305. doi: 10.1088/1674-1056/addcd4

PT-symmetry phase transition in a bipartite lattice with long-range interactions

  • Received Date: 10/04/2025
    Accepted Date: 23/05/2025
    Available Online: 01/11/2025
通讯作者: 陈斌, bchen63@163.com
  • 1. 

    沈阳化工大学材料科学与工程学院 沈阳 110142

  1. 本站搜索
  2. 百度学术搜索
  3. 万方数据库搜索
  4. CNKI搜索

Figures(5)

Article Metrics

Article views(415) PDF downloads(3) Cited by(0)

Access History

PT-symmetry phase transition in a bipartite lattice with long-range interactions

Abstract: We investigate the parity–time (PT) symmetry-breaking quantum phase transition in a one-dimensional (1D) bosonic lattice featuring cavity-mediated long-range interactions and spatially staggered dissipation. By mapping the system to an effective spin chain under the constraints of hard-core bosons and integrating the mean-field decoupling approach with biorthogonal basis formalism, we derive a self-consistency equation. Numerical simulation results validate that the derived equation quantitatively captures the PT-symmetry order parameter’s phase diagram. Our findings reveal that coherent hopping maintains PT symmetry through quantum fluctuations. Conversely, cavity-engineered long-range interactions, in synergy with staggered dissipation, act in opposition to drive symmetry breaking. This competitive interplay can inspire further exploration of tunable quantum phase transitions in non-Hermitian systems.

1.   Introduction
  • Ultracold atoms in optical lattices provide an experimentally accessible quantum platform for simulating strongly interacting many-body systems and exploring fundamental quantum phases with precise control of interactions and lattice configurations.[1–6] This platform has become a paradigmatic realization of the Bose–Hubbard (BH) model, successfully emulating equilibrium phenomena including the Mott insulator (MI) to superfluid (SF) transition.[7–12] Early studies on this field were predominantly confined to closed quantum systems with short-range couplings due to experimental limitations, whereas state-of-the-art precision control techniques have now enabled two transformative capabilities: controlled dissipation for stabilizing non-equilibrium quantum states,[13–15] and tunable long-range interactions mediated by optical cavities.[16–20] These developments enable the realization of novel phases, such as the supersolids (SS) and the charge density waves (CDW).[21–25]

    Recent breakthroughs in dissipative cold-atom platforms have enabled the creation of synthetic gain-loss landscapes exhibiting parity–time (PT) symmetry.[26–31] In the context of non-Hermitian quantum mechanics and open quantum systems, two particular symmetries are of relevance: parity (P) symmetry, or spatial inversion, and time-reversal (T) symmetry. If the action of the combined PT operators on the Hamiltonian satisfies the relation PTH(PT)−1=H, the Hamiltonian is PT-symmetric.[32–34] In these systems, balanced non-Hermitian potentials preserve real energy spectra until spontaneous PT-symmetry breaking occurs, triggering a transition to complex eigenvalues, which is a hallmark of non-Hermitian criticality.[32,35] State-of-the-art studies employing complementary theoretical approaches, including mean-field approximations, analytically exact methods, and nonlinear spin-wave theory, have systematically identified distinct phenomena in one-dimensional (1D) PT-symmetric quantum systems: the collapse of quantum–classical correspondence,[36] topological boundary-induced spectral reconstruction,[37] and emergent dynamical instability mechanisms.[38] At the same time, coupling atoms to high-finesse optical cavities enables photon-mediated long-range interactions[16,17] where atoms coherently exchange photons over extended lattice distances. This kind of experimental setup was successfully established in Ref. [23], which achieved independent control over three energy scales by combining an optical lattice with cavity-mediated interactions and observed the presence of SS and CDW phases.

    Emerging theoretical and experimental advances have unveiled a variety of PT-symmetry breaking phenomena and unconventional collective phases in non-Hermitian quantum systems with long-range interactions.[39–43] Notable experimental breakthroughs in optically coupled nanoparticle arrays[39] and trapped-ion platforms[40] have successfully realized non-Hermitian dynamics with precisely controlled exceptional points. From a theoretical perspective, the synergy between dissipative processes and long-range coupling has been shown to induce novel quantum phases and fundamentally modify entanglement scaling laws in extended spin systems.[41–43] These findings collectively underscore the critical importance of investigating the intertwined effects of non-Hermiticity and long-range interactions in quantum many-body physics. Since non-Hermitian dissipation and long-range interactions inherently disrupt the spatial symmetry required for PT-symmetry, whereas coherent hopping tends to preserve it,[20,35] elucidating the competition between these mechanisms is essential for understanding quantum phase transitions in non-equilibrium systems.[44,45]

    In this work, we focus on the effects of cavity-mediated interactions on bosons in a 1D bipartite optical lattice with alternating gain and loss. The system maintains PT symmetry when coherent hopping and long-range interactions are balanced, while symmetry breaking emerges at critical hopping strengths. We demonstrate that for hard-core bosons (i.e., strong on-site repulsion that allows only single-particle occupancy) in one dimension, the phase diagram of the effective ground state characterized by the lowest real part of the eigenspectrum[46] is influenced by all of hopping, dissipation, and interactions. These effects combine in a non-trivial manner, resulting in a complex phase diagram that extends beyond the traditional MI to SF transition. We show that the interplay between PT-preserving quantum fluctuations (dominated by hopping) and PT-breaking mechanisms, cavity-mediated long-range interactions as well as dissipation, leads to a dynamic competition. This redefinition of quantum criticality in open systems provides new insights into phase transitions in non-local interaction and non-Hermitian systems.[47,48]

    The rest of the paper is organized as follows. Section 2 introduces the non-Hermitian model and derives its effective Hamiltonian via boson-spin mapping, establishing the foundation for PT-symmetry analysis. Then, in Section 3, we systematically develop the self-consistency equation using the biorthogonal basis formulation, which enables Section 4 to construct the phase diagram and analyze the factors that dominate the phase transition. Finally, we summarize the main results in Section 5.

2.   Model
  • Bosons in an optical lattice with cavity-mediated long-range interactions are described by an extended Bose–Hubbard (EBH) model.[16,49–52] We consider an ensemble of bosonic gas trapped in a 1D optical lattice located inside an optical cavity, and its dynamics can be described by the Hamiltonian[25]

    where b^j†(b^j) is the bosonic creation (annihilation) operator at the j-th site, n^j=b^j†b^j is the number operator, N is the number of sites, t is the tunneling amplitude, U0 is the on-site repulsion, μ is the chemical potential, and Ul is the strength of the infinite-range interactions mediated by the cavity. The first line in Eq. (1) represents the single-particle part of the atomic gases, while the second line describes both local and global-range interactions in the system. The cavity-mediated long-range interactions are represented as the square of the density-wave order parameter x^,

    where ∑j∈e (∑j∈o) represents the sum over even (odd) lattice sites.[45]

    In the hard-core boson limit (U0 → ∞), onsite multiple occupancy is strictly prohibited, thereby mapping the system to spin-1/2 excitations with single-particle per site constraints. The mapping is given by b^j†→S^j†=S^jx+iS^jy and b^j†b^j→S^jz+1/2,[53] which allows us to obtain an effective 1D-spin-chain model for the system, as shown in Fig. 1,

    The density-wave order parameter corresponds to the lattice’s total staggered magnetization, which quantifies antiferromagnetic long-range order. We can define it as

    In the hard-core limit, the cavity-mediated long-range interaction is equivalent to the long-range interaction among the spin-z component. On the other hand, the hopping term in Eq. (1) translates into a ferromagnetic (FM) short-range interaction in the spin-XY plane. Therefore, CDW or SF order in the bosonic system is equivalent to AFM-z or FM-xy order in the spin system.[25]

    Previous analysis has predominantly focused on the Hermitian sector of the system, with intentional omission of non-Hermitian processes. To extend this model into the non-Hermitian domain, a PT-symmetric configuration is engineered by imposing staggered dissipation: even (odd) lattice sites experience particle gain (loss) at rate γ, encoded in the Hamiltonian H^eff=H^spin−iγ2∑j(−1)jn^j. Here, the alternating sign factor (−1)j explicitly correlates with the spatial dissipation pattern, preserving the system’s PT-symmetry through balanced gain and loss. In our analysis, we focus on the system dynamics within a timescale that is short compared to the inverse loss rate 1/γ. In this case, the eigenstate associated with the lowest real part of the eigenspectrum can be identified as the effective ground state, while the imaginary components of the eigenenergies characterize the decay rates corresponding to each eigenstate.[46] The effective non-Hermitian Hamiltonian can be expressed as

    where Jjk = (−1)j+k.

    The non-Hermitian Hamiltonian can be studied through a mean-field decoupling scheme. Central to this approach is the order parameter m≡〈M^〉/N. Applying the linearization procedure,

    the original quartic interaction is reduced to a linear operator form. Applying the linear approximation to the effective Hamiltonian (5) eliminates explicit operator products, yielding the mean-field form[24]

    The self-consistency equation for the imbalance order parameter m can be derived from m=〈M^〉/N.

    The spin operators can be mapped to fermionic operators through the Jordan–Wigner transformation. This procedure converts the original interacting spin system into a quadratic fermionic model, which can be exactly solved in one dimension[54–56]

    Consequently, the mean-field Hamiltonian in Eq. (7) reduces to a quadratic form in terms of fermionic operators,

    Note that the constant terms are neglected since they do not change the system’s dynamic properties.

3.   Self-consistency equation
  • Following the formulation of the fermionic mean-field Hamiltonian, we can drive the self-consistency equation. Due to the staggered potential terms (−1)j of the system, the lattice can be divided into even (j = 2m) and odd (j = 2m + 1) sublattices. This bipartition is formally implemented by defining sublattice operators,

    In momentum space, the Hamiltonian can be written as

    in which

    Diagonalization of the Hamiltonian matrix yields the eigenenergy spectrum Ek,

    By employing the sublattice decomposition defined in Eq. (10), the self-consistency equation can be expressed in momentum space as

    In the thermodynamic limit (N → ∞), the sum can be converted into an integral

    The derivation of the exact self-consistency equation requires computing the particle density difference between sublattices 〈a^j†a^j〉 and 〈b^j†b^j〉. In our model at effective zero temperature,[46] when the chemical potential is set to μ = 0, the negative energy eigenstates Ek− are completely occupied, while the positive energy eigenstates Ek+ remain unoccupied.

    The Bogoliubov transformation provides a systematic framework for calculating quantum expectation values.[57] In non-Hermitian systems, the Bogoliubov transformation requires extension to a biorthogonal basis to preserve canonical relations.[58] Defining right (|ΨR〉) and left (|ΨL〉) eigenstates with 〈ΨL|ΨR〉 = 1, the dual transformations are

    where the biorthogonal matrices MR=(ukRvkRwkRzkR) and ML=(ukRvkRwkRzkR) satisfy MRML = I.

    The conventional definition of the order parameter becomes inadequate in non-Hermitian systems due to the non-orthogonality of the eigenstates. To maintain thermodynamic consistency, the order parameter must be redefined in the biorthogonal basis as

    The fermionic operators expand in terms of quasiparticles as

    Calculating the biorthogonal transformation coefficients, we get

    where Δk=4t2cos2(k/2)+ϵk2. Through this relation, we can obtain the self-consistency equation,

    In this equation, the Heaviside step function Θ(⋅) restricts the integration domain to the negative-energy states, ensuring that only these states exclusively contribute to the order parameter. Since the origin of dissipation can introduce a non-Hermitian term in the energy spectrum, the real part of Ek− is used to avoid complex-valued outputs in step functions, ensuring physically meaningful results. Having derived the general form of the self-consistency equation, we now turn to a systematic analysis of its mathematical structure and physical implications.

    Prior to mathematical analysis, qualitative insights emerge. We first examine the non-interacting case with Ul = 0, where the solution to the self-consistency equation reduces to the trivial configuration m0 = 0. Through rigorous analysis of the energy spectrum given in Eq. (13), the critical parameter for PT-symmetry breaking is explicitly determined as tc = γ/4. This critical threshold marks the emergence of complex eigenvalues in the spectrum, characterizing the phase transition to a fully PT-symmetry broken phase with order parameter |m| = 1.

    When Ul≠0, long-range interactions modify both the energy spectrum Eq. (13) and the self-consistency equation (21), thereby precluding analytical solutions. We numerically solve this equation through iterative computation of the order parameter m, systematically mapping how Ul-controlled interactions select distinct quantum phases.

    For positive interaction strength, Ul > 0, the system stabilizes a paramagnetic phase with strict sublattice spin balance m = 0, where long-range interaction energies vanish identically. Under these conditions, the energy contribution from the long-range interaction term vanishes identically. Conversely, negative interaction strength, Ul < 0, drives spontaneous symmetry breaking m ≠0, inducing a sublattice-ordered phase with antiferromagnetic-type alignment. This ordering features magnetization contrast between parity-opposite sublattices, resulting in long-range spin correlations.

    At t = 0, spin dynamics become confined to the XY-plane with suppressed hopping. In this frozen limit, the system exhibits sharp solutions: m = 0 for Ul > 0 and m = 1 for Ul < 0. The hopping amplitude t activates quantum fluctuations through the kinetic term, which progressively suppresses long-range order and drives a quantum phase transition to a gapless spin liquid state when t surpasses the critical value tc,[59] with the ordered phase persisting only when t < tc.

4.   Phase diagram
  • In this section, we perform numerical simulations across the parameter space to validate the solutions from the self-consistency equation. Figure 2(a) demonstrates the phase diagram of Eq. (5) obtained through exact diagonalization (ED) implemented within the biorthogonal basis framework. The criticality at Ul = 0 manifests as a phase transition where the order parameter m vanishes for Ul > 0 while attains finite values under attraction Ul < 0 at small t, indicating spontaneous PT-symmetry breaking. Notably, singularities emerge at the parameter boundaries γ = 0, which merit explicit physical interpretation. As shown in Fig. 2(b), solutions to the self-consistency equation (Eq. (21)) maintain quantitative agreement with ED across the parameter space, despite localized discrepancies near the γ = 0 boundary. The amplified PT-symmetry breaking observed in ED data, characterized by enhanced m values compared to predictions, will be analyzed in the following content.

    At γ = 0, the order parameter m vanishes across the entire parameter space, which is a manifestation of finite-size effects inherent to ED methods.[60] The ground state manifests as a quantum superposition of two degenerate Néel configurations: |ΨGS〉=(1/2)(|↑↓↑↓⋯〉+|↓↑↓↑⋯〉), which symmetrizes the staggered magnetization and enforces m=〈M^〉/N=0. The hidden order parameter is quantified via the staggered magnetization variance[61,62]

    with thermodynamic extrapolation implemented through the scaling relation,

    as detailed in Fig. 3(a). The non-zero extrapolated order parameter v(∞) definitively establishes long-range ordering in the thermodynamic limit, even though m vanishes in finite-size ED calculations.

    The system exhibits a clear phase transition between the spin-liquid and antiferromagnetic phases when Ul < 0, as per our expectations. This critical behavior demonstrates quantitative agreement with the numerical solutions of the self-consistency equation shown in Fig. 3(b), confirming the consistency of our analytical framework.

    To systematically map the phase diagram, we show the dependence of the order parameter m on Ul/t at fixed γ/t, as well as its dependence on γ/t at fixed Ul/t. As seen in Fig. 4, |m| remains zero for Ul > 0, while for Ul < 0, |m| exhibits a discontinuous jump to a value between 0 and 1, which increases with larger γ/t. Overall, there is good agreement between the theoretical predictions and the numerical results, although discrepancies between theory and exact diagonalization (ED) data are also evident. The nonzero values of |m| for Ul > 0 in the ED results are likely attributable to finite-size effects, since |m| is expected to vanish in the thermodynamic limit. Similarly, the vanishing of |m| at small γ/t for Ul < 0 may also arise from finite-size limitations. Furthermore, we perform cross-sectional scans through the (γ, t, Ul) parameter space, as shown in Fig. 5. The critical hopping strength tc = γ/4 at γ = 2.5 is marked by white dashed lines, serving as a reference for a symmetry-breaking threshold. An analysis of the PT-symmetry properties’ dependence on Ul reveals that for Ul < 0, increasing |Ul| correlates with higher tc, indicating a stronger tendency for spontaneous PT-symmetry breaking. The m = 0.5 contour (black dashed lines) is overlaid to highlight discrepancies between the ED results and theoretical predictions. Note that this contour does not correspond to the critical boundary between the PT-symmetry and broken phases.

    A notable feature in both Figs. 4 and 5 is the pronounced enhancement of PT-symmetry breaking, as revealed by the ED results. This enhancement originates from two key factors in our non-Hermitian ED implementation. (i) The open-boundary condition induces wavefunction localization via the non-Hermitian skin effect, amplifying boundary-state contributions to m. (ii) Finite-size effects produce quasi-degenerate energy levels that prevent complete gap closure near the phase transition, enabling preemptive order parameter growth. Particularly, our approach, which assumes spatially uniform order parameters and inherently smooths finite-size fluctuations through thermodynamic-limit derivation, underestimates boundary localization contributions to m.

    The global trend reveals competing mechanisms: Parameters γ and Ul drive bosons toward odd–even symmetry breaking (spatially modulated distribution), thereby enhancing m and promoting PT-symmetry breaking. In contrast, hopping strength t amplifies quantum fluctuations that homogenize boson distribution and preserve PT symmetry. This is the same as what we obtained from our qualitative analysis from an energy perspective. Furthermore, the quantitative consistency between theoretical predictions from the self-consistency equation and numerical simulations across all parameter regimes (γ, t, Ul) within mean-field error margins demonstrates the validity of the theoretical framework of the biorthogonal basis.

5.   Conclusions
  • Our analysis reveals that the PT-symmetry breaking in a 1D bosonic lattice arises exclusively from the interplay between dissipation (staggered gain-loss) and long-range interactions, while the hopping terms preserve PT-symmetry. The PT-broken phase emerges only in the attractive interaction regime, where cavity-induced long-range correlations amplify density imbalances. Dissipation extends the parameter regime of PT-symmetry breaking to higher hopping amplitudes, and the non-Hermitian gain-loss modulation amplifies the symmetry breaking. The synergy between PT-symmetric dissipation and cavity-mediated engineering may host emergent topological edge modes and non-Hermitian skin effects and construct a tunable platform for controlling dissipative phases, probing exotic quantum transport phenomena, and developing fault-tolerant quantum sensors. In addition, we observe noticeable discrepancies between the ED results and theoretical predictions. To resolve these differences and to enable more accurate comparisons, further calculations using methods such as DMRG, which can handle larger system sizes, are warranted.

    These findings not only highlight the crucial roles of long-range interactions and dissipation in PT-symmetry breaking, but also open up new avenues for exploration in related fields. For example, the insights gained from this work may inspire further research into PT-symmetric engineering in acoustic metamaterials,[63] quantum magnetism in multicomponent Bose gases in optical lattices,[64] and nonequilibrium phenomena in high-band Bose–Einstein condensates.[65]

Figure (5)  Reference (65)

Catalog

    /

    DownLoad:  Full-Size Img  PowerPoint
    Return
    Return