2025 Volume 34 Issue 8
Article Contents

Zhihong Huang, Nan Li, Jun Zhang, Xiuyuan Li, Zihuan Peng, Chongwen Jiang, Changqing Jin. Theoretical investigation on the H sublattice in CaH6 and energetic performance[J]. Chinese Physics B, 2025, 34(8): 086202. doi: 10.1088/1674-1056/ade1c3
Citation: Zhihong Huang, Nan Li, Jun Zhang, Xiuyuan Li, Zihuan Peng, Chongwen Jiang, Changqing Jin. Theoretical investigation on the H sublattice in CaH6 and energetic performance[J]. Chinese Physics B, 2025, 34(8): 086202. doi: 10.1088/1674-1056/ade1c3

Theoretical investigation on the H sublattice in CaH6 and energetic performance

  • Received Date: 16/04/2025
    Accepted Date: 03/06/2025
    Available Online: 01/08/2025
通讯作者: 陈斌, bchen63@163.com
  • 1. 

    沈阳化工大学材料科学与工程学院 沈阳 110142

  1. 本站搜索
  2. 百度学术搜索
  3. 万方数据库搜索
  4. CNKI搜索

Figures(2)  /  Tables(1)

Article Metrics

Article views(462) PDF downloads(1) Cited by(0)

Access History

Theoretical investigation on the H sublattice in CaH6 and energetic performance

Abstract: Metal superhydride compounds (MSHCs) have attracted much attention in the fields of high-pressure physics due to the superconductivity properties deriving from the metallic-hydrogen-like characteristics and relatively mild synthesis conditions. However, their energetic performance and related potential applications are still open issues till now. In this study, CaH6 and NbH3, which exhibit evidently differences in their geometric and electronic structures, were chosen as examples of MSHCs to investigate their energetic performance. The structure, bonding features and energetic performance of CaH6 and NbH3 were predicted based on first-principles calculations. Our results reveal that high-pressure MSHCs always exhibit high energy densities. The range of theoretical energy density of CaH6 was predicted as 2.3–5.3 times of TNT, while the value for NbH3 was predicted as 1.2 times of TNT. Our study further uncover that CaH6 has outstanding energetic properties, which are ascribed to the three-dimensional (3D) aromatic H sublattice and the strong covalent bonding between the H atoms. Moreover, the detonation process and products of rapid energy-release stage of CaH6 were simulated via AIMD method, based on which its superior combustion performance was predicted and its specific impulse was calculated as 490.66 s. This study not only enhances the chemical understanding of MSHCs, but also extends the paradigm of traditional energetic materials and provides a new route to design novel high energy density materials.

1.   Introduction
  • Metallic hydrogen has long been sought in the field of high-pressure physics since its first proposal in 1935 by physicists Eugene Wigner and Hillard Huntington,[1] with numerous theoretical studies revealing its outstanding properties continuously. In 1968, Ashcroft[2] predicted that metallic hydrogen could exhibit superconductivity at room temperature. In 1999, Nellis[3] predicted its extremely high energy density, making it a potential candidate for fuel, propellant, or explosive. In 2010, its energy density was predicted as 216 MJ/kg by Silvera et al.,[4] which is 46.85 times that of trinitrotoluene (TNT) and far exceeds those of widely studied energetic materials such as the most powerful energetic materials hexanitrohexaazaisowurtzitane (CL-20) and 1,3,5,7-tetranitro-1,3,5,7-tetrazocane (HMX). These remarkable predicted properties have propelled the studies of metallic hydrogen to the cutting edge of materials science and high-pressure physics. However, due to the extremely high pressures required, the synthesis and stabilization of metallic hydrogen remain persistent challenges. In 2012, McMahon et al.[5] theoretically predicted that the synthesis pressure of metallic hydrogen reaches ∼ 500 GPa. In 2017, Isaac Silvera et al.[6] reported the observation of metallic hydrogen under approximately 495 GPa, though great controversies remain.

    In 2004, Neils[7] proposed the concept of chemical precompression, which could lower the formation pressures of metallic hydrogen by introducing other elements, particularly metals. Following this idea, in 2014, Duan et al.[8] predicted that H3S could be synthesized under 111 GPa, which was regarded as a milestone of superhydrides and proved by experimental success that H3S was successfully synthesized under 90 GPa in 2015 by MI Eremets.[9] Then, scientists have devoted their research to superhydrides, especially metal superhydride compounds (MSHCs), and more and more novel MSHCs have been achieved.[10–13] Typically, LaH10 and CaH6 exhibit superconductivity with high-Tc higher than 200 K, similar to that predicted for pure solid-state metallic hydrogen.[11,12] Also, the lattices of superhydrides composed of metals near the s–d border and H atoms possess strong covalent H–H networks,[14,15] which inspire us to hypothesize their high energy density. On the other hand, the ambient-pressure metal hydrides such as AlH3 and MgH2 have been widely investigated as energetic materials.[16–19] In 2021, Wu et al.[17] measured the combustion heat of MgH2, TiH2, and ZrH2 with values of 29.96 MJ/kg, 20.94 MJ/kg, and 12.22 MJ/kg, respectively. In 2024, Makhov et al.[19] reported the addition of Al and AlH3 to an explosive could greatly improve its heat and the TNT equivalent of an underwater explosion. Considering these two aspects, MSHCs should be promising candidates for energetic materials.

    In recent years, our research team has synthesized a series of hydrogen-rich MSHCs,[20–22] such as CaH6 and Lu4H23, using the diamond anvil cell combined with an in-situ laser heating technique. Nevertheless, existing studies[23–26] on high-pressure MSHCs have predominantly focused on their superconductivity and electron–phonon coupling interactions. To date, their energetic performance has barely been studied, while its comprehension is essential for developing novel energetic materials.

    In this work, the detailed energetic performance of CaH6 and NbH3 was investigated based on the density functional theory (DFT), which were chosen as the typical representative MSHCs due to their differences in structure and chemical bonding. The critical influences on energetic performance imposed by the structures of MSHCs were uncovered. Further investigations reveal that CaH6 also possesses high energy density and high specific impulse, highlighting its potential applications as high explosives and propellant components.

2.   Methods
  • The original structures of CaH6 and NbH3 under high pressure are obtained from experimental data,[20,22] and are investigated using the Vienna Ab Initio Simulation Package (VASP)[27,28] afterwards. The projector augmented wave (PAW) method[29] with a plane-wave cutoff energy of 400 eV is employed, and the Perdew–Burke–Ernzerhof (PBE) functional within the generalized gradient approximation (GGA)[30] is used to describe the exchange–correlation interactions. Considering the strong electron correlation effects in NbH3, the Hubbard parameter U[31] is applied to the effective potential. The effective U value is set to 2.0 eV for d-orbitals of Nb atoms, as used in the previous literature.[32] To account for van der Waals interactions, the DFT-D3 method[33] is applied for corrections. The convergence criteria for the Hellmann–Feynman force and energy are set to 0.01 eV/Å and 1 × 10−5 eV, respectively. The K-point mesh is sampled within 2π × 0.02 Å−1 using the Gamma scheme in the Brillouin zone. The structures and electron localization function (ELF) of the two MSHCs are visualized using the VESTA ver. 3.90.0a program.[34] The integrated crystalline orbital Hamiltonian population (ICOHP) calculations are carried out by employing the LOBSTER ver.5.1.1 program.[35]

    The calculations of the theoretical detonation parameters of the two high-pressure MSHCs, including heat of detonation (Q), detonation velocity (D), and detonation pressure (P), were conducted following the Hess’s law and Kamlet–Jacobs equations[36] as shown below:

    where M = Ca and Nb, and x = 6 and 3, respectively; ϕ represents a parameter for energy under detonation conditions, N (in mol/g) represents the amount of moles of gas products formed per gram of MSHCs during detonation under high pressure, m is the average molar mass of these gases, which is 2.016 g/mol, and ρ (in g/cm3) denotes the density of the two MSHCs under high pressure. Moreover, the energy densities of the two MSHCs are numerically equal to their Q, according to the common definition for traditional energetic materials.

    The thermal decomposition behavior of CaH6 was simulated by AIMD within the CP2K program,[37] with the orbital transformation technology[38] used to accelerate computing. A 2 × 2 × 2 supercell of CaH6 containing 112 atoms was conducted and optimized under 200 GPa. After optimization, the system was run for 10 ps at 3000 K, and subsequently for 3 ps with cooling to 298.15 K in the constant NPT ensemble at 1 atm under the PBE-D3[39] level of theory with the DZVP-MOLOPT-SR-GTH[40] basis set. The convergence criteria for forces and energy were set to 0.01 eV/Å and 1 × 10−5 eV, respectively. All simulations were performed under periodic boundary conditions (PBC), and the thermostat was set as CSVR for efficient and accurate temperature control. The time step was 0.5 fs, and the time constant was 200 fs. The DIIS minimizer was employed for all integration calculations in the simulations.

    The calculations of combustion performance were carried out by employing the Explo5 ver.6.04 program under isobaric combustion conditions at a chamber pressure of 7 MPa, with equilibrium expansion conditions at the nozzle throat.

3.   Results and discussion
  • In this study, CaH6 and NbH3 were chosen and investigated as examples of MSHCs by employing the first-principle GGA-PBE method. Firstly, CaH6 and NbH3 were optimized respectively under 150 GPa and 300 GPa. The calculated structures are similar to the experimental structures,[20,22] and all the relative errors in lattice parameters are within 5% (as listed in Table S1), indicating the reliability of our computational scheme. High formation pressure always causes the energy input to systems, and the energy properties of CaH6 and NbH3 are closely related to the programmed pressure. To eliminate the impact of different programmed pressures, we optimized both structures again at 200 GPa. The structures of CaH6 and NbH3 under 200 GPa almost remain unchanged, and the detailed structure parameters are listed in Table S2. All following discussions of the structures, energies and properties of CaH6 and NbH3 are based on the structures at 200 GPa.

    As shown in Figs. 1(a) and 1(b), compared to ambient-pressure metal hydrides, MSHCs always have higher H coordination, more complex geometric structures and novel electronic configurations. Besides the interactions between metal and H atoms, the high pressure facilitates to drive the transformation of hydrogen to atomic phases. The H sublattices in MSHCs always feature a strong covalent H–H network and high electron density. We first discuss the geometric structures of CaH6 and NbH3.

    Under 200 GPa, the structure of CaH6 (shown in Fig. 1(a)) exhibits high symmetry and high hydrogen content. The Ca atoms in CaH6 form body-centered cubic (BCC) sublattices, and the uniformly distributed H atoms form a highly symmetric covalent H network. Specifically, each H atom bonds with four adjacent H atoms via equivalent H–H covalent bonds with a bond length of 1.191 Å. Every 24 H atoms constitute a H24 cage, in which eight H6 hexagonal units are located in the tetrahedral interstitial sites and six H4 square units are located in the octahedral interstitial sites of the Ca sublattice. In addition, all the distances from the H atoms to the cage-centered Ca atoms in CaH6 are 1.883 Å.

    NbH3 (shown in Fig. 1(b)) has an XY2Z-type Heusler structure, where the Nb atoms occupy the X sites in a face-centered cubic (FCC) arrangement and the H atoms occupy the Y and Z sites. The Y-type and Z-type H atoms in NbH3 are individually distributed in the tetrahedral and octahedral interstitial sites of the Nb sublattice, respectively. The bond lengths of Nb–HY–type bond and Nb–HZ–type bond are respectively 1.719 Å and 1.985 Å, and the shortest distance between the adjacent H atoms is 1.719 Å.

    Further, the electronic structure and bonding features of CaH6 and NbH3 were investigated via ELF and ICOHP. The ELF, derived from the topological analysis of electron pair probability based on the Pauli exclusion principle, can intuitively display the electron occupation in the MSHCs system.[41] And the ICOHP values (commonly negative) can be used to evaluate the interaction strengths between two atoms by integrating the partition of band–structure energy calculated via the Hamiltonian matrix elements weighted densities of states. Specifically, the lower ICOHP value indicates the stronger interaction, while the value close to zero implies no chemical bonding.[42,43]

    The ELF of CaH6 (shown in Fig. 1(c)) shows that there is low electron occupation around Ca atoms and higher electron occupation around H atoms, which implies the electron delocalization and metallization of CaH6. Notably, relatively high electron occupation exists between the adjacent H atoms and expands in the H sublattice of CaH6, which implies an extended H network with covalent H–H bonds. The ICOHP value for H–H bonds (−0.559 eV) is lower than those for Ca–H (−0.126 eV) and Ca–Ca (−0.036 eV) interactions. Both ELF and ICOHP of CaH6 reveal the strong H–H covalent bonding, weak interaction between Ca and H atoms and no interaction between Ca atoms.

    For NbH3 (shown in Fig. 1(d)), the ICOHP values of Nb–HY, Nb–HZ and Nb–Nb are respectively −1.201 eV, −0.585 eV and −0.534 eV, which imply the strong bonding interactions of Nb–H and Nb–Nb. The high electron occupation between the Nb and H atoms indicates that Nb–H bonds exhibit a certain degree of covalent character, and both the low electron occupation and the near-zero ICOHP value of −0.040 eV between the adjacent H atoms indicate the weak interactions between them.

    Here, we further discuss the performance of H atoms under different pressures. Under ambient pressure, H atoms typically form H2 molecules, where the H–H bond is a σ-bond formed by the overlap of the two 1s orbitals of H atoms, with a bond length of 0.74 Å and an ICOHP value of −2.555 eV. The intermolecular distances between H2 molecules exceed 3 Å, and their interactions are dominated by dispersion forces. For the traditional metal hydrides at ambient-pressure conditions, such as AlH3, H atoms interact with metal atoms through ionic bonds, while there is almost no interaction between H atoms. The ELF (Fig. S1) and ICOHP of AlH3 indicate that electron occupation mainly locates around H atoms. The ICOHP values for Al–H and H–H are respectively −1.309 eV and −0.003 eV, which means the strong ionic interactions between Al and H atoms but almost no interactions between H atoms.

    However, the H atoms behave differently in high-pressure MSHCs. The high pressure increases both the potential energy and kinetic energy of CaH6 and NbH3 systems, and the kinetic energy increases more quickly than the Coulomb energy with the increase of pressure.[44] The increase of kinetic energy closely depends on the growth rates of pressure and intrinsic properties of the systems, which causes the electron delocalization and metallization of the atoms. Different performances of metallization occur in high-pressure CaH6 and NbH3, which is ascribed to their different metal atoms and other inherent properties. For the CaH6 system, under 200 GPa, the electronic delocalization of Ca and H atoms causes the formation of the equivalent covalent bonding between the H atoms. These pressure-induced delocalized covalent H–H bonds are weaker than the typical σ-bond in the H2 molecule, which aids in forming the metastable covalent H network. This extended H sublattice in CaH6 is a metallic-hydrogen-like structure featuring high energy density. In the NbH3 system, electron delocalization causes a certain degree of covalent character in Nb–H bonds and strong bonding between Nb atoms.

  • The above discussion suggests that the MSHCs possess high energy. In the following section, the energetic performance of CaH6 and NbH3 has been well studied. Also, the relationship between their structural characteristics and energetic performance was explored theoretically by using thermodynamic and molecular dynamics methods.

  • The energetic performance of energetic materials is closely related to their density, formation enthalpy and energy density. Higher density, higher positive formation enthalpy and higher energy density generally contribute to better energetic performance of explosives.[45] The densities (ρ), formation enthalpies (ΔHf) and energy density (Ed, numerically equal to detonation heat, Q) of CaH6 and NbH3 under 200 GPa were calculated and listed in Table 1.

    The ρ of CaH6 and NbH3 under 200 GPa are 4.01 g/cm3 and 10.08 g/cm3, respectively. The high ρ of MSHCs is attributed to the high compact crystal structure compressed by high pressure and the inherent high mass of metal atoms. Their ΔHf values are respectively 1020.98 kJ/mol and 468.92 kJ/mol, both higher than that of CL-20, whose ΔHf is a high positive value of 377 kJ/mol. CaH6 possesses a higher Ed of 22.13 kJ/g, which is 3.6 times that of CL-20 (a traditional energetic material, whose Ed is 6.56 kJ/g) and 2.3 times that of cubic gauche polymeric nitrogen (cg-N, a novel high-pressure energetic material, whose Ed is 9.7 kJ/g).[50] While, the Ed of NbH3 is comparable to that of TNT (4.184 kJ/g[46]) but below CL-20. The outstanding Ed value of CaH6 is closely related to its structure and chemical bonding. CaH6 has a metallic-hydrogen-like structure with high H coordination and extended covalent H–H bonding induced by high pressure. This unique structure makes CaH6 in the metastable state and tends to store more energy introduced by high pressure within the H networks in the form of chemical energy. In contrast, NbH3 lacks the metallic-hydrogen-like structure and bonding features resembling CaH6. Most of the energy introduced by high pressure is stored in the form of Coulomb energy. As a result, NbH3 has a relatively low Ed compared to CaH6.

  • The K–J equations are a common method for predicting the detonation parameters of traditional CHON-based energetic materials, which have also been employed for metal-containing systems.[51] Here, we also borrowed the K–J equations to describe the detonation performance of MSHCs to a certain extent. The detonation parameters are closely related to the detonation reaction process and the corresponding final products. In an ideal case, the final products consist of metal crystal and H2 gas, in which the energy release reaches its optimal level. The corresponding detonation parameters were calculated and listed in Table 1, including the gas production (N), theoretical detonation heat (Q), detonation velocity (D), and detonation pressure (P).

    The N of CaH6 and NbH3 are respectively 0.0650 mol/g and 0.0145 mol/g, due to the difference in their hydrogen content. The Q (numerically equal to Ed) of CaH6 and NbH3 are respectively 5.3 times and 1.2 times TNT equivalent, and all values for their D and P are higher than those of CL-20. Particularly, both the D and P of CaH6 are higher than those of NbH3 by over 30%, which is primarily attributed to its larger H content and the extra energy stored in its metallic-hydrogen-like structure, as discussed above. Thus, substantial amounts of high-temperature gases are released during its detonation, which provides the necessary force for working.

  • As discussed above, CaH6 possesses metallic-hydrogen-like H–H covalent bonds and superior detonation performance. In this section, we further explored its energetic performance and potential applications by employing the ab initio molecular dynamics (AIMD) method and CP2K software. The decomposition process was theoretically simulated with a CaH6 model containing 112 atoms. The system was first optimized under 200 GPa and then was simulated for 3 ps within the NVT ensemble. To provide sufficient energy to initiate the decomposition, the thermostat temperature was set to 3000 K. The evolution of the potential energy and the structure throughout the decomposition simulation are shown in Fig. 2.

    After short time heating, the CaH6 system undergoes a rapid decomposition stage within 0.4 ps. During this stage, extensive bond dissociation occurs, accompanied by the release of hydrogen atoms and a sharp decline in potential energy. The freed H atoms further bond with neighboring H or Ca atoms to form H2 and CanHm clusters. At the end of this stage, 73% of H atoms form H2 molecules and the remaining 27% participate in the formation of CanHm clusters, as shown in Fig. 2(c). According to this simulated decomposition process, there is a decrease in both energy release and detonation parameters of CaH6 compared to the ideal case. Based on the potential energy decline throughout the simulations, the detonation parameters (denoted as CaH6MD) were calculated and listed in Table 1. The results show that CaH6 exhibits large gas production (NMD = 0.0474 mol/g, or 1062.26 mL/g), also far exceeding that of CL-20 (628.5 mL/g.[52]). The QMD is 9.51 kJ/g, which is 2.3 times that of TNT. The DMD and PMD are 11.23 km/s and 80.25 GPa, respectively. Consequently, Table 1 shows the detonation performance of CaH6 in different decomposition processes, the N, Q, D and P respectively lie in (0.65–0.474 mol/g), (22.13–9.51 kJ/g), (16.25–11.23 km/s) and (168.95–80.25 GPa), which are all higher than those of CL-20. Our simulation validates the excellent detonation performance of CaH6 and its tremendous potential as high explosives.

    The above discussion about the hydrogen release suggests the potential of CaH6 for high-performance propellant component. Further, its combustion performance was predicted by using the Explo 5 software. The theoretical vacuum specific impulse (Isp) of CaH6 is 490.66 s, which is 1.9 times that of hexogen (RDX, whose Isp is 258 s)[53] and 3.2 times that of ammonium perchlorate (AP, whose Isp is 155 s).[54] The characteristic velocity (c*) and the combustion temperature of CaH6 are 2672.4 m/s and 2620.7 K, respectively. The main combustion products consist of 24.54% Ca and 71.76% H2, corresponding to a hydrogen release ratio of 97.48%. All these results highlight that high-pressure CaH6 exhibits combustion performance far exceeding that of common high-energy propellant components such as RDX and AP, suggesting its potential for propellants.

4.   Conclusion
  • For the first time, CaH6 and NbH3 were chosen as examples of MSHCs to systematically investigate their energetic performance. Since the two MSHCs were obtained under high pressure, both the potential and kinetic energy of the systems increase, while the increase in kinetic energy is more rapid than the Coulomb energy as the pressure rises. Consequently, both MSHCs exhibit high energy densities, with the values of 5.3 times and 1.2 times that of TNT, respectively. Notably, the outstanding energy density of CaH6 is relatively higher than that of NbH3, which is closely related to the structure and characteristic H–H covalent bonds in CaH6. CaH6 possesses highly ordered extended H sublattice and metastable covalent H network with strong pressure-induced covalent H–H bond, which are similar to those in metallic hydrogen and offer CaH6 higher energy density.

    Given this, we conducted an in-depth study of its detonation process and energy release performance. First of all, instead of the complete decomposition into pure Ca metal and H2, CaH6 might undergo complex reactions and produce various CanHm clusters. Furthermore, the corresponding energy density of CaH6 was predicted as 2.3 times TNT equivalent. Consequently, the theoretical energy density of CaH6 ranges from 2.3 to 5.3 times TNT equivalent. Moreover, at least 72.9% of H atoms in CaH6 are finally released to form 35 H2 molecules in the rapid energy-release stage, suggesting its potential for high-performance propellant component. Therefore, we further predicted its combustion performance. The theoretical specific impulse, characteristic velocity and hydrogen release ratio of CaH6 are respectively 490.66 s, 2672.4 m/s and 97.48%, indicating its superior combustion performance far exceeding that of common high-energy propellant components such as RDX and AP.

    Our results demonstrate that the energy density and energy release of high-pressure MSHCs are significantly higher than traditional CHON-based explosives, which makes them a promising candidate for next-generation energetic materials. Certain high-pressure MSHCs, such as CaH6, possess metallic-hydrogen-like structures and characteristic covalent bonds and can release substantial amounts of high-temperature gases during their detonation, demonstrating tremendous potential for explosives and high-energy propellant components. To date, stabilizing MSHCs, which are synthesized at high pressure, under ambient pressure conditions is very challenging. Using the pressure-quench protocol (PQP) or achieving solid solutions is promising to recover the pressure-induced phases to ambient pressure, which may extend the research on MSHCs from basic studies to applied research. This study enhanced the chemical understanding of MSHCs and provided a new route to design novel high-energy-density materials, promoting the exploration of MSHCs in defense, aerospace, and energy sectors.

Figure (2)  Table (1) Reference (54)

Catalog

    /

    DownLoad:  Full-Size Img  PowerPoint
    Return
    Return