2026 Volume 35 Issue 3
Article Contents

Qin Wu, Jiao Peng, Yu-Dong Chen, Zeng-Xing Liu. Dissipative-coupling-induced magnomechanical chaos[J]. Chinese Physics B, 2026, 35(3): 037501. doi: 10.1088/1674-1056/adfa7a
Citation: Qin Wu, Jiao Peng, Yu-Dong Chen, Zeng-Xing Liu. Dissipative-coupling-induced magnomechanical chaos[J]. Chinese Physics B, 2026, 35(3): 037501. doi: 10.1088/1674-1056/adfa7a

Dissipative-coupling-induced magnomechanical chaos

  • Received Date: 21/04/2025
    Accepted Date: 11/08/2025
    Available Online: 01/03/2026
通讯作者: 陈斌, bchen63@163.com
  • 1. 

    沈阳化工大学材料科学与工程学院 沈阳 110142

  1. 本站搜索
  2. 百度学术搜索
  3. 万方数据库搜索
  4. CNKI搜索

Figures(4)

Article Metrics

Article views(244) PDF downloads(0) Cited by(0)

Access History

Dissipative-coupling-induced magnomechanical chaos

Abstract: Chaotic motion that exhibits extraordinary dynamic behavior has attracted particular attention in magnonics in the context of understanding nonlinear magnomechanical interaction. Here, we theoretically explore the magnomechanical chaos induced by dissipative coupling in an open cavity magnomechanical system. Numerical calculations of the magnomechanical dynamics show that the introduction of dissipative coupling can greatly enhance the nonlinearity of the system and induces ultra-low driving threshold chaotic motion, which effectively solves the bottleneck that the weak magnetostrictive interaction cannot trigger chaotic motion in a cavity magnomechanical system. Furthermore, we find that the degree of chaos represented by the Lyapunov exponent can be well tuned by changing the dissipative coupling strength. In addition to providing insight into chaotic behavior in open magnomechanical systems, dissipative-coupling-induced chaotic motion may also hold for other magnonic quantum systems since magnons possess excellent compatibility with other quasiparticles, and may find applications in the chaotic transfer of information.

1.   Introduction
  • Magnonics, as an emergent interdisciplinary field, has been widely studied in the fields of condensed matter physics, quantum optics and spintronics.[1–4] Magnons, the quasiparticles of spin waves, serve as the information carrier that have no movement of charge during the transmission process, avoiding the emergence of Ohmic losses, which is the key advantage of magnonic devices compared with electrons.[1] In recent years, magnomechanical system has attracted much interest in the context of understanding nonlinear magnetostrictive interaction, providing a special platform for observing many intriguing classical and quantum phenomena,[5–26] ranging from entanglement and squeezing states of magnons[14–20] and the magnon Kerr effect[24] to the ground-state cooling of mechanical vibration mode[27–30] and the magnonic frequency combs based on magnetostrictive effect.[31–34] A typical magnomechanical system consists of a microwave cavity mode, a magnon mode, and a mechanical mode, in which the mechanical mode couple to the magnon mode through the magnetostrictive effect, which is the core of the magnomechanical system and the main source of nonlinearity.[35–40] Chaos, as a distinct nonlinear phenomenon,[41–44] holds significant importance in exploring the nonlinear properties of magnonics;[4] however, the weak magnetostrictive interaction of magnons presents a challenge for generating chaotic motion.[45,46]

    Recently, the concept of dissipative coupling has attracted particular attention due to its rich fundamental physics, materials, devices, and potential practical applications, where the cavity and magnon modes interact with cooperative external damping.[47–59] Many exotic phenomena based on dissipative coupling in magnonic systems have been reported; for example, previous studies have demonstrated that the dissipative interaction can suppress magnon damping and thereby reduce the threshold for conventional magnon Kerr bistability.[58] For comparable parameters, for instance, the bistability threshold for dissipatively coupled systems is lower by a factor of about 5, which opens up new possibilities for the exploration of nonlinear phenomena in cavity magnonics.[57] Furthermore, ultra-wideband magnonic frequency comb generation can be implemented by introducing dissipative coupling in an open magnomechanical system. The total width of the magnonic comb in the robust plateau region can be up to ∼400 comb lines, which is much broader and flatter than that reported in the previous works.[59] The introduction of dissipative coupling allows the observation of weak nonlinear phenomena that could not be observed before, which has important scientific significance and practical value in the study of nonlinear cavity magnomechanics.

    Inspired by these works, we propose an efficient mechanism to induce ultra-low threshold magnomechanical chaos by introducing dissipative coupling interplay in an open magnomechanical system. Our results suggest that the dissipative coupling between the cavity and magnon modes plays a crucial role in the dynamic evolution of the magnomechanical system and can significantly enhance the nonlinear magnetostrictive interaction.[35–37] A chaotic motion with an ultra-low drive threshold (∼ nW) is obtained in the magnomechanical system, and the introduction of dissipative coupling adds a new degree of freedom to the manipulation of magnomechanical chaotic motion. Besides being of fundamental importance in chaotic dynamics, this work may have broad implications for many practical applications of secret information processing and communication based on magnonic devices.[60,61]

2.   Physical model and methods
  • The physical model we consider is schematically illustrated in Fig. 1(a), in which a highly polished single crystal yttrium iron garnet sphere with a diameter of 1 mm is placed above the intersection of the microwave cavity and waveguide line. The microwave driving source with a central frequency ωd and a driving amplitude Ωd=κa,ePd/ℏωd (κa,e the external coupling of the microwave cavity mode to the waveguide, Pd the power of the microwave driving field) is introduced into the microwave cavity to excite the magnon mode of the YIG sphere.[5] Simultaneously, a bias magnetic field with a strength of B0 is applied to saturate the magnetization and control the frequency of the Kittel mode, i.e., ωm = γB0, where the gyromagnetic ratio γ/2π = 28 GHz/T.[62] As shown in Fig. 1(b), the magnon excitation will cause varying magnetization due to the magnetostrictive effect, thereby introducing the deformation mode of the ferromagnetic crystal and facilitating its coupling with the Kittel mode.[5] This coupling interaction can be described by a radiation pressure-like Hamiltonian,[63] i.e., Hmb=ℏgmbm^†m^(b^+b^†), where gmb is the single magnon–phonon coupling strength, and b^†(b^) and m^†(m^) correspond to the creation (annihilation) operators of the phonon mode with frequency ωb and magnon with frequency ωm, respectively. The crossline-microwave circuit supports both the standing wave and the traveling wave, where the standing wave forms the cavity mode and contributes to coherent coupling between the magnon mode and the microwave cavity mode, while the traveling wave induces the dissipative coupling between the cavity mode and the magnon mode by radiating energy into an open environment.[47–49] Furthermore, the dissipative coupling strength can be changed by moving the position of the YIG sphere so that the dissipative coupling dominates.[51] As a consequence, the interaction Hamiltonian between the magnon and the cavity photon is given by Hma=ℏ(gma+iΓ)(a^†m^+a^m^†), here a^†(a^) is the boson creation (annihilation) operator of the cavity mode with the intrinsic frequency ωa. gma represents the coherent coupling strength arising from magnetic dipole moment interaction, and Γ denotes the dissipative coupling strength between the magnon and microwave cavity modes through their common storage layer.[47] Therefore, the Hamiltonian of the whole system, which consists of the photon, magnon and phonon modes and their interactions, can be written as

    In order to eliminate the time dependence of the microwave pump term, the system is placed in the rotating frame at the frequency ωd of the microwave driving field, that is, the unitary transformation U(t)=exp(−iωdm^†m^t) is adopted. Thus, the effective Hamiltonian of this non-Hermitian system can be written as

    where Δa(m) = ωa(m) – ωd denotes the frequency detuning between the cavity mode (magnon mode) and the microwave pump field. Under the semiclassical approximation,[64] the operators of each mode are reduced to their average values, viz. a(t)≡a^(t), m(t)≡m^(t), and b(t)≡b^(t). The evolution of the magnomechanical system can be described by the Heisenberg–Langevin equation, i.e., o.=i/ℏ[H,o](o=a,m,b), as follows:

    where ℜ=(a,m,b)T and ℧=(Ωd,0,0)T. κa is the total microwave cavity loss rate that can be written as the sum of the loss rate associated with the input coupling (κa,e) and the remaining loss rate (κa,i), i.e., κa=κa,e+κa,i. κm and κb are the intrinsic dissipation for the magnon and phonon modes, respectively. ϱ=(κaain(t),κmmin(t),κbbin(t))T represent the white noise terms of the corresponding modes, characterized by the temperature-dependent correlation functions[64]

    The thermal occupancy of the baths is given by Bose–Einstein distributions, i.e.,

    where KB is the Boltzmann constant and Tbath is the bath temperature (assumed to be the same for all the modes). Equation (3) is a set of nonlinear differential equations and thus the dissipative coupling between the magnon and microwave cavity modes will affect the dynamical evolution of the system, which may trigger some intriguing nonlinear phenomena.[47,48,58] In what follows, we discuss in detail the influence of dissipative coupling on the chaotic dynamics of the magnomechanical system. Firstly, to characterize the chaotic properties of the magnon, without loss of generality, we define the mean value of the magnon operator as m = mr + imi (mr and mi are real numbers), and the intensity of the magnon is defined as Im=mr2+mi2. The magnonic spectrum S(ω) in the frequency domain can be obtained by performing the fast Fourier transform on Im, where ω is the spectroscopic frequency. Furthermore, the chaotic system is extremely sensitive to tiny perturbations, and in order to quantitatively investigate such hypersensitivity to the initial conditions, we assume the evolution of a perturbation δ=(δar,δai,δmr,δmi,δbr,δbi)T, which characterizes the divergence degree of adjacent trajectories in phase space.[41–43] Here, the perturbation components δar,δai,δmr,δmi,δbr,δbi correspond to the quantum fluctuations of the respective mode operators around their classical mean-field values (e.g., δar,δai for the microwave cavity mode, δmr,δmi for the magnon mode, and δbr,δbi for the phonon mode).

    Thence, the perturbation equation of δ can be obtained by linearizing Eq. (3) and dδ/dt = Mδ, with the coefficient matrix

    The temporal evolution of the magnon mode can be obtained by numerically solving the nonlinear evolution Eq. (3) and the perturbation equations dδ/dt = Mδ under various initial conditions. To investigate the chaotic characteristics during the evolution process of magnomechanic dynamics, we take into account the evolution of a nearby point (Im + δIm) of Im to characterize the property of the magnon mode. The calculated exponential variation of δIm (δIm = |m + δm|2 – Im) demonstrates how the initial states of the cavity field evolve in the temporal domain and phase space. Note that the perturbation component δm corresponds to the quantum fluctuations of the magnon operator around the classical mean-field values (e.g., m^≡m+δm).

    In what follows, we discuss the dynamic evolution of the magnomechanical system under dissipative coupling in detail. Figure 2 shows the numerical results of solving Eq. (3) and the perturbation equations dδ/dt = Mδ in the presence and absence of dissipative coupling. Specifically, in the absence of dissipative coupling i.e., Γ/2π = 0 MHz, the time evolution of the magnon number Im is shown in Fig. 2(a). We can see that after a transient process, the oscillation of the magnon reaches a stable periodic oscillation before t = 1 μs. Note that the disordered oscillations in the inset of Fig. 2(a) arise from environmental white noise dominating the weak coherent dynamics under ultralow driving power (Pd = 1 nW). The spectrum of the magnonic dynamics is shown in Fig. 2(c). It should be pointed out that the magnonic spectrum undergoes a frequency shift of ωd, because the evolution equations describe the evolution of the magnon mode in a frame rotating at the driving frequency ωd. Correspondingly, the exponentially decaying perturbation also demonstrates the periodic evolution of magnons [shown in Fig. 2(b)]. It can be seen from the above discussion that the chaotic motion of the magnomechanical system cannot be triggered by the weak nonlinear magnetostrictive interaction under a weak driving power. However, when dissipative coupling between the magnon and microwave cavity modes is introduced (Γ/2π = 20 MHz), the magnon number Im is dramatically enhanced by approximately 13 orders of magnitude [Fig. 2(d)]. This substantial amplification renders the influence of environmental thermal noise on the magnon dynamics negligible. At room temperature, the thermal magnon occupation number (nth,m ∼ 103) is far lower than the significantly boosted magnon population sustained by the dissipative coupling mechanism. Concurrently, the evolution of the perturbation δIm exhibits exponential divergence over time [Fig. 2(e)], a hallmark signature of deterministic chaos.[42,43] In addition, the broadband spectrum [Fig. 2(f)] further corroborates chaos. This divergence signifies extreme sensitivity to initial conditions (the butterfly effect) and confirms the chaotic nature of the magnon dynamics under dissipative coupling, distinct from noise-induced fluctuations. Therefore, while environmental noise introduces minor fluctuations in the perturbation evolution trajectory and sideband spectrum under dissipative coupling, the defining chaotic characteristics of the system, such as a positive Lyapunov exponent, remain robustly present.

    To further elucidate the pronounced dependency of magnomechanical chaos on dissipative coupling strength, we analyze the variation of the maximal Lyapunov exponent of the magnon mode with the dissipative coupling strength under the weak driving power Pd = 1 nW. The maximal Lyapunov exponent of the magnon mode defined by the logarithmic slope of the perturbation δIm, i.e., δIm(t) = δIm(0)eλLEt, and the logarithmic slope, i.e.,

    which is a mensurable description of the rate of convergence or divergence of nearby trajectories in phase space. In physics, a positive Lyapunov exponent (λLE > 0) implies that the evolution of the magnon mode is chaotic, i.e., divergence and sensitivity to initial conditions. Conversely, a negative Lyapunov exponent (λLE < 0) indicates that the evolution of the magnon mode is ordered. In particular, a zero Lyapunov exponent (λLE = 0) means that the appearance of period-doubling bifurcations.[41–43] Figure 3(a) shows the maximum Lyapunov exponent of the magnon mode varying with the dissipative coupling strength. Obviously, as the dissipative coupling strength increases, the Lyapunov exponent of the magnon mode changes from negative to positive, which means that the system enters a chaotic state from an ordered state. Furthermore, by adjusting the dissipative coupling strength, the degree of chaos can be effectively enhanced, which plays a crucial role in the chaotic behavior of the cavity magnomechanical system. It is worth noting that the dissipative coupling strength is controllable in experiments and can be adjusted by tuning the 3D position of the YIG sphere.[51] From the above results, it can be seen that dissipative coupling provides a feasible way to realize magnomechanical chaos under low power conditions. The variation of the Lyapunov exponent of the magnon mode with the intensity of the coherent coupling is also discussed, and the results are shown in the inset of Fig. 3(a). We can see that when the system is dominated by coherent coupling, the maximum Lyapunov exponent of the magnon is always negative as the coupling intensity increases, which means that coherent coupling cannot induce the system to enter chaotic motion under weak power drive. In this context, dissipative coupling provides a convincing alternative mechanism to address the severe challenge of being unable to trigger magnomechanical chaotic motion under weak driving.

    A pivotal comparison of the maximal Lyapunov exponent λLE evolution with microwave driving power Pd under distinct coupling regimes: dissipative coupling (Γ/2π = 20 MHz) and coherent coupling (gma/2π = 20 MHz, the inset). Crucially, under dissipative coupling, λLE remains persistently positive (λLE > 0) even at ultra-low driving powers down to Pd ≪ 0.1 nW. This signifies the emergence of chaotic dynamics effectively without a lower power threshold. In stark contrast, under coherent coupling, λLE remains strictly negative (λLE < 0) even when Pd is increased by nine orders of magnitude up to 1 W, indicating only stable periodic oscillations. This profound difference stems from the distinct physical nature of the couplings. Dissipative coupling, mediated by interaction with a common reservoir (waveguide), introduces level attraction and significantly amplifies the magnon population.[47,48] This population boost dramatically enhances the effective nonlinearity arising from the magnetostrictive interaction, and the amplified nonlinearity readily triggers chaotic instability at minimal drive powers. Conversely, coherent coupling, while enabling energy exchange, lacks this inherent amplification mechanism. In addition, the effective damping rate of the magnon mode κeff is modified by the cavity-magnon interaction, i.e., κeff = κm + ηκa.[58] The coefficient η=(gma+iΓ)2/(Δa2+κa2) stands for the transfer efficiency of the excitation power from the input port into the magnon system, and κ is dependent on the frequency detuning Δa, and the total damping of the cavity κa. For the coherent coupling region (Γ = 0), in this case, η=gma2/(Δa2+κa2)>0, leading to an enhanced effective damping rate of the magnon mode, i.e., κeff = κm + ηκa. However, for the dissipative coupling region (gma = 0), in this case, η=−Γ2/(Δa2+κa2)<0, leading to a suppressed effective damping rate, i.e., κeff = κm – |κ|κa. Note that, in cavity magnonics, coherent and dissipative interactions usually coexist. Whereas, it is possible to design systems where one coupling type (coherent or dissipative) dominates. The choice to enhance or suppress certain interactions is guided by the objective of a specific device or experiment.[48]

    It is worth noting that the dissipative magnon–photon interaction is mediated by mutual coupling of the magnon and cavity photon to a traveling-wave reservoir, which inevitably introduces additional dissipation in both the magnon mode κm′ and the cavity mode κa′.[47,48,51] To comprehensively characterize the influence of additional dissipation on the chaotic dynamics, we present in Fig. 4 the detailed perturbation evolution δIm under varying cavity and magnon dissipation rates. Phenomenologically, we add the additional dissipation to the evolution Eq. (3), and the Langevin equations are solved numerically with the same simulation parameters. The results show that magnomechanical chaos exhibits significant sensitivity to additional dissipation. To be specific, as the cavity additional dissipation increases (e.g., red curve: κa′=κa; blue curve: κa′=2κa; brown curve: κa′=3κa), the duration of the chaotic motion significantly diminishes (from ∼1.6 μs to ∼ 1.4 μs and shorter), accompanied by a reduction in the maximal Lyapunov exponent λLE, indicating a suppression in both the persistence and the intensity of chaos. A qualitatively similar suppression of chaotic dynamics, characterized by reduced duration and λLE, is observed upon increasing the additional magnon dissipation κm′, as shown in Fig. 4(b). Physically, additional dissipation accelerates the energy loss from the coupled magnon–photon–phonon system, impeding the efficient buildup of nonlinear magnetostrictive interactions essential for chaotic instability. The faster energy decay curtails the time available for trajectories to diverge exponentially in phase space (shorter chaos duration) and dampens the amplification rate of initial perturbations (smaller λLE). Consequently, achieving and maintaining the chaotic state necessitates a careful trade-off between the nonlinearity-enhancing dissipative coupling and the chaos-suppressing environmental dissipation. These findings provide crucial theoretical guidance for the experimental realization and manipulation of ultra-low-threshold magnomechanical chaos. Furthermore, it should be pointed out that dissipative magnon-photon coupling inevitably introduces additional dissipation into both the magnon mode and the cavity mode. However, given that chaos is fundamentally a classical phenomenon, introducing gain into the cavity can compensate for this additional dissipation,[65,66] thereby enabling ultra-low-threshold chaos.

    Finally, discuss the feasibility of the experimental realization of cavity magnomechanical chaos. First, the proposed system is simple and has high feasibility in experimental implementations. The dissipative coupling between the magnons and microwave photons has been experimentally demonstrated, and the parameter requirements are benchmarked against existing cavity magnomechanical platforms, revealing that the predicted chaos regime (microwave driving power Pd = 1 nW, bias magnetic field B0 ∼ 0.3 T, and magnon–phonon dissipative coupling strength Γ/2π ≤ 20 MHz) aligns with currently achievable specifications in YIG-based systems.[5,51] Second, purely dissipative coupling between the cavity and magnon modes can be experimentally realized by placing the YIG sphere above the center of the crossline-microwave circuit, and in addition, the dissipative coupling strength can be changed by moving the position of the YIG sphere.[47,48] Third, YIG crystal maintains a good ferromagnetic property at room temperatures as a result of its Curie temperature being as high as 559 K, which means that the dissipative-coupling-induced magnomechanical chaos is robust against thermal noise at room temperature.[62] Finally, the dissipative coupling-induced magnomechanical chaos exhibits inherent compatibility with hybrid quantum systems. Recent advances in nanofabrication techniques have enabled seamless integration of YIG spheres with on-chip architectures, further facilitating their implementation in scalable quantum platforms. Our findings not only confirm the experimental accessibility within state-of-the-art magnonic architectures but also establish a concrete roadmap for implementing chaotic dynamics as a functional resource in hybrid magnonic systems.

3.   Conclusion
  • In summary, we have theoretically demonstrated that dissipative coupling serves as a powerful mechanism to induce magnomechanical chaos with an ultra-low driving threshold in an open cavity magnomechanical system. By introducing dissipative coupling between the magnon and cavity modes, the nonlinear magnetostrictive interaction is significantly enhanced, overcoming the inherent limitation of weak magnetostriction in triggering chaotic dynamics. Numerical simulations reveal that chaotic motion emerges at an unprecedentedly low driving power (∼ nW), accompanied by a positive Lyapunov exponent. The degree of chaos can be precisely tuned by adjusting the dissipative coupling strength, providing a versatile control knob for chaotic dynamics. This work not only deepens the understanding of nonlinear magnomechanics in open systems but also establishes a practical pathway for harnessing chaos in hybrid quantum technologies, such as secure communication and chaotic information transfer.

Figure (4)  Reference (66)

Catalog

    /

    DownLoad:  Full-Size Img  PowerPoint
    Return
    Return