2026 Volume 35 Issue 4
Article Contents

Shuang Wang, Yu Zhao, Hui-Rong Wang, Yun-He Xing, Xiao-Xin Huo, Jun Zhang. Role of trajectory symmetry in solid high-order harmonic generation[J]. Chinese Physics B, 2026, 35(4): 044204. doi: 10.1088/1674-1056/ae04da
Citation: Shuang Wang, Yu Zhao, Hui-Rong Wang, Yun-He Xing, Xiao-Xin Huo, Jun Zhang. Role of trajectory symmetry in solid high-order harmonic generation[J]. Chinese Physics B, 2026, 35(4): 044204. doi: 10.1088/1674-1056/ae04da

Role of trajectory symmetry in solid high-order harmonic generation

  • Received Date: 30/08/2025
    Accepted Date: 30/08/2025
    Available Online: 01/04/2026
通讯作者: 陈斌, bchen63@163.com
  • 1. 

    沈阳化工大学材料科学与工程学院 沈阳 110142

  1. 本站搜索
  2. 百度学术搜索
  3. 万方数据库搜索
  4. CNKI搜索

Figures(5)

Article Metrics

Article views(254) PDF downloads(0) Cited by(0)

Access History

Role of trajectory symmetry in solid high-order harmonic generation

Abstract: High-order harmonic generation (HHG) from a ZnO crystal has been investigated theoretically using a two-band model driven by a few-cycle laser pulse. We observe that harmonics in the cut-off region exhibit periodic frequency shifts with changes in the carrier envelope phase (CEP) of the laser field. When the CEP of the laser pulse is an integer multiple of π, the cut-off region is dominated by even-order harmonics rather than odd-order harmonics. To illustrate the physical mechanism behind the even-order harmonics, we track the trajectories of electrons and holes between two successive half-cycles by performing time-frequency analysis and applying the recollision model. The results show that the maximum electron displacement is symmetric between successive half-cycles for odd-order harmonics. In contrast, the half-cycle symmetry of the maximum displacement is broken in the case of even-order harmonics.

1.   Introduction
  • High-order harmonic generation (HHG) is a highly nonlinear phenomenon arising from the interaction between intense laser fields and matter. HHG from gases is one of the main sources for generating soft x-ray attosecond pulses and can be applied to probe ultrafast electron dynamics with attosecond time resolution.[1–3] However, the low electron density in gases results in weak harmonic conversion efficiency, which limits their practical applications. Recently, HHG from solids has attracted considerable attention due to its higher conversion efficiency and the possibility of reconstructing the band structure of semiconductors all-optically.[4–9] HHG from solids exhibits a range of novel phenomena, including the field dependence of maximum photon energy,[4,10] multiple plateaus in the harmonic spectrum,[11,12] and complex ellipticity dependence.[13,14] Furthermore, various crystals have been used as target materials to generate high-order harmonics,[15–17] making HHG in solids a hot research topic in recent years.

    The mechanism of HHG in solids can be interpreted in terms of intraband currents and interband polarization.[5] The intraband current arises from the motion of electrons or holes within a single energy band, whereas the interband polarization is similar to atomic HHG and can be described using a recollision model.[5,18,19] In this model, HHG from solids involves three steps: (1) an electron is excited vertically from the top of the valence band (VB) to the conduction band (CB), creating an electron–hole pair; (2) the electron and hole are accelerated within their respective bands by the electric field; (3) the electron recollides with the hole, emitting a harmonic photon with energy determined by the band gap. Based on this model, a linear relationship between the cut-off energy of the harmonics and the electric field intensity can be theoretically established.[20]

    Due to the inversion symmetry of the medium and the time-translation symmetry of the laser pulse, the harmonic spectrum of a solid typically contains only odd-order harmonics.[19–22] In particular, even-order harmonics cannot be directly generated in ZnO using only a two-band model.[23–26] Nevertheless, both odd- and even-order harmonics have been observed experimentally under certain conditions.[27–29] For example, Liu et al.[27] detected even-order harmonics from monolayer MoS2, showing that the anomalous intraband current originating from the Berry curvature is responsible for their generation. Vampa et al.[28] observed even-order harmonics in ZnO driven by a combined linearly polarized laser field. The addition of a second harmonic breaks the symmetry of electron trajectories between successive half-cycles, leading to even-order harmonic generation. Many theoretical studies have also explored the underlying physics of even-order harmonics.[26,30–32] Jia et al.[26] used a multiple-band model to illustrate that even-order harmonics originate from electrons being excited to higher conduction bands in a stepwise process. Jiang et al.[30,31] highlighted the role of the transition dipole phase (TDP) and symmetry breaking, showing that nonzero TDP in a symmetry-broken solid leads to even harmonics. Across these investigations, odd- and even-order harmonics typically appear alternately across the harmonic spectrum.[4,26,28–32]

    In this work, we investigate HHG from ZnO along the Γ–M direction driven by a few-cycle laser pulse. We find that both odd- and even-order harmonics appear when the carrier envelope phase (CEP) of the laser field is an integer multiple of π, with even-order harmonics dominating the cut-off region. By analyzing electron trajectories in real space, we reveal that the asymmetry of electron maximum displacement between successive half-cycles is responsible for the generation of even-order harmonics. The paper is organized as follows: Section 2 describes the theoretical approach, Section 3 presents the simulation results and discussion, and Section 4 concludes the work.

2.   Method
  • Since the time-dependent Schrödinger equation (TDSE) is primarily applied to model solids,[11,33] it cannot fully describe real solid materials. At present, simulations of laser interaction with real solids are mainly performed by solving the semiconductor Bloch equations (SBEs)[19,20,28,34] or using time-dependent density functional theory (TDDFT).[35,36] Approaches such as TDSE and TDDFT, however, do not account for dephasing effects. Therefore, in this work, we employ SBEs within a two-band model to describe the interaction between laser pulses and ZnO crystal. Unless stated otherwise, atomic units are used throughout. The SBEs are given by

    where nm(K,t) is the population of band m (c for conduction band, v for valence band), with all electrons initially in the valence band. Ωmm′ (K, t) = E(t) ⋅ dmm′[K + A(t)] is the polarization strength, where dmm′ is the transition dipole moment.[20] The crystal momentum k is transformed to a moving frame via K = k − A(t),[37] shifting the first Brillouin zone (BZ) to BZ¯=BZ−A(t), with the BZ defined as [−π/a,π/a] and lattice constant a = 5.32 a.u. The classical action is Smm′(K,t)=∫−∞tεmm′[K+A(t′)]dt′, where εmm′ = Em − Em′ is the band energy difference. Following experimental comparison, the dephasing time is set as T2 = 1.375 fs to effectively remove anharmonic contributions in the high-order harmonics.[5,23,25] Different from Ref. [38], the system is not allowed to exchange energy with phonons of lattice defects in this work. Thus, T2 = 1.375 fs is adopted to depict the intrinsic dephasing time of the ZnO crystal.

    The intraband and interband harmonic spectra are obtained by Fourier transform of the corresponding currents

    The ZnO band structure is taken from Refs. [5,20], obtained via ab initio calculations under the local density approximation, with a bandgap Eg = 0.1213 a.u. (3.3 eV) at the Γ point. The laser field is linearly polarized along the Γ–M direction

    where τ is the pulse duration (5 optical cycles), E0 = 0.00342 a.u. (4.1 × 1011 W/cm2), ω0 = 0.014 a.u. (3253 nm), and φ is the CEP. The peak field is below the Bloch field Eb = πω0/a ≈ 0.008 a.u., so excitation to higher conduction bands is neglected.[33]

3.   Results and discussion
  • Figure 1 shows the intraband and interband harmonic spectra for a laser pulse with φ = 0. Odd-order harmonics dominate below the 24th harmonic due to inversion symmetry along the Γ–M direction,[19,20,22] while even-order harmonics (e.g., 24th and 26th) appear near the cut-off region. Solid HHG originates from intraband and interband currents. Intraband harmonics arise from Bloch oscillations and a recollision-like contribution associated with electron–hole polarization. Since intraband harmonics are weaker than interband ones by about four orders of magnitude near the cut-off, we focus primarily on interband harmonics. Unlike previous works where odd- and even-order harmonics appear alternately across the entire spectrum,[26–28] in our case, even-order harmonics appear only near the cut-off. Because the system retains inversion symmetry, the phase of dmm′ is set to zero,[21,39] differing from scenarios with nonzero transition dipole phase that generate even-order harmonics.[30,31] The physical mechanism for this observation warrants further investigation.

    The Bloch oscillation of electrons depends on the vector potential of the driving pulse, i.e., K = k − A(t). Changing the CEP of the laser field alters the waveform of the vector potential, thereby controlling the motion of Bloch electrons and directly modifying their acquired kinetic energy ε (ε ∝ [Ab(t) − Ar(t)]2, where tb and tr denote the birth and recollision times).[40–43] We further investigate the influence of CEP on HHG in both the plateau and cut-off regions. Figure 2(a) shows the CEP dependence of the harmonics in the plateau region (9th–15th harmonics), where the harmonics exhibit negligible dependence on CEP. In contrast, in the cut-off region, the harmonics continuously shift with CEP variation, as presented in Fig. 2(b), indicating that the generation of even-order harmonics is highly sensitive to CEP. Such a distinction between plateau and cut-off regions has also been observed in topological insulators,[41] where it is attributed to the ballistic acceleration of Dirac currents in the topological surface state. As seen in Fig. 2(b), when CEP is a half-integer multiple of π, odd-order harmonics dominate the cut-off region. Conversely, even-order harmonics are generated when CEP is an integer multiple of π. To elucidate the mechanism of even-order harmonic emission, we focus on trajectory analysis for the specific case of φ = 0, which exhibits clear even-order harmonics.

    To gain a deeper physical insight into the even-order harmonics, we present the time-frequency (TF) distribution of HHG through the Morlet wavelet transformation[44] in Fig. 3(a). It can be seen that the generation of harmonics occurs mainly at the center of the laser pulse, with two primary peaks contributing to harmonic generation, marked as P1 and P2, respectively. For harmonics below the 25th order, the short trajectories from P1 and P2 contribute together. However, for harmonics above the 26th order, the emission mainly originates from a single short trajectory of P1. Moreover, Fig. 3(a) shows that the temporal separation between these two bursts increases with harmonic order, resulting in a time delay between successive subcycles during harmonic emission. In the harmonic spectra, this gives rise to peaks separated by slightly less than twice the laser frequency.[40]

    In Ref. [40], the instantaneous energy difference was calculated to understand harmonic emission dynamics. The results indicate that harmonic orders deviate from odd multiples when the vector potential peaks at the envelope maximum. Comparing with Fig. 3(a) in Ref. [40], the instantaneous energy difference agrees with the TF distribution. Furthermore, the energy difference approximately traces the magnitude of the vector potential |A(t)|.[45]

    Figure 3(a) also illustrates the magnitude of the vector potential |A(t)| (magenta dashed lines), used to trace the instantaneous energy difference. A time delay is observed between each emission path and the vector potential, which arises because only the Γ point (k = 0) is considered in TDSE calculations of Ref. [40]. In this work, we investigate HHG in ZnO crystal by solving the SBEs, considering a fully occupied valence band (all crystal momenta within the first BZ). Thus, the mechanism of even-order harmonic generation may differ from that in Ref. [40]. TF analysis of the Γ channel (not shown here) also follows the vector field magnitude, consistent with Ref. [40].

    Figure 3(b) depicts the harmonic orders as a function of birth time and recollision time calculated by the recollision model derived from a fully occupied VB, consistent with Refs. [18–20]. Two main peaks, P1 and P2, contribute to HHG, in agreement with TF analysis from SBEs shown in Fig. 3(a). Peak P2 does not contribute to harmonics above the 25th order, whereas harmonics below the 25th arise from both P1 and P2. The red dotted line in Fig. 3(b) shows the transient CB population. The CB population rapidly increases from t = −0.75 o.c. to t = −0.25 o.c., corresponding to the birth time of P1′, and recombines at t = −0.25 o.c. to t = 0.25 o.c. Similarly, from t = −0.25 o.c. to t = 0.15 o.c., the CB population rises again, corresponding to the birth of P2′, with recombination from 0.25 o.c. to 0.65 o.c.

    To further understand even-order harmonic generation, we analyze electron trajectories between two successive half-cycles using the recollision model.[18,19,46] For all harmonic orders, we set the initial condition at the Γ point (k = 0). Figures 4(a1) and 4(a2) show trajectories of the electron and its associated hole for the 13th harmonic at different birth times tb. In Fig. 4(a1), the electron–hole pair is created at tb = −0.35 o.c. (peak P1′ from Fig. 3(b)), with the electron and hole moving along positive- and negative-X directions, respectively. At tr = −0.05 o.c., the electron recollides with the hole, emitting a harmonic photon. The maximum displacement of the electron is around X = 0.85 a.u. In Fig. 4(a2), the pair is created at tb = 0.15 o.c., recolliding at tr = 0.45 o.c., with maximum displacement X = −0.85 a.u. The electron thus moves symmetrically in positive- and negative-X directions over successive half-cycles. As proposed by Vampa et al.,[47] HHG can be viewed as an array of interferometers, with each arm corresponding to electron–hole trajectories generated in subsequent half-cycles. Equal electron propagation distances lead to constructive interference only for odd-order harmonics, here generating the 13th harmonic.

    Figures 4(b1) and 4(b2) show electron trajectories for the 15th harmonic. The maximum displacements are X = 1.23 a.u. and X = −1.23 a.u., symmetric over successive half-cycles. Compared with the 13th harmonic, the electron gains more energy due to the longer displacement, and the symmetry ensures the generation of the 15th harmonic.

    Figures 4(c1) and 4(c2) illustrate the trajectories of the electron and associated hole for the 24th harmonic between two successive half-cycles. From Fig. 4(c1), the electron–hole pair is created at tb = −0.40 o.c. (peak P1′ in Fig. 3(b)). The electron recollides with its associated hole at tr = 0.08 o.c., with a maximum displacement of X = 3.52 a.u. From Fig. 4(c2), the electron–hole pair is created at tb = 0.09 o.c. (peak P2′ in Fig. 3(b)) and recollides at tr = 0.66 o.c., with a maximum displacement X = −5.17 a.u. in the negative-X direction. The asymmetry of maximum displacement between two successive half-cycles leads to constructive interference for even-order harmonics, e.g., the 24th harmonic, following Eq. (33) in Ref. [47]. Figure 4(d) shows the trajectory of the 26th harmonic, where the electron moves only in the positive-X direction with a maximum displacement of X = 4.93 a.u., confirming that even-order harmonics originate from asymmetric electron trajectories.

    To further elucidate the HHG dynamics, we analyze electron and hole trajectories in k-space using the recollision model.[18] Figures 5(a) and 5(b) depict the k-space trajectories for the 13th harmonic, corresponding to birth times in Figs. 4(a1) and 4(a2). In Fig. 5(a), the electron–hole pair is created at k = 0 (green point), then undergoes Bloch oscillation driven by the laser pulse. At t = t′, the electron and hole pass through k = 0 (red point) and finally recollide at k = −0.12 a.u. (orange point). In Fig. 5(b), the electron recollides at k = 0.12 a.u. (orange point). For odd-order harmonics, the crystal momentum of recollision is symmetric about the Γ point.

    Figure 5(c) shows the k-space trajectory for the 26th harmonic (birth times in Fig. 4(d)). Only a single trajectory contributes, with recollision at k = −0.35 a.u. (pink point), resulting in loss of half-cycle symmetry for even-order harmonics. Figure 5(d) presents the band gap between CB and VB in k-space. The two orange points correspond to the band gap at k = −0.12 a.u. and k = 0.12 a.u. (energy ∼ 4.35 eV, 13th harmonic), while the pink point represents the band gap at k = −0.35 a.u. (energy ∼ 9.91 eV, 26th harmonic).

4.   Conclusion
  • In summary, we investigated the HHG from ZnO crystal within the framework of a two-band model. By tuning the CEP of the incident pulse, we observed even-order harmonics in the cut-off region when the CEP is integer multiples of π. To investigate the electron dynamics of harmonic generation, we analyzed the electron trajectories in real space using the recollision model. It is demonstrated that the even-order harmonic generation is a consequence of the asymmetry of the maximum displacement of the electron between two successive half-cycles. We also analyzed the recollision dynamics of the electron–hole pair in the k-space. The results show that the crystal momentum when the electron recollides with its associated hole is symmetric about the Γ point for odd-order harmonics, while it is asymmetric for even-order harmonics. We expect that our results will contribute to further exploration and understanding of the physical mechanisms of solid HHG.

Figure (5)  Reference (47)

Catalog

    /

    DownLoad:  Full-Size Img  PowerPoint
    Return
    Return