2026 Volume 35 Issue 1
Article Contents

Lin-Sheng Bao, Jia-Yun Ning, Ao-Qian Shi, Peng Peng, Zhen-Nan Wang, Chao Peng, Shuang-Chun Wen, Jian-Jun Liu. Exceptional point-induced knot structure transformations in non-Abelian braids[J]. Chinese Physics B, 2026, 35(1): 010203. doi: 10.1088/1674-1056/ae2265
Citation: Lin-Sheng Bao, Jia-Yun Ning, Ao-Qian Shi, Peng Peng, Zhen-Nan Wang, Chao Peng, Shuang-Chun Wen, Jian-Jun Liu. Exceptional point-induced knot structure transformations in non-Abelian braids[J]. Chinese Physics B, 2026, 35(1): 010203. doi: 10.1088/1674-1056/ae2265

Exceptional point-induced knot structure transformations in non-Abelian braids

  • Received Date: 16/10/2025
    Accepted Date: 19/11/2025
    Available Online: 01/01/2026
通讯作者: 陈斌, bchen63@163.com
  • 1. 

    沈阳化工大学材料科学与工程学院 沈阳 110142

  1. 本站搜索
  2. 百度学术搜索
  3. 万方数据库搜索
  4. CNKI搜索

Figures(5)

Article Metrics

Article views(311) PDF downloads(1) Cited by(0)

Access History

Exceptional point-induced knot structure transformations in non-Abelian braids

Abstract: The strong connection between braids and knots provides valuable insights into studying the topological state and phase classification of various physical systems. The phenomenon of non-Hermitian (NH) two- and three-band braiding has received widespread attention. However, a systematic exploration and visualization of non-Abelian braiding and the associated knot transformations in four-band systems remains unexplored. Here, we propose a theoretical model of NH four-band braiding, provide its phase diagram, and establish its trivial, Abelian, and non-Abelian braiding rules. Additionally, we report on special knots, such as the Hopf and Solomon links in braided knots, and reveal that their transformations are accompanied by and mediated through exceptional points. Our work provides a detailed case for studying NH multiband braiding and knot structures in four-band systems, which could offer insights for topological photonics and analog information processing applications.

1.   Introduction
  • Recently, braiding has played a prominent role in the fields of condensed matter physics,[1–6] topological quantum,[7–11] and machine learning.[12–14] Braiding is a branch of topology and an important tool for characterizing non-Hermitian (NH) band topology.[15–18] The development of NH band theories has significantly broadened and deepened the understanding of traditional Hermitian bands.[19–24] Unlike Hermitian systems, NH bands exhibit abundant winding and braiding topologies in the complex energy–momentum (E–k) space and can be represented by the braid group BN. When N = 2, BN is an Abelian group, whereas when N ≥ 3, BN is a non-Abelian group.[5,15,25–27] Braids and knots are inextricably linked, and knots can be formed by twisting the strings and joining their ends together.[27–29] Knots have rich structures, including unlinks,[12,13] unknots,[15,18] Hopf links,[28–30] and Solomon links.[31,32] It is impossible for different knots to transform into each other through direct continuous deformation unless they experience a transition state featuring one or multiple touch points.[18,33] In NH systems, braiding phenomena and knot structures are characterized by complex eigenvalues and non-orthogonal eigenvectors, which exhibit complex winding evolution phenomena.[34–37] Specifically, the braiding phenomenon is directly related to the encirclement of exceptional points (EPs), where different knot structures can transform into each other through these EPs.[28,29,38,39]

    In NH systems, it has been found both theoretically and experimentally[15,18,34,40,41] that single and double bands can generate complex-energy windings, and double bands exhibit rich braiding structures that can be represented by the braid group B2. However, the braid group B2 is merely a simple Abelian group. The most attractive feature of topological braid groups is the non-Abelian characteristic of higher-order braid groups BN (N ≥ 3).[12,27,42,43] For NH multiband braiding, non-commutative braiding and non-trivial eigenvalue permutations greatly enrich the study of NH band braiding.[5,26,44] Currently, NH three-band braiding and higher-order braid group B3 have been partially studied theoretically and experimentally,[16,27,45] but the study of NH multiband braiding phenomena is still in its infancy. Braiding and knots are inseparable, and NH multiband braiding, while inducing rich braiding phenomena, also increases the complexity and difficulty of distinguishing the various structures of knots. While the general classification of 1D non-Hermitian band braiding by the group BN is well-established,[26–30] a systematic exploration and visualization of non-Abelian braiding and the associated knot transformations in four-band systems remains unexplored. Prior works have pioneered the study of 2-band and 3-band braiding.[28,44] Our work extends this frontier to the four-band case, providing a concrete and comprehensive platform that not only catalogues the achievable braiding phases but also visually bridges the abstract braid group theory, the physical parameter space, and the resulting knot structure transformations.

    In this paper, we propose a one-dimensional (1D) tight-binding model to achieve NH four-band braiding, provide its phase diagram controlled by hopping, and establish its trivial, Abelian, and non-Abelian braiding rules, which can be represented by the braid group B4. By studying the knot structures corresponding to the phase diagram, we discover special knots, such as the Hopf link and Solomon links, and reveal the intrinsic connection between the braiding degrees of the phase diagram and the knots. Furthermore, by studying the continuous phase transitions in the phase diagram, we find evidence for the occurrence of transformations between different knots induced by EPs.

2.   Model and theory
  • In NH multiband systems with nonreciprocal hopping, the NH bands experience topological braiding induced by nonreciprocal hopping as well as phase transitions when they cross boundary lines. Based on previous theoretical studies on NH band braiding and knot structures,[27,45,46] we propose a 1D NH tight-binding model that can be used to study NH four-band braiding. Taking m = 1 and n = 2 as an example, we illustrate the phase diagram of this NH four-band braid in Fig. 1.

    The 1D NH tight-binding model shown in Fig. 1(a) consists of a unit cell that includes four atomic sites (with zero on-site energy). The neighboring atomic sites are coupled by the reciprocal intracell hopping t0, and the two nonreciprocal intercell hoppings tm and tn represent the long-range hoppings that span m and n unit cells, respectively. The Hamiltonian can be expressed as

    To study NH four-band braiding, we introduce an integer topological invariant υ to represent the braiding degree of the NH bands,[15,18] which is expressed as

    where E˜i,j=[Ei(k)−Ej(k)]/2(i≠j).

    Therefore, we can classify different braiding types according to the braiding degrees and encapsulate them in a phase diagram controlled by intracell and intercell hoppings. For convenience, we set t0 = 1 so that the phase diagram is completely controlled by the intercell hoppings tm and tn. Our work focuses on showing the phase diagram and the corresponding band braiding for m = 1 and n = 2, as shown in Fig. 1(b) (see Section A of the supplementary material[47] for the details of its derivation). According to the phase diagram in Fig. 1(b), we can achieve NH band braiding with a specific braiding degree by selecting appropriate values of tm and tn. It should be noted that during the braiding process, the momentum k must evolve over a complete period, i.e., k ∈ [k0, k0 + 2π]. The braiding process depends on the initial momentum k0. Considering the positions where the NH bands experience swapping, in order to better present the braiding characteristics of the bands in complex E–k space, we assume k0 = π/4 in this work.

3.   Results and discussion
  • Firstly, the NH four-band braid belongs to the fundamental braid group B4 (see Section B of the supplementary material[47] for the details of the definition and characteristics of the braid group B4). We can represent the braiding relations mentioned in this work using a combination of the basic elements σ1, σ2, and σ3 in the braid group B4. Next, based on the phase diagram shown in Fig. 1(b), we introduce the NH band braiding phenomenon corresponding to different braiding degrees and summarize its braiding characteristics, as shown in Fig. 2.

    Similarly, when υ = 2, the four bands are braided twice, but there are two different types of braiding processes (related to the phase diagram in Fig. 1(b)). (1) The bands E2 and E3 are braided twice, resulting in [E1, E2, E3, E4] → [E1, E2, E3, E4], with the corresponding braid being represented by σ2σ2, as shown in Fig. 2(c). (2) The pairs of bands E1/E2 and E3/E4 are braided once each, resulting in [E1, E2, E3, E4] → [E2, E1, E4, E3], with the corresponding braid being represented by σ1σ3, as shown in Fig. 2(d). Although the three types of braiding processes in Figs. 2(b)–2(d) yield different results, essentially, they can be regarded as simple Abelian braiding processes involving only two bands. After two continuous identical braiding processes, the eigenvalue permutation returns to the initial state. However, non-Abelian braiding occurs when the number of bands involved in the braiding exceeds two. For example, when υ = 3, the four bands are braided three times. Like for the case with υ = 2, also in this case there are two different types of braiding processes, as illustrated in Figs. 2(e) and 2(f). Unlike for the two types of braiding processes for the case with υ = 2, which have different braid group elements, both types of braiding processes for the case with υ = 3 are represented by the same braid group elements σ1, σ2, and σ3, with the braids being σ2σ1σ3 and σ1σ3σ2 in Figs. 2(e) and 2(f), respectively. Similarly, when υ = 4, the increase in braiding degree merely results in the addition of another braid group element, namely, σ2, which still exhibits non-Abelian braiding characteristics, as shown in Figs. 2(g) and 2(h). Therefore, different braid orders result in different eigenvalue permutations, ultimately giving rise to non-Abelian braids. Importantly, the above discussion sheds light on the relationship between braiding degree and braid group. Specifically, the braiding degree matches the number of braid group elements, e.g., for υ = 3, there are three corresponding braid group elements, namely, σ2, σ1, and σ3, as shown in Fig. 2(e).

    In the same phase diagram, the two different types of braiding processes corresponding to the same braiding degree are related to the distribution of EPs in the NH four-band eigenenergy spectrum. In other words, NH four-band braiding is directly related to the evolution paths of the four bands encircling the EPs. Next, we discuss braiding and nontrivial eigenvalue swapping by studying the encirclement of EPs on Riemann surfaces.[48,49] We replace the k-space Hamiltonian H(k) in Eq. (1) with a parameter-space Hamiltonian H(cos(k), sin(k)) governed by cos(k) and sin(k).[15,50] After transformation, the momentum k can be mapped to a unit circle described by (cos(k), sin(k)), i.e., cos(k)2 + sin(k)2 = 1. Now, we select four cases from Fig. 2 with υ = 0 (Fig. 2(a)), υ = 2 (Fig. 2(c)), υ = 3 (Fig. 2(e)), and υ = 4 (Fig. 2(g)) to illustrate the evolution of the eigenvalues on the Riemann surface corresponding to different braiding phenomena, as shown in Fig. 3.

    The parameter-space Hamiltonian H(cos(k), sin(k)) defines the four planes that constitute the Riemann surface shown in Fig. 3. The eigenvalues evolve along different paths on the Riemann surface as the momentum k changes, and their projection onto the cos(k)–sin(k) plane clearly shows the eigenvalue evolution paths crossing the EPs and their branch cuts. Note that due to the distribution of EPs in complex E–k space, there are cases where the projections of two EPs overlap in this plane: In Figs. 3(b) and 3(d), the red dot 1 and red line 1 represent the projections of EP1 and EP5, along with their branch cuts, and the red dot 3 and red line 3 represent the projections of EP2 and EP6, along with their branch cuts. In Fig. 3(c), the red dot 2 and red line 2 represent the projections of EP1 and EP3, along with their branch cuts. Different braiding degrees correspond to different evolution paths of the bands encircling the EPs, leading to different eigenvalue permutations.[36,37] In Fig. 3(a), the eigenvalues are not swapped since the evolution paths do not cross the EPs, which corresponds to the independent and trivial evolution of the four bands illustrated in Fig. 2(a) for υ = 0. By contrast, when the evolution paths of the bands encircle the EPs, it is inevitable that the branch cuts cross on the Riemann surface, which leads to the eigenvalues being swapped. As shown in Fig. 3(b), the evolution paths of the bands sequentially cross the branch cut red lines 4 and 2, encircling two EPs (EP3 and EP4). The eigenvalues change from [E1, E2, E3, E4] to [E1, E3, E2, E4] and then back to [E1, E2, E3, E4], which corresponds to the braid σ2σ2 displayed in Fig. 2(c). Similarly, in Figs. 3(c) and 3(d), the evolution paths of the bands encircle three EPs (EP1, EP2, and EP3) and four EPs (EP3, EP4, EP2, and EP6) in sequence, resulting in three and four braids, respectively. These braids correspond to Figs. 2(e) and 2(g), respectively. Thus, NH band braiding is closely related to the evolution paths of the bands encircling the EPs, and the number of EPs encircled determines the value of the braiding degree υ.

  • NH band braiding is accompanied by the emergence of knot structures. The NH band braiding discussed in this work is based on the evolution of the momentum k over one period. However, if the ends of the braided bands are connected, their knot structures can be determined. Taking the braiding example with υ = 4 in Fig. 2(g), we demonstrate how the knot structures are generated, and we summarize the transitions corresponding to different braiding degrees shown in the phase diagram of Fig. 1(b), as presented in Fig. 4.

    In Fig. 4(a), the left subfigure shows NH four-band braiding with υ = 4, which is represented by the braid σ2σ2σ1σ3. To illustrate the transition from band braiding to a knot, we have added additional auxiliary lines to the diagram of the braid represented by σ2σ2σ1σ3, as shown in the middle subfigure of Fig. 4(a). We use two different lines (of different gray colors) to connect the ends of the bands where the evolution finishes, eventually forming a knot. Lines of the same color indicate that a ring can be formed after connection. For example, the light-gray lines connect the ends of the red and blue braiding bands, which thus form a ring; this ring is then combined with the ring formed by the yellow and green braiding bands (connected by the dark-gray lines) to give rise to a Hopf link, as shown in the right subfigure of Fig. 4(a). Thus, in NH multiband systems, by utilizing auxiliary lines, one or multiple bands collectively form a ring, and then the individual rings wind around each other to form a unique knot.[15,28]

    Based on the phase diagram with m = 1 and n = 2 shown in Fig. 1(b), we study the knot structures corresponding to each braiding degree, as shown in Fig. 4(b). When υ = 0, due to the trivial braiding, the four bands evolve independently, and the resulting knots are four separate rings, known as unlinks. However, with increasing braiding degree, the obtained knot constantly changes. From υ = 0 to υ = 6, the braided knot transforms from the initial four separate rings, which are unlinks, through continuous evolution, to a final complex knot structure, known as the Solomon link. Simultaneously, during this process, other knots appear, such as an unknot for υ = 3, and a Hopf link for υ = 4. For a given phase diagram, the knot structures obtained through band braiding can vary continuously with the braiding degree, enabling continuous transitions between different knots.

    Next, we clarify the nature of transformations between different knot structures for a given phase diagram. We select five representative cases on the black dashed line in the phase diagram of Fig. 1(b) to analyze and explain the transformations between the knot structures, as shown in Fig. 5.

    We change the evolution of momentum k and transform the band from the complex E–k space braiding to a two-dimensional (2D) knot structure (see Section D of the supplementary material[47] for the details of the complex E–k space braiding). The NH four-band braiding in stages ①, ③, and ⑤ in Fig. 5 corresponds to a Hopf link, Solomon link, and Hopf link, respectively, which is consistent with the knot structures obtained for υ = 4 and υ = 6 in Fig. 4. Next, we analyze the knot structure transformation in the transition state, taking the transformation from stage ① (Hopf link) to stage ③ (Solomon link) as an example (indicated by the blue arrow in Fig. 5). From the phase diagram in Fig. 1(b), we can observe that during the transition from stage ① to stage ③, the nonreciprocal hopping t2 remains constant, while t1 changes continuously and crosses the boundary line where stage ② is located. In Fig. 5, stage ② serves as a transition state from stage ① to stage ③, featuring two degenerate points, namely, EP1 and EP2. Therefore, the essence of the transformation from stage ① to stage ③ is the braided phase transition of NH bands when the nonreciprocal hopping t1 crosses EPs. Similarly, there are two degenerate points in stage ④, namely, EP3 and EP4. The phase transition in this case also occurs when the nonreciprocal hopping t1 crosses these two EPs. The nonreciprocal hopping t1 in stages ② and ④ crosses different EPs, resulting in different ways in which the bands in stages ① and ⑤ can be connected, although both result in the formation of Hopf links. Although stages ② and ④ in Fig. 5 do not give rise to any special knot, they are key evidence demonstrating the transformations of the knot structures. Not only can this prove that the value of υ is related to the number of times the EPs are encircled (consistent with the conclusion in Fig. 3), but it can also indicate that the boundary lines of the phase diagram are composed of different numbers of EPs (consistent with the conclusion in Section A of the supplementary material[47]). Additionally, if we change the transformation direction in Fig. 5 so that stage ⑤ continuously evolves to stage ① (along the direction of the red arrow), the above conclusions are still valid because the encircling EPs are the same. Therefore, our work provides evidence that transformations between different knot structures are induced by EPs.

4.   Conclusion
  • In summary, we presented a systematic investigation of NH four-band braiding, provided its phase diagram, and established its trivial, Abelian, and non-Abelian braiding rules, which can be represented by the braid group B4. Additionally, we discovered special knots, such as the Hopf and Solomon links, by showing the knot structures corresponding to different braids and unveiled that the transitions between these distinct knot structures occur at parameter boundaries defined by exceptional points. Our results provide a concrete and visualizable platform for the study of NH multiband braiding and the non-Abelian characteristics of higher-order braid groups. The controllable manipulation of topological knots via system parameters may inspire novel approaches in topological photonic devices and classical information processing schemes based on topological invariants. For instance, in topological photonics, such EP-driven knot transformations could be leveraged to design reconfigurable optical devices[51] or switching schemes[52] where the knot type serves as a robust topological state variable. Furthermore, the principles of our 1D tight-binding model are not limited to four bands. The approach can be generalized to systems with N > 4 bands, where the braid group BN exhibits even richer non-Abelian structures. Exploring these higher-band systems could uncover more complex knots and braiding phenomena, offering a fertile ground for future theoretical and experimental work in topological metamaterials.

    The proposed 1D NH tight-binding model is amenable to experimental implementation in several advanced platforms. For example, photonic waveguide arrays[53] offer precise control over hopping amplitudes and engineered losses, providing an ideal setting to map our Hamiltonian and directly observe the complex energy braids and their associated knot structures. Similarly, synthetic dimension lattices implemented in photonic systems or with ultracold atoms[15,16,54] can emulate the multi-band tight-binding dynamics and probe the requisite momentum-space topology. Additionally, acoustic or electrical circuit networks have emerged as versatile and highly controllable testbeds for non-Hermitian physics[18,27–29,36,55] and could be tailored to realize the non-reciprocal hopping terms and detect the knot structure transformations predicted in our work.

Figure (5)  Reference (55)

Catalog

    /

    DownLoad:  Full-Size Img  PowerPoint
    Return
    Return