HTML
-
Soft magnetic materials are a type of material that can rapidly respond to changes in external magnetic fields and achieve high magnetic induction intensity with low loss.[1] Due to their high sensitivity and low energy consumption, soft magnetic materials are widely used and currently include the largest variety of magnetic materials, including metallic soft magnetic materials, ferrite soft magnetic materials, and amorphous/nanocrystalline soft magnetic materials.[2–4] Metallic soft magnetic materials are often used in applications requiring high-efficiency magnetic properties, such as transformers, inductors, magnetic sensors, antennas, and wireless charging devices. However, the more severe skin effect and eddy current loss caused by their low resistivity limit their applications in the high-frequency band. Therefore, soft magnetic ferrite materials with higher resistivity are promising due to their superior high-frequency characteristics.[1] Although higher operating frequencies enable compact designs, high specific losses force designers to select lower operating flux densities, usually only 0.3–0.5 T, which increases the required volume and is not conducive to device miniaturization.[5,6] This limitation restricts their applications in fields requiring high magnetic flux density and high power.[5] Amorphous and nanocrystalline alloys are mostly formed as thin strips, which limits their compatibility in terms of shape and volume.[7] However, when fabricated into bulk forms, the relatively high eddy current loss also limits their applications, not to mention the relatively low saturation magnetization of nanocrystalline and amorphous soft magnetic materials. With the development of wide-band-gap semiconductor technology, it is becoming increasingly difficult for soft magnetic materials to meet the requirements for high resonant frequency and device miniaturization.[8–11]
In view of this, we aim to prepare soft magnetic composites with high permeability, high cutoff frequency, and low loss. Among these parameters, the cutoff frequency determines the frequency range over which magnetic materials can operate normally.[1] Generally, the working frequency of ferromagnetic materials cannot exceed the resonance frequency, because the largest energy loss occurs at resonance, as observed in magnetic spectrum curves. Thus, the natural resonance frequency is also called the cutoff frequency. For materials with uniaxial anisotropy, there is a competitive relationship between permeability and natural resonance frequency, which can be described by Snoek’s limit.[12] For a material with uniaxial anisotropy, Snoek’s limit can be expressed as
where μi is the initial permeability, fr is the natural resonance frequency, γ is the gyromagnetic ratio, and Ms is the saturation magnetization. In other words, due to Snoek’s limit, for a given magnetic material, it is impossible to increase the initial permeability and the natural resonance frequency simultaneously. However, for soft magnetic composites with easy-plane structures, the Snoek’s limit can be overcome,[13] which can be described by
Here, Hθ and Hφ are the out-of-plane and in-plane anisotropy fields of the material, respectively. From Eq. (2), it can be seen that if the out-of-plane anisotropy of the material is much greater than its in-plane anisotropy, larger μi and fr can be obtained simultaneously. Generally, planar anisotropy can be realized in two ways. One is that some materials with intrinsic magnetic crystal anisotropy can produce an easily magnetized surface, whose out-of-plane anisotropy is greater than the in-plane anisotropy. The other is that, due to shape anisotropy, the out-of-plane demagnetizing field of sheet magnetic materials is usually larger than the in-plane field, resulting in an easily magnetized surface.
Based on this, Y2Co17 alloys are selected for investigation owing to their intrinsic magnetocrystalline anisotropy, which makes them planar-anisotropic materials. Furthermore, once the Y2Co17 alloys are ground into sheets, their out-of-plane anisotropy field becomes the synergistic consequence of the magnetocrystalline anisotropy field and the shape anisotropy field. Thus, the right side of Eq. (2) would increase, and, promisingly, higher operating frequency and initial permeability can be obtained simultaneously.
To date, the main methods for synthesizing rare-earth alloys are metallothermic reduction and molten-salt electrolysis.[14] Light rare-earth metals such as La, Ce, Pr, and Nd are usually produced by molten salt electrolysis for economic and energy-efficiency reasons. The metallothermic reduction method is more suitable for synthesizing heavy rare-earth metals with higher melting and boiling points (Gd, Tb, and Y, etc.).[15] In this paper, the heavy rare-earth alloy Y2Co17 was prepared by the reduction-diffusion method. The reduction-diffusion method reduces metal oxides to metals at one temperature and then allows them to react with Fe, Co, Ni, and other elements at another temperature to form the desired alloy.[16,17] It possesses several advantages as follows. First, it uses cheaper rare-earth oxides as raw materials instead of rare-earth metals, thus greatly reducing cost. Besides, it reduces pollution during smelting and homogenization and makes it easier to control the phase purity of the product.
In addition, metallic soft magnets inevitably exhibit eddy-current effects. Therefore, the cutoff frequency of Y2Co17 is affected by eddy currents. To increase the cutoff frequency, it is necessary to fabricate uniform, micron-sized soft magnetic composite (SMC) particles.[18,19] The advantage of the reduction-diffusion method is that the particle size can be controlled by adjusting the size of the raw material particles, thus enabling the preparation of smaller particles to reduce the skin effect and improve the cutoff frequency.[18,19] In this work, the reduction-diffusion technique was employed to prepare Y2Co17 particles with several-micron sizes and improved uniformity, thereby enhancing the cutoff frequency of the SMCs.
-
During the experiment, the raw materials were commercially available Y2O3 powder (purity > 99.9%), metallic Co, and Ca particles.
The chemical reaction equation for the preparation of Y2Co17 alloy by the reduction-diffusion method is shown in
Y2O3 powder (purity > 99.9%), metallic Co particles, and Ca particles were calculated and weighed according to the stoichiometric ratio of Eq. (3) for mixing. To compensate for potential volatilization losses during the reaction and ensure smooth progress, Y2O3 was weighed with a 5% excess, and excess Ca was added to ensure complete reduction. After completing the above steps, the powder was mixed in a three-dimensional mixer for 4 hours and pressed into a column weighing approximately 25 g. To prevent oxidation of the raw materials, the mixing process was performed under an argon atmosphere. The column was placed in an iron can and transferred to a vacuum tube furnace for reduction and diffusion. The iron can was sealed with CaO to prevent molten Ca leakage and avoid affecting the operation of the tube furnace. A mechanical pump was used to evacuate the system. During the tube furnace program, the temperature was first raised to 120 °C and maintained for a certain period, after which argon gas was introduced. Reduction-diffusion sintering was performed in an argon atmosphere by heating the sample to 880 °C and holding at this temperature for 4 hours. Subsequently, the temperature was increased to the diffusion temperature of 1080 °C and maintained for 8 hours for diffusion treatment. The sample was cooled in the furnace under an argon atmosphere to room temperature to obtain Y2Co17 containing CaO. The prepared sample was roughly ground in a vacuum glove box, passed through a 200-mesh sieve, and then repeatedly washed with deionized water and ammonium acetate solution to obtain pure Y2Co17 rare-earth soft magnetic powder. The drugs and equipment used in this experiment are listed in Tables 1 and 2.
Flaky particles with a high aspect ratio (large lateral size relative to thickness) and pronounced morphological anisotropy can improve the magnetic permeability and cutoff frequency of Y2Co17 magnetic powder. To obtain Y2Co17 magnetic powder with a sheet-like particle morphology and improved magnetic properties, the powder was further ball-milled using a planetary ball mill. Ethanol was used as the grinding medium, and zirconia beads were used as the milling media. The ball mill speed was set to 400 r/min. The ball-milling time and ball-to-material ratio were selected as the experimental variables. Because the sintered powder contained CaO, ammonium acetate solution was used to remove CaO and obtain single-phase Y2Co17. Subsequently, the cleaned powder was dried in a vacuum drying oven and passed through a 200-mesh sieve to obtain Y2Co17 rare-earth alloy powder. X-ray diffraction (XRD) and scanning electron microscopy (SEM) were used to characterize the crystal structure and microstructure of Y2Co17. The hysteresis loop of Y2Co17 magnetic powder was measured using a vibrating sample magnetometer (the accuracy of the measured saturation magnetization was 1 × 10−6 emu) to determine the saturation magnetization and coercivity. To measure the magnetic properties, the Y2Co17 powder was formed into a toroidal (ring-shaped) sample. Because Y2Co17 powder lacks binding properties, epoxy resin was used as a binder. The milled powder was dried in a vacuum drying oven at 60 °C for 24 h and then mixed evenly with epoxy resin at a specified ratio using ultrasonication. After drying in a fume hood for 12 h, the composite was pressed using a tablet press at 10 MPa for 5 min and then at 20 MPa for 15 min to form dense discs. Subsequently, a Y2Co17/epoxy soft magnetic composite ring with an inner diameter of 7 mm and an outer diameter of 13 mm was fabricated using a mold. Finally, the permeability of the Y2Co17/epoxy soft magnetic composite ring was measured using an impedance analyzer. By analyzing the x-ray diffraction pattern, hysteresis loop, SEM image, and magnetic permeability spectrum of Y2Co17 magnetic powder, the optimum milling conditions for achieving excellent shape anisotropy and high cutoff frequency were determined.
-
The crystal structure of Y2Co17 powders ball-milled for 2 h, 4 h, and 6 h was characterized by the XRD method, and the corresponding results are shown in Fig. 1. Y2Co17 powder with 0 h milling represents the sample without ball milling. The results demonstrate that the diffraction peak positions of the Y2Co17 magnetic powder after ball milling are essentially consistent with those of the standard JCPDS card for Y2Co17 (No. 18-0434); however, the diffraction peak intensities are slightly reduced, and no obvious impurity peaks are observed. Meanwhile, the peak width of the main diffraction peak changes slightly when the milling time is increased from 4 h to 6 h. The above phenomenon is consistent with the potential XRD changes induced by internal stress. Microstrain and crystal defects are introduced as a result of internal stress. The diffraction peak width increases because the interplanar spacing is widened, while the diffraction intensity decreases because the crystal integrity is destroyed.
Figure 2 shows the static hysteresis loops of Y2Co17 magnetic powder after ball milling for different times. The saturation magnetizations of Y2Co17 powder milled for 2 h, 4 h, and 6 h are 0.9661 × 106 A/m, 0.9650 × 106 A/m, and 0.9647 × 106 A/m, respectively (Table 3). Compared with the test accuracy of the experimental equipment, the obtained data show only slight changes, which confirms the reliability of the data. However, this slight decrease is more likely attributable to the incorporation of partially non-magnetic zirconia powder into Y2Co17 during the ball milling process. Furthermore, the increase in coercivity of Y2Co17 magnetic powder after ball milling may be related to internal stresses and defects introduced during the ball milling process.[20] The defects pin domain walls during the magnetization process, increasing the resistance to domain-wall motion and thus leading to decreased magnetic permeability and increased coercivity.[20] This explains the sharp increase in coercivity to over 200 Oe.
SEM was used to characterize the microscopic morphology of Y2Co17 magnetic powder before and after ball milling for different times, and the results are shown in Fig. 3. The formation and evolution of flaky structures can partially reflect changes in the shape anisotropy of Y2Co17. When the sample is not ball-milled, the particle morphology is basically spherical and more regular than that of the ball-milled samples, and no flaky structures appear. At a milling time of 2 h, the Y2Co17 powder shows agglomeration with irregular particle shapes. As the milling time increases, some particles form flaky structures, while agglomerated clusters remain, resulting in the coexistence of particles and flakes at different milling times. However, clumps still remain, leading to the coexistence of particles and aggregates. When the milling time is increased to 6 h, the Y2Co17 powder becomes predominantly granular, and the agglomerates are largely dispersed. This is because the flaky structures are further broken into granules, and the resulting particle size is smaller than that after 2 h of ball milling.
Y2Co17/epoxy composites with a volume fraction of 33% were prepared by mixing Y2Co17 magnetic powder samples and epoxy resin, respectively. Figure 4 shows the magnetic spectrum variation of Y2Co17/epoxy composites over the 1 MHz–1 GHz band. As the alternating magnetic field frequency increases, the real part of the permeability gradually decreases, while the imaginary part initially increases and then decreases. This behavior reflects the dispersion and absorption characteristics of permeability.[1] When the imaginary part of the permeability reaches its maximum, the magnetic loss also reaches its maximum, and the corresponding frequency is the cutoff frequency of the magnetic material.[21] The cutoff frequencies of Y2Co17 powder milled for 2 h, 4 h, and 6 h are 57.95 MHz, 171.75 MHz, and 31.62 MHz, respectively. Based on the above results, it can be concluded that the cutoff frequency first increases and then decreases with increasing milling time. Among them, the Y2Co17/epoxy sample milled for 4 h formed partially flaky particles with good shape anisotropy, and its cutoff frequency was the highest among all samples, reaching nearly 200 MHz. It should be noted that these frequencies were obtained at a ball-to-material ratio of 10:1 for all samples. It is also worth noting that the real part of the permeability falls below 1 at certain frequencies, likely due to the high magnetic anisotropy of rare-earth cobalt intermetallic compounds. Furthermore, core loss is a critical parameter for practical applications and can be deduced from the permeability spectrum according to[22]
Therefore, comparison of the imaginary part of the permeability in the magnetic spectrum reveals that Y2Co17 milled for 4 h exhibits the lowest power loss below the cutoff frequency.
-
As one of the most important working parameters of ball milling, the ball-to-material ratio directly affects the grinding efficiency. Only with an appropriate ball-to-material ratio can the grinding media be effectively involved in the grinding process, fully enabling the impact and shear interactions between the grinding media and the material.[23–25] To determine the appropriate ball-to-material ratio, the Y2Co17 magnetic powder was ball-milled at ball-to-material ratios of 5:1, 10:1, 25:1, and 40:1, respectively.
The XRD results of the material after ball milling show the XRD patterns of Y2Co17 magnetic powder ball-milled with different ball-to-material ratios (Fig. 5). The results show that the diffraction peak positions of Y2Co17 magnetic powder after ball milling are essentially consistent with those of the standard JCPDS card (No. 18-0434), indicating that the crystal structure of Y2Co17 remains unchanged after ball milling and that the material retains good crystallinity. The primary diffraction peaks of the sample with a ball-to-material ratio of 25:1 exhibit reduced intensity and increased broadening. This is likely due to the increased structural homogeneity of the material during the ball milling process.
Figure 6 shows the static hysteresis loop of Y2Co17 magnetic powder at different ball-to-material ratios. The results show that too large or too small a ball-to-material ratio will affect the milling efficiency and thereby affect the saturation magnetization. Only an appropriate ball-to-material ratio can ensure that Y2Co17 powder maintains good soft magnetic properties, that is, high saturation magnetization and low coercivity. Specifically, with the gradual increase of the ball-to-material ratio, the saturation magnetization of Y2Co17 magnetic powder initially increases, as shown in Fig. 6. After ball milling, at a ball-to-material ratio of 25:1, the saturation magnetization of Y2Co17 magnetic powder reaches the maximum value of 0.9937 × 106 A/m. However, when the ball-to-material ratio is 40:1, the saturation magnetization of Y2Co17 particles decreases to 0.9345 × 106 A/m. Meanwhile, the coercivity of Y2Co17 magnetic powder decreases with increasing ball-to-material ratio. The results are shown in Table 4.
As the ball-to-material ratio increases, the saturation magnetization first increases and then decreases. In fact, a higher ball-to-material ratio indicates more frequent collisions between balls and between balls and the material. When the ratio increases from 5:1 to 25:1, the mechanical alloying effect during ball milling leads to an increase in saturation magnetization.[26,27] However, when the ratio further increases to 40:1, the increased collision frequency may cause abrasion of the zirconia grinding balls, contaminating the Y2Co17 sample and resulting in a decrease in saturation magnetization. Therefore, the saturation magnetization of Y2Co17 powder at a ball-to-material ratio of 5:1 is low, and its soft magnetic properties are also poor. The ball-milled Y2Co17 sample at a ball-to-material ratio of 25:1 exhibits high saturation magnetization, but its coercivity is also high, which adversely affects its soft magnetic properties. The sample at a ball-to-material ratio of 40:1 is also limited by low saturation magnetization and poor soft magnetic properties. Only at the appropriate ball-to-material ratio of 10:1 does Y2Co17 magnetic powder exhibit optimally low coercivity and high saturation magnetization, resulting in the best soft magnetic properties.
Figure 7 shows SEM micrographs of Y2Co17 magnetic powder after ball milling for 4 h at different ball-to-material ratios. At the ball-to-material ratio of 5:1, the Y2Co17 powder contains predominantly large particles and few flaky particles, with an average particle size below 5 μm. When the ball-to-material ratio increased to 10:1, the Y2Co17 magnetic powder exhibited a pronounced flaky structure, with particle sizes mainly distributed between 5–7 μm, and the thickness-to-diameter ratio was relatively small. Because Y2Co17 is relatively brittle, increasing the ball-to-material ratio to 25:1 and 40:1 results in particles that are again irregular in shape, which may be attributed to the higher ball-to-material ratio. In fact, a higher ball-to-material ratio indicates more frequent collisions between the balls and the powder. As the ratio increases, the flaky particles are further fragmented into irregular particles by high-frequency impacts; this change in particle morphology may affect eddy-current behavior. Under high-frequency conditions, eddy-current losses suppress magnetic moment rotation, leading to a significant reduction in resonance frequency. Therefore, the cutoff frequency of the Y2Co17 sample with a ball-to-material ratio of 25:1 is expected to be reduced. The magnetic-spectrum results shown in Fig. 8 support this interpretation.
To investigate the effect of changes in the ball-to-material ratio on the high-frequency performance of Y2Co17, we measured the complex permeability spectrum of a Y2Co17/epoxy composite as a function of frequency using an impedance analyzer from 1 MHz to 1 GHz. The impedance-analyzer results in Fig. 8 show that, with the Y2Co17 volume fraction held at 33% and samples ball-milled for 4 h at different ball-to-material ratios, the real part of the complex permeability (μ′) of the Y2Co17/epoxy composite is about 2.6, and both μ′ and the imaginary part (μ″) gradually decrease with increasing frequency.
Based on the imaginary part of the complex permeability, the cutoff frequencies of the samples with ball-to-material ratios of 40:1 and 5:1 are 28.51 MHz and 56.88 MHz, respectively. For the 25:1 ball-to-material ratio, the cutoff frequency of the Y2Co17/epoxy composite is low, only 7.16 MHz, likely due to magnetostatic interactions and particle shape. As shown in Fig. 7, at a ball-to-material ratio of 10:1, the Y2Co17/epoxy composite exhibits pronounced flaky particles with strong shape anisotropy, which increases the equivalent field of out-of-plane anisotropy and thus raises the cutoff frequency to nearly 170 MHz. Furthermore, the Y2Co17 sample with a ball-to-material ratio of 10:1 also features the lowest power loss, as evidenced by its minimal imaginary part of the permeability prior to the cutoff frequency.
In fact, the cutoff frequency of the sample with a ball-to-material ratio of 10:1 is very close to that of the sample ball-milled for 4 h. This is because the ball-to-material ratio that yields the highest cutoff frequency is the same as the ratio used in the experiments investigating the effect of milling time on the cutoff frequency.
3.1. Influence of milling time
3.2. The influence of the ball-to-material ratios
-
In summary, based on the idea that combining the magnetocrystalline anisotropy of Y2Co17 powder with the shape anisotropy of flaky particles can increase the cutoff frequency of Y2Co17, we synthesized Y2Co17 powder by the reduction-diffusion method and determined the conditions for increasing its cutoff frequency. We studied the effects of milling time and ball-to-material ratio on the crystal structure and magnetic properties of Y2Co17 powder. Under identical processing conditions, both the milling time and ball-to-material ratio play essential roles in determining the powder’s soft magnetic properties. The experimental results show that, at a ball milling time of 4 h and a ball-to-material ratio of 10:1, the material exhibits pronounced shape anisotropy, and the cutoff frequency of the Y2Co17/epoxy composite increases to approximately 170 MHz.
首页
登录
注册


DownLoad: